KatyPrismSpirit Posted Monday at 11:34 AM Posted Monday at 11:34 AM 1 minute ago, GraceRandolph said: Critics still praised her performance in Joker though? It was salty ATRL gays who blamed Gaga for Todd's poor creative decisions despite Gaga being highlighted as the standout of Joker 2. Well critical reception and commerical performance are two seperate things. You asked why her acting success is being diminished and I pointed out that this started to take off during Joker 2 because the movie performed very poorly. It's not a surprise that the commercial performance of a movie she was the lead actress in would be used as a means to diminish her as well. If Joker 2 made $1.6B in the box-office nobody would diminish Lady Gaga's acting success. 1
Jay07 Posted Monday at 11:36 AM Posted Monday at 11:36 AM Jealousy from fans of far less talented artists and this weird obsession with trying to troll Gaga fans, like it's absurd. That Golden Globes thread had like 5 pages by haters in an hour, were they just watching the show waiting for a Gaga dig? 5
K$Ellie Posted Monday at 11:42 AM Posted Monday at 11:42 AM she literally has one successful role that was a remake of an already popular movie why do monsters exaggerate every bit of success she has 1 10 13
OrgVisual Posted Monday at 11:45 AM Posted Monday at 11:45 AM More like Liddos exaggerated Gaga's success and acted like she's one of the best actresses of all time Are we pretending to forget all the "Oscar" threads whenever she announced a new role? 3 10 1 5
GraceRandolph Posted Monday at 11:46 AM Author Posted Monday at 11:46 AM 1 minute ago, K$Ellie said: she literally has one successful role that was a remake of an already popular movie why do monsters exaggerate every bit of success she has The successful iteration of ASIB came out in 1954? Barely anyone who saw ASIB 2018 had probably seen it, the Streisand movie was not well received. This argument is so dumb. Are y'all saying the same about Ariana playing a role that was already popularized by Kristen Chenoweth? 1
GraceRandolph Posted Monday at 11:46 AM Author Posted Monday at 11:46 AM Just now, OrgVisual said: Are we pretending to forget all the "Oscar" threads whenever she announced a new role? The threads like 50% of working actors get on ATRL you mean?
Mordecai Posted Monday at 11:46 AM Posted Monday at 11:46 AM Her career shows a lot of success and promise... until you check her filmography and realise she's only done a small handful of roles. I'm not sure what there is to hype about a career that's only had two credits in the last five years, one of which was a box office failure 1 1
enchanted0 Posted Monday at 11:50 AM Posted Monday at 11:50 AM Her success and tankery canceled each other out 2 1 7
Jay07 Posted Monday at 11:51 AM Posted Monday at 11:51 AM (edited) 9 minutes ago, K$Ellie said: she literally has one successful role that was a remake of an already popular movie why do monsters exaggerate every bit of success she has In this case, successful doesn't necessarily mean financially but artistically. Her role in AHS won a Golden Globe and her roles in ASIB and Gucci won multiple awards. Even her part in Joker was praised. Like you can't make people believe Gaga isn't a respected actress no matter how hard you gaslight, especially since you can't come up with any real panned reviews for her. Edited Monday at 11:52 AM by Jay07 2 1
alexrex Posted Monday at 11:53 AM Posted Monday at 11:53 AM This site is so unserious. I wouldn't take anything seriously here
Mariano Posted Monday at 12:09 PM Posted Monday at 12:09 PM (edited) 39 minutes ago, Punky Rooster said: Because it's a major televised award for a film role, isn't that what Gaga fans want? And also she was in a panned film before the re-re-re-remake role of her playing a singer wasn't she? She should do more TV and forget movies, she's clearly not a leading lady. Gaga won Best Actress at the Critics Choice awards in 2019 which was a major televised award and she won it for ASIB - a film role. Idk why you make me repeat it again She had two cameos in Sin City and Matchete Kills. I am sure you know the difference between cameo and actual supporting/leading role All of Gaga's roles have been lead, including the TV one so how is she not a leading lady Edited Monday at 12:11 PM by Mariano
ericcartman Posted Monday at 12:10 PM Posted Monday at 12:10 PM (edited) It's ATRL it's what we do, what kind of answer as re you expecting lmao Edited Monday at 12:11 PM by ericcartman
RideOrDie Posted Monday at 12:12 PM Posted Monday at 12:12 PM everything gaga does is diminished, it's not exclusive to her acting career 2
Azealia Banks Posted Monday at 12:16 PM Posted Monday at 12:16 PM its benefitial to their rhetoric that gaga is a "fad" and a "flop" lol
sugarysunflower Posted Monday at 12:22 PM Posted Monday at 12:22 PM Liddos spamming and over posting them Over stimulating the matter on the forum Thus De-sensitises most ATLRs 1 1
Mariano Posted Monday at 12:28 PM Posted Monday at 12:28 PM 42 minutes ago, OrgVisual said: More like Liddos exaggerated Gaga's success and acted like she's one of the best actresses of all time Are we pretending to forget all the "Oscar" threads whenever she announced a new role? Well we did forget, but you clearly remember as you keep tabs on Gaga more than her own fans, can't wait for the announcement of Gaga's next role, there'll be more of those once again hihi I'm sure u can't wait
Mariano Posted Monday at 12:31 PM Posted Monday at 12:31 PM 39 minutes ago, enchanted0 said: Her success and tankery canceled each other out Mhm that would be horrible news for your fav music career (your real fav, not the one u hide behind)
Sannie Posted Monday at 12:37 PM Posted Monday at 12:37 PM the same reason all of her success is diminished. these people are deranged psychopaths who don't live in the real world. they spent years convincing themselves gaga was over and then when she had one of the biggest comebacks of all time, it literally broke their brains. broke their brains so badly they have to constantly come up with new goalpost-moving categories, like "solo hit" to desperately downplay what gaga accomplishes lol. even now as gaga has the biggest song in the world, they're trying every desperate tactic to downplay it. it's mental illness. they're mad she's not the flop they convinced themselves she was so they have to continue living in a fantasy world they've created so they can function. 1
IBelonginYourArms Posted Monday at 12:42 PM Posted Monday at 12:42 PM 1 hour ago, Punky Rooster said: Because it's a major televised award for a film role, isn't that what Gaga fans want? And also she was in a panned film before the re-re-re-remake role of her playing a singer wasn't she? She should do more TV and forget movies, she's clearly not a leading lady. She clearly is but I enjoy your desperate crying. Luckily she doesn't have to resort to TV since she effortlessly won one of the three most prestigious critics awards in the US that is older than the Oscars We don't stan Madino after all 1
IBelonginYourArms Posted Monday at 12:43 PM Posted Monday at 12:43 PM 57 minutes ago, OrgVisual said: More like Liddos exaggerated Gaga's success and acted like she's one of the best actresses of all time Are we pretending to forget all the "Oscar" threads whenever she announced a new role? That's what happens when your name brings the Oscars conversation
OrgVisual Posted Monday at 12:47 PM Posted Monday at 12:47 PM 2 minutes ago, IBelonginYourArms said: That's what happens when your name brings the Oscars conversation Then when she failed to do so, suddenly she's a victim because people "diminished" her success? Liddos only have themselves to blame in this case 4
IBelonginYourArms Posted Monday at 12:49 PM Posted Monday at 12:49 PM Whoever just quoted me above, sorry, ur too worthless to get a 2nd reply from me. Just wanted to make a point Anyway, Gaga is a legend that will bounce back with acting like she always does with music so we can just be patient since she has many successful years in acting ahead of her. Perks of being young and in demand 1
Mariano Posted Monday at 12:51 PM Posted Monday at 12:51 PM (edited) 14 minutes ago, Sannie said: the same reason all of her success is diminished. these people are deranged psychopaths who don't live in the real world. they spent years convincing themselves gaga was over and then when she had one of the biggest comebacks of all time, it literally broke their brains. broke their brains so badly they have to constantly come up with new goalpost-moving categories, like "solo hit" to desperately downplay what gaga accomplishes lol. even now as gaga has the biggest song in the world, they're trying every desperate tactic to downplay it. it's mental illness. they're mad she's not the flop they convinced themselves she was so they have to continue living in a fantasy world they've created so they can function. Oh damn when u put it like that Maybe we have been a bit unkind to OGH we should probably be nicer Edited Monday at 12:51 PM by Mariano
єѕℓαм Posted Monday at 12:54 PM Posted Monday at 12:54 PM 1 hour ago, Zaram said: I mean every kind of success Gaga has is diminished here. She is still pulling #1 mega smashes despite allegedly being a fad for 10 years Same with the acting. She has one of the biggest acting careers compared to ATRL faves and that makes those ATRLers insecure as usual. .
Phaunzie Posted Monday at 12:57 PM Posted Monday at 12:57 PM Because she likes to go on campaigns when it is award season, therefore no new music or music that the monsters don't want.
Recommended Posts