base talk The 12th Annual ATRL Grammys | Votes due January 12

[TRF.]

5 minutes ago, supaspaz said:

The buzz evaporated!

I have been trying to post but this Khia site is not allowing me!!!

 

Anyways, biggest surprise was not Taylor getting completely snubbed since, after all, she put out a Bad album with a lot of Bad music in it. However, the one that I found surprising was PinkPantheress? Not sure how love she gets on ATRL nowadays but Heaven Knows was one of the finest pop albums released during the eligibility period and I thought she would get... something at least!  Instead of being completely shut out?

 

Also is it me or the R&B noms are... kind of bad  I was rooting for Erika de Casier and Sampha to get something?

[khalyan]

1 hour ago, supaspaz said:

Another lineup heavy on dance-pop. @khalyan, I'm so sorry!

I’m not too mad outside of yes and!

[supaspaz]

4 minutes ago, Element Of Milk said:

Sometimes, a nomination makes you question everything you know about the integrity of an awards process. Enter Jade - Angel of My Dreams, a track that has somehow managed to weasel its way into the ATRL Grammys conversation. Let's be real—this nomination reeks of desperation, clout chasing, and, frankly, a severe lapse in musical taste.

 

Firstly, let's talk about the song itself. "Angel of My Dreams" is neither groundbreaking nor memorable. Its production feels like it was lifted straight from a free stock-music website, with uninspired melodies and a hollow, lifeless beat that wouldn't even make it onto a B-side from a mid-tier pop star. The lyrics are equally banal—filled with clichés so tired they could put a toddler to sleep. If this is what passes for "Grammy-worthy" material, then we might as well start nominating karaoke performances at this point.

 

What's even more galling is how this track seems to have gained its nomination. It doesn't take much digging to see that this was the result of fan campaigns rather than genuine recognition of artistic merit. Sure, stan culture is a force to be reckoned with, but there's a fine line between supporting your fave and pushing mediocrity into spaces it doesn't belong. Jade's fans may be vocal, but volume doesn't equate to value.

 

Let's also address the elephant in the room: the competition. This year has been a buffet of artistic excellence, with artists pouring their heart and soul into works that resonate deeply and push boundaries. The inclusion of "Angel of My Dreams" in the same lineup is not just laughable—it's an insult to those who have worked tirelessly to create art that matters. For every slot wasted on filler like this, there's an actual masterpiece being overlooked.

 

In conclusion, the nomination of Jade - Angel of My Dreams at the ATRL Grammys is a textbook example of how popularity contests can overshadow genuine artistry. It's a sobering reminder that hype often trumps substance in today's music industry. Here's hoping the voters do the right thing and leave this "angel" where it belongs: grounded.

@Patrick, you've got some competition!

[Namiskine]

Angel Of My Dreams slander - out of all the nominees - as your first ATRL post is a choice

 

Edited December 15 by Namiskine

[supaspaz]

3 minutes ago, Namiskine said:

Angel Of My Dreams slander - out of all the nominees - as your first ATRL post is a choice

 

We welcome all kinds. Our job is not to judge, but to educate.

[Element Of Milk]

2 minutes ago, Namiskine said:

Angel Of My Dreams slander - out of all the nominees - as your first ATRL post is a choice

 

Oh, honey, a choice is pretending that "Angel of My Dreams" deserves anything other than a skip button, but here we are, aren't we? I've been on ATRL long enough to see some wild takes, but stanning for that song as your hill to die on? Bold.

 

Let's be clear: dragging "Angel of My Dreams" isn't slander—it's public service. Someone has to say what the rest of us are thinking while you're out here trying to romanticize mediocrity. You've been on ATRL "for too long"? Clearly not long enough to develop taste. Maybe take a break, refresh your ears, and come back when you're ready to engage with actual music.

 

Until then, I'll be here—listening to nominees that deserve their spots. Have fun defending elevator music in the comments!

[supaspaz]

Archive is updated, @Achilles.!

 

https://atrl.net/forums/topic/336504-the-official-atrl-grammys-archive/page/2/#findComment-26951202

[Element Of Milk]

[supaspaz]

 

[Frozen99]

first of all, i'm shocked the noms reveal went kinda well with the site being shite, i can't even post... BUT the fact kacey has as many noms as billie ...AND DUA  i love dua but AOTY? umm, chile, anyways, so...

taylor's department was bad and i'm pleasantly surprised it got shunned out tho i voted (and wanted to see) fortnight in pop duo.

[Frozen99]

also, angel of my dreams is one of best songs released this year  

JADE really is the beyoncé of LM, can't wait for the album next year

[glitch]

Angel of my dreams has made several year end lists, so it's not like ATRL is out of step with critical opinion here

[djcalpal]

Choosing between MagBay and Chappell is my Sophie's Choice.

[makeawish]

i see that the perrie stans are getting out of hand

[Element Of Milk]

My Scathing Review (Record Of The Year) -Part 1

 

 

Verdict: Absolutely not.

 

If the ATRL Grammys had a category for "Most Dramatic Song About an Awkward Love Triangle With Your Own Self," Jade's Angel of My Dreams would take the crown—and the mic, and possibly the stage as well, because, let's face it, Jade needs the spotlight. This track is a whirlwind of emotions, a rollercoaster that somehow keeps getting stuck at the bottom of the hill. If record of the year is about making an impression, Jade definitely made one... just not the kind anyone asked for.

 

Lyrically, Angel of My Dreams is a soap opera—one where Jade spends three minutes explaining that she's deeply in love with someone who doesn't care, then complaining about it over a synth line that could have been programmed by a toaster. If we gave out awards for repeating the word "care" like it's a particularly boring version of "Where's Waldo," Jade would get all the trophies. "Care, care, care, care"—we get it, you're emotional. But where's the depth? Where's the artistry? Maybe it's buried under that pile of Gucci suits, sushi, and the car you bought for someone who clearly doesn't even know your name.

 

The whole song sounds like it was written during a dramatic rant over a Zoom call with a breakup playlist on shuffle. The chorus? Oh, it's just Jade lamenting how "bittersweet" it is that someone doesn't appreciate her and how she "always" wants them, even though they "don't care." But hey, it's "so bad, it's funny," right? A line so confusing, even an existential crisis couldn't fully grasp it.

 

And then we get to the bizarre inclusion of the "money" line—because nothing says record of the year like flexing materialism and a slight hint of existential dread. Jade, honey, are we in love with someone, or are we just bitter about your latest financial investment?

 

The whole thing culminates in a self-absorbed moment of "look at me" mixed with "poor me"—and all of it is punctuated with dramatic flair. Sure, it "feels nice" to be in the spotlight, but maybe it would feel nicer if the song didn't sound like a bad Instagram caption.

 

Final verdict: Absolutely not for Record of the Year. If there were a category for "Most Confusing Combination of Emo and Show Off," Jade would win without question. But as for top honors? Let's just say, "Angel of My Dreams" isn't quite the angel we're praying for. 

[Fitzswiftie]

2 hours ago, supaspaz said:

And the nominees for ALBUM OF THE YEAR are...

 

Brat

Charli XCX

Cowboy Carter

Beyoncé

Deeper Well

Kacey Musgraves

Eternal Sunshine

Ariana Grande

Hit Me Hard and Soft

Billie Eilish

Imaginal Disk

Magdalena Bay

Radical Optimism

Dua Lipa

Short n' Sweet

Sabrina Carpenter

The Rise and Fall of a Midwest Princess

Chappell Roan

The way five of these are actual AOTY nominees and only Magdalena Bay and Dua don't have a nomination period this year.

 

 

[Fitzswiftie]

2 hours ago, Achilles. said:

A few of the swifties think you are biased against Taylor and rig things against her somehow, but most of them just don't really care because she wins real Grammys.

FWIW, I tried to make "Cruel Summer (Live from TS | Eras Tour)" happen

[Born to Run]

GODs of My Dreams is literally #12 most acclaimed song of the year.

 

The Best Songs of 2024 Aggregate - Album of the Year

 

[supaspaz]

2 hours ago, glitch said:

Angel of my dreams has made several year end lists, so it's not like ATRL is out of step with critical opinion here

Exactly. Critical acclaim and ATRL Grammy nominations. The Little Jewelers really won! #BuildTheThirlwall

[supaspaz]

1 hour ago, Element Of Milk said:

My Scathing Review (Record Of The Year) -Part 1

 

 

Verdict: Absolutely not.

 

If the ATRL Grammys had a category for "Most Dramatic Song About an Awkward Love Triangle With Your Own Self," Jade's Angel of My Dreams would take the crown—and the mic, and possibly the stage as well, because, let's face it, Jade needs the spotlight. This track is a whirlwind of emotions, a rollercoaster that somehow keeps getting stuck at the bottom of the hill. If record of the year is about making an impression, Jade definitely made one... just not the kind anyone asked for.

 

Lyrically, Angel of My Dreams is a soap opera—one where Jade spends three minutes explaining that she's deeply in love with someone who doesn't care, then complaining about it over a synth line that could have been programmed by a toaster. If we gave out awards for repeating the word "care" like it's a particularly boring version of "Where's Waldo," Jade would get all the trophies. "Care, care, care, care"—we get it, you're emotional. But where's the depth? Where's the artistry? Maybe it's buried under that pile of Gucci suits, sushi, and the car you bought for someone who clearly doesn't even know your name.

 

The whole song sounds like it was written during a dramatic rant over a Zoom call with a breakup playlist on shuffle. The chorus? Oh, it's just Jade lamenting how "bittersweet" it is that someone doesn't appreciate her and how she "always" wants them, even though they "don't care." But hey, it's "so bad, it's funny," right? A line so confusing, even an existential crisis couldn't fully grasp it.

 

And then we get to the bizarre inclusion of the "money" line—because nothing says record of the year like flexing materialism and a slight hint of existential dread. Jade, honey, are we in love with someone, or are we just bitter about your latest financial investment?

 

The whole thing culminates in a self-absorbed moment of "look at me" mixed with "poor me"—and all of it is punctuated with dramatic flair. Sure, it "feels nice" to be in the spotlight, but maybe it would feel nicer if the song didn't sound like a bad Instagram caption.

 

Final verdict: Absolutely not for Record of the Year. If there were a category for "Most Confusing Combination of Emo and Show Off," Jade would win without question. But as for top honors? Let's just say, "Angel of My Dreams" isn't quite the angel we're praying for. 

Well, you've got a way with words, I'll give you that.

[supaspaz]

Radical Optimism already getting votes for Album of the Year. Dua Lipa really is the people's princess.

[wehavetostan]

Radical Optimism is the least deserving of AOTY out of all the nominees, and I have yet to listen to Imaginal Disk

[loveisdead9582]

I'm genuinely shocked that Radical Optimism is up for album of the year. It was… pretty bad. TTPD isn't exactly my favorite Taylor album but I did kind of expect to see it there. I haven't been able to post all day @supaspazbut I've been trying to keep up with it. 

Edited December 16 by loveisdead9582

[loveisdead9582]

4 hours ago, supaspaz said:

Biggest snub: Obviously, Taylor completely whiffing. But "360" missing Record of the Year and Best Pop Solo Performance shocked me. It was Charli's year!

 

Biggest surprise: Ariana being the nominations leader might only be eclipsed by Radical Optimism making it into Album of the Year. Yes, that feels even crazier than Magdalena Bay. Pleasantly surprised by all the "Angel of My Dreams" love.

Pretty much all of this. Taylor not landing a single nomination kind of baffles me but… I think the burnout is real. Fortnight was cute but it was up against far stronger songs each time it was up. Ariana finally getting her pretend flowers for Eternal Sunshine is a very pleasant surprise. Kesha getting snubbed however… meh. Was she even close to making it?

[brokee]

This was a crazy year for the music competition was so high. Let's see how ATRL decides this year.