shimind Posted October 2 Posted October 2 Lg 6.5 is not a studio album.. It can be considered like some pop girl remix album which was released as a cash grab. Only if LG7 fails to chart in top 10 this thread would make sense 2 1
KatyPrismSpirit Posted October 2 Posted October 2 Just now, shimind said: Lg 6.5 is not a studio album.. It can be considered like some pop girl remix album which was released as a cash grab. Only if LG7 fails to chart in top 10 this thread would make sense Where did I say studio album? I said album very clearly in the OP 1 1
RideOrDie Posted October 2 Posted October 2 another Good Morning another gar updates thread from Lady Gaga Now 3
Shaner69 Posted October 2 Posted October 2 This is clearly a studio solo Album so that can be put aside and it's ok. Not sure why people are ignoring facts. 8
PMM Posted October 2 Posted October 2 i don't think so. but thank you KatyPrismSpirit for streaming it <3 I know you listen to the whole project every time you do Ga thread. That's lovely 2
Janet Posted October 2 Posted October 2 57 minutes ago, KatyPrismSpirit said: This list excludes limited edition compilations So what do you think Harlequin, an album with 90% covers, is?
Peak Now Posted October 2 Posted October 2 38 minutes ago, Jump said: Are you saying it doesn't even qualify as a gift for the fans? 2
illia Posted October 2 Posted October 2 This is a gift for the fans The real numbers come on February
KatyPrismSpirit Posted October 2 Posted October 2 6 minutes ago, Janet said: So what do you think Harlequin, an album with 90% covers, is? Lady Gaga says its all from herself, that she put her heart and soul into it and that its a companion studio album inspired by the movie. How is that limited edition or a compilation? Especially if its all original production 5 1
Nightglitch Posted October 2 Posted October 2 Hopefully, I'm tired of cover albums, please make something original for once.
LVP Posted October 2 Posted October 2 44 minutes ago, mike_int said: I dont even consider as Gaga album, just like I didnt consider Star Is Born or the Jazz albums. I think mistake they did with Harlequin is to announce it literally days before release with no single before and Die With Smile not being on the album. Die With Smile overlap with Harlequin too much. It is also mostly album of covers and mostly in Jazz style, this is not something regular Gaga listener is interested in. I enjoy Happy Mistake and maybe 1-2 other guitar driven songs on the album but I dont feel like listening Jazz outside of theater or thematic bar I think it is nice companion to the soundtrack and that is it, but I understand some Gaga haters will jerk off their egos that it wont be commercial success, but I dont think it ever was planned to be. Do you also not consider The Gift as Beyonce's album? Cause I remeber monsters used to claim it broke Beyonce streak of all #1 albums. 2
DonnaSpring Posted October 2 Posted October 2 29 minutes ago, mike_int said: I said "I dont consider it" if others does, it is fine, I consider Fame, Fame Monster, ArtPop, Joanne and Chromatica to be Gaga albums Thats all And cheek to cheek / love for sale
KatyPrismSpirit Posted October 2 Posted October 2 6 minutes ago, DonnaSpring said: And cheek to cheek / love for sale harlequin is a gaga album too lets stop denying facts
mike_int Posted October 2 Posted October 2 1 minute ago, DonnaSpring said: And cheek to cheek / love for sale As I said, twice "I dont consider them as Gaga albums" their are all covers anyway, aren't they? For example I dont even consider "Im Breathless" by Madonna her album despite it all be original production and even have Vogue on it. So to each their own ... It really dosent matter, everyone should listen what they want Also which ones Gaga consider her albums? Cause Fame, Fame Monster, ArtPop, Joanne and Chromatica are 5 and she called Harlequin 6.5, so if if she considered Cheek To Cheek and Love For Sale her albums then it would have must have been 7.5 or she doesnt consider Fame Monster an full album
mike_int Posted October 2 Posted October 2 (edited) 15 minutes ago, LVP said: Do you also not consider The Gift as Beyonce's album? Cause I remeber monsters used to claim it broke Beyonce streak of all #1 albums. No I dont consider The Gift Beyonce album as well but guys, there is nothing deep about it, I simply dont consider certain albums, especially if they are all covers, or soundtracks, compilations(even if they ahve new songs on them) etc. as regular studio albums, and it applies to many artists. Also Im not stan of any artists, Im listening absolutely anything by anyone if I like it, so I will equally criticize even my favs when they release sh*t AND ... I absolutely dont care about chart positions, not in slightest Edited October 2 by mike_int
Shaner69 Posted October 2 Posted October 2 On topic it's going to miss forsure! (Sideproject) come over Katyperryspirit
crymelanie Posted October 2 Posted October 2 (edited) Critical and commercial failure Edited October 2 by crymelanie
Spicy Pisces Posted October 2 Posted October 2 1 hour ago, KatyPrismSpirit said: 2008: One Of The Boys — #9 2010: Teenage Dream — #1 2013: PRISM — #1 2017: Witness — #1 2020: Smile — #5 2024: 143 — #6 1 hour ago, KatyPrismSpirit said: 2008: The Fame — #2 2009: The Fame Monster — #5 2011: Born This Way — #1 2013: ARTPOP — #1 2014: Cheek To Cheek — #1 2016: Joanne — #1 2018: A Star Is Born — #1 2020: Chromatica — #1 2021: Love For Sale — #8 2024: Harlequin — #17 (HDD early prediction) Oh wow these lists are impressive, considering how both debuted in 2008 and only one managed to have 3/6 no.1 albums, and another 6/10. We're focusing on things such as "breaking streaks" now? Aim higher, OGHs 3
GAGAISTHEBESTYA Posted October 2 Posted October 2 (edited) Well yes, it is going to break her album debut streak. 4 months from now miss KatyPrismSpirit is going to spiral HARD when LG7 number outsells (Smile + 143)x2 with a top 10 lead single debut, but until then, enjoy the little moments while it lasts. A Jazz album having the same amount of SEA + TEA as a pop album with 3 collabs tells me everything I need to know. Edited October 2 by GAGAISTHEBESTYA 3 1
ChooseyLover Posted October 2 Posted October 2 2 hours ago, RideOrDie said: another Good Morning another gar updates thread from Lady Gaga Now Don't shoot the messenger or whatever he says 1 1
dumbsparce Posted October 2 Posted October 2 Unfortunately, it looks like her top 10 streak is following a hip-like career path 1 3
Sharamee6 Posted October 2 Posted October 2 But I thought GaGa has so much star power that her jazz-leaning album would easily do above 100K (without Tony). Oops. 🤭 ThankYouTony ThankYouBruno ThankYouAriana 1 2
DevilsRollTheDice Posted October 2 Posted October 2 How does Billboard count records like this? Don't they consider Beyoncé's to be in-tact? If they don't count TG and EIL there I probably wouldn't count this for Gaga.
.thumb.gif.b76ca4d9d1266836992837a38dd37e35.gif)
Recommended Posts