GAGAISTHEBESTYA Posted October 3 Posted October 3 18 hours ago, Mirrorcle said: Ughh lemme save this before it gets deleted. Maybe I'll have to update my signature soon. Please do
Robyn. Posted October 3 Posted October 3 Side projects tend to sell less than actual studio albums, just look at the transition from The Gift to Renaissance. HOWEVER, I remember vividly monsters getting cocky with that ASIB soundtrack and comparing its success to other pop girls' soundtracks so it's really just a little reminder that it was all a fluke, and she doesn't hold the power they think to smash out of the gate. Maybe, and just maybe, this project could have a revival when Joker comes out. 1
Weld_E Posted October 3 Posted October 3 46 minutes ago, Robyn. said: Maybe, and just maybe, this project could have a revival when Joker comes out. 2
Sharamee6 Posted October 3 Posted October 3 (edited) Joke of the day: A friend (GaGa fan) was telling me how this record is just a side project, not meant for the fans.. You know the same ol' excuses; and that if any other big artist had released it then it would have flopped too. So I asked.. If Taylor releases this.. Will it also debut with 26K only and peak in the top 20? *silence in the room* #NoStarPower Edited October 3 by Sharamee6 11 1
gab00 Posted October 3 Posted October 3 Yeah. I knew this wasnt doing Big numbers because of being just jazz covers but I confess I was expecting at least 80k ish fanbase driven sales. I take the L. 2
argentite Posted October 4 Posted October 4 14 hours ago, Sharamee6 said: So I asked.. If Taylor releases this.. Will it also debut with 26K only and peak in the top 20? *silence in the room* No, because Taylor would release 5382 versions. 5 1
Malkuth Posted October 4 Posted October 4 14 hours ago, Sharamee6 said: Joke of the day: A friend (GaGa fan) was telling me how this record is just a side project, not meant for the fans.. You know the same ol' excuses; and that if any other big artist had released it then it would have flopped too. So I asked.. If Taylor releases this.. Will it also debut with 26K only and peak in the top 20? *silence in the room* #NoStarPower That's not really a fair comparison. Taylor is MUCH bigger than Gaga. For this point in Gaga's career, and for someone of her level if fame, it's a fine debut for a side project.
Elementary Posted October 4 Posted October 4 3 hours ago, argentite said: No, because Taylor would release 5382 versions. If she did that it would be because there would be people buying them. Gaga is very welcome to release a second version if she wants to. 3
Nefertiti0 Posted October 4 Posted October 4 LW TW ARTIST | TITLE | LABEL TOTAL CHANGE ALBUMS TEA SEA 3 1 SABRINA CARPENTER | SHORT N' SWEET ISLAND (UMG) 100,029 3% 13,195 893 85,941 2 2 CHAPPELL ROAN | THE RISE AND FALL OF A MIDWEST PRINCESS ISLAND (UMG) 62,838 -47% 17,818 665 44,355 1 3 FUTURE | MIXTAPE PLUTO FREEBANDZ/EPIC (SME) 55,471 -57% 605 131 54,735 5 4 MORGAN WALLEN | ONE THING AT A TIME BIG LOUD/MERCURY/REPUBLIC (UMG) 50,606 -5% 783 480 49,343 7 5 BILLIE EILISH | HIT ME HARD AND SOFT DARKROOM/INTERSCOPE (UMG) 48,691 9% 5,090 611 42,990 4 6 POST MALONE | F-1 TRILLION MERCURY/REPUBLIC (UMG) 47,676 -12% 2,611 780 44,286 6 7 TAYLOR SWIFT | THE TORTURED POETS DEPARTMENT REPUBLIC (UMG) 43,295 -8% 3,290 203 39,802 10 8 NOAH KAHAN | STICK SEASON MERCURY/REPUBLIC (UMG) 36,830 -1% 2,569 208 34,052 11 9 ZACH BRYAN | THE GREAT AMERICAN BAR SCENE WARNER (WMG) 32,745 -8% 182 244 32,319 12 10 MORGAN WALLEN | DANGEROUS: THE DOUBLE ALBUM BIG LOUD/MERCURY/REPUBLIC (UMG) 32,006 -6% 348 156 31,502 29 11 POST MALONE | THE DIAMOND COLLECTION MERCURY/REPUBLIC (UMG) 29,662 59% 213 197 29,253 13 12 SZA | SOS TDE/RCA (SME) 29,609 -1% 1,186 71 28,352 18 13 TITO DOUBLE P | INCOMODO DOUBLE P (THE ORCHARD) 28,598 10% 24 30 28,544 15 14 ZACH BRYAN | ZACH BRYAN WARNER (WMG) 26,650 -4% 1,763 121 24,766 -- 15 LADY GAGA | HARLEQUIN INTERSCOPE (UMG) 26,273 -- 16,329 382 9,562 14 16 CHARLI XCX | BRAT ATLANTIC (WMG) 26,135 -8% 2,604 221 23,310
spree Posted October 4 Posted October 4 11 minutes ago, Nefertiti0 said: 143 out of top 50 it's probably not even on the chart, lbr. But it still debuted Top 10. 4
fridayteenage Posted October 4 Posted October 4 45 minutes ago, KatyPrismSpirit said: Harlequin increased 2 spots matched perfect illusion. how fitting.
Ger Posted October 4 Posted October 4 Katy Sabrina pulling 100k oh wow, MPG teas right there. Noah's longevity is crazy considering he hasn't had any more hit singles in months.
eli's_rhythm Posted October 4 Posted October 4 29 minutes ago, Joaco95 said: Still a dumb comparison. The Gift was a fully original album with a ton of high-profile collabs and big producers. It even had a rollout campaign with multiple singles. This is a collection of old showtunes and jazz covers. 1 5 4
40_L3VE Posted October 4 Posted October 4 1 hour ago, Joaco95 said: Gaga won the pure sales battle at least.
Rocket Posted October 5 Posted October 5 2 minutes ago, ClashAndBurn said: wow, what a disastrous bomb Enough about 143, lets talk Harlequin.
QueenBLadyG Posted October 5 Posted October 5 On 10/1/2024 at 2:54 PM, Aramis said: I just remember when The Gift debuted #2 and was the biggest bomb of all time. And it debuted with 54k....
.thumb.gif.b76ca4d9d1266836992837a38dd37e35.gif)
Recommended Posts