base talk Delete One Taylor Swift album: Lover, Midnights, TTPD

[halcyonday]

TTPD is her worst album so that was an easy decision!

[spiritboy]

Listening to TTpD was literally a torture.

[Into The Void]

2 minutes ago, LoveInStereo said:

Have you heard the album? How do moments like Fortnight, My Boy, So High School, imgonnagetyouback or The Alchemy sound like loml, Smallest Man, Cassandra, The Manuscript or How Did It End? It's one thing to not enjoy it but 31 versions of the same song? Rly?

 

OT: Lover without a shadow of a doubt

If u heard the album u would see why it's 31 versions of the same song. When listening to it the first few times I remember wondering if track 1 ever ended and I was 8 tracks in 

[Bloo]

3 minutes ago, Into The Void said:

If u heard the album u would see why it's 31 versions of the same song. When listening to it the first few times I remember wondering if track 1 ever ended and I was 8 tracks in 

Please explain how these songs are the same:

 

 

 

[bielneira]

Let's say our goodbyes to 'THE TORTURED POETS DEPARTMENT'

[Prisoner]

Lover has: Cornelia sreet, cruel summer, dbatc

 

Midnights is a 1-23-4-5-6-7-19 punch

 

TTPD: 

[Trent W]

Lover is her worst album

 

MidnIghts is the best one out of the 3

 

TTPD has a lot of hidden gems

[gatito]

10 minutes ago, LoveInStereo said:

Have you heard the album? How do moments like Fortnight, My Boy, So High School, imgonnagetyouback or The Alchemy sound like loml, Smallest Man, Cassandra, The Manuscript or How Did It End? It's one thing to not enjoy it but 31 versions of the same song? Rly?

 

OT: Lover without a shadow of a doubt

they're just running with the narrative stan twitter's made up to cope with ttpd's massive success out of the gate 

[aotearoa]

reputation is the right answer

[BlackoutZone]

Accidentally voted MIDnights, but it's obviously poets. I do love like 3 songs tho

[tiagol88]

It's funny that Lover was so lackluster to me back then...but looking at these choices both other albums are worse 

 

Yes Lover has Me and You Need To Calm Down but its highs are higher than anything on the other 2 albums and Taylor could still give us good music, with decent melodies instead of reading letters to us with a beat on the background barely assembling songs like she does now.

[ScorpiosGroove]

can we delete all 3 ?

[Raphy23]

This is so so easy for me. TTPD has to go.

 

It has a few really great highlights (TSMWEL, Guilty As Sin, So High School, SL,L). But the rest is extremely bloated and like 80% skips. While I can get through Lover and Midnights in full with only 2-3 skips. 

[TaggedGalaxy]

None, puta can go 

[kellebrity98]

30 minutes ago, Into The Void said:

If u heard the album u would see why it's 31 versions of the same song. When listening to it the first few times I remember wondering if track 1 ever ended and I was 8 tracks in 

literally. Tortured Ears Department.

[Raphy23]

57 minutes ago, wastedpotential said:

It'd be sad to see Cruel Summer go, but Lover in a heartbeat 

I can't live without Miss Americana, DBATC, False God, CS, TA, LB, Cornelia Street, Afterglow, and Daylight.

[kellebrity98]

Just now, Raphy23 said:

I can't live without Miss Americana, DBATC, False God, CS, TA, LB, Cornelia Street, Afterglow, and Daylight.

NOW THAT IS TASTE. Cruel Summer is the best song of her career and her biggest hit. 

[BabyBenzz]

Lover without hesitation

[MissedTheTrain]

I voted Midnights but could also go with Lover....Midnights is more consistent, but Lover has higher highs (and lower lows).

 

TTPD gets way too much flack, I feel like it was a bit of a bandwagon opinion when it came out and people haven't given it a fair shot.  It's long and not for the casual fans, but it's kind of turned out to be one of my favorite Taylor albums.  

[MissedTheTrain]

1 hour ago, kellebrity98 said:

ttpd = 31 versions of the same song 

bye diva 

Yes because these are identical!

 

 

[TaylenaStan]

all 3 in my bottom 5 taylor albums, but i'd delete Midnights because TTPD and even Loser have higher highs (and just ignore the lows) 
Midnights is just MID overall, wont ever listen to the full album ever again anyways
But definitely a close call between Midnights and Loser 

Edited Monday at 04:15 PM by TaylenaStan

[Dear Reader]

All the Swifties with taste voting Lover 

[Klein]

People saying TTPD is the same 31 songs is funny to me. They're really showing how they are talking **** about the album without ever listening to it and just blindly following whatever stan twitter is telling them (or that they have an audition deficit idk). 

[rebeltwat]

Do you guys really dislike TTPD that much  Lover easily

[SpaceOddity]

Torture Borefest Department should've never happened, it doesn't deserve 1/10 of its success. Covers no new ground for her musically or lyrically and each track is like a lackluster version of a previous song she's done. It's bloated, repetitive and the the production does nothing for the songs. Genuinely the only impressive thing about it are the stats.