hindsight Posted August 20 Posted August 20 I think the song is ok. The problem is that the lyrics are too generic, it's like they didn't have anything interesting to say at all and just thought "stupid love" was a nice title and went it with it.
JO1s Posted August 20 Posted August 20 6 minutes ago, lgaga1fan said: Madge X army, Lambs, random khia kpop/jpop fans running to call this song bad bc they've been conditioned like pavolv's dog to think its **** from the stupid social media response. The hate for the song is artificial. When it leaked everyone was calling it great and they were playing it in the clubs. People were mad bc they thought the final would be some DRASTIC difference. Gaga's held to a ridiculous standard compared to other pop girls here (esp the one terrorizing the site since her tour started). Good god girl get a grip. 1
Sheep Posted August 20 Author Posted August 20 5 minutes ago, JO1s said: Good god girl get a grip. would you like it better if VIXX sang it? 1
JO1s Posted August 20 Posted August 20 Just now, Sheep said: would you like it better if VIXX sang it? No because Vixx hasn't released a song this bad since Obama's first term.
Sheep Posted August 20 Author Posted August 20 (edited) 12 minutes ago, JO1s said: No because Vixx hasn't released a song this bad since Obama's first term. See the only flaw I can find in the song is that it's a little too similar to songs like Bad Romance and Poker Face with the lo-o-o-o-ve ad lib chorus. Sort of like how some ATRL users are similar to previously banned ones, we've seen it before and already decided it's a chop. I can see how people might be fatigued by that or never liked it in the first place like those ATRL users but to me its just her signature. Edited August 20 by Sheep 1
Femalien Posted August 20 Posted August 20 her lead singles are always busted. btw applause perfect illusion and stupid love are all rotten
Colbygg Posted August 20 Posted August 20 It's a solid 8/10, and it especially hits when you've had a couple. 1 1
LittleCupid Posted August 20 Posted August 20 I usually am not a Gaga listener (I like a few tracks) but I like this song. 2
JO1s Posted August 20 Posted August 20 2 minutes ago, Sheep said: See the only flaw I can find in the song is that it's a little too similar to songs like Bad Romance and Poker Face with the lo-o-o-o-ve ad lib chorus. Sort of like how some ATRL users are similar to previously banned ones, we've seen it before and already decided it's a chop. I can see how people might be fatigued by that or never liked it in the first place like those ATRL users but to me its just her signature. So you admit she hasn't evolved and you're okay with dated rehashes?
Janet Posted August 20 Posted August 20 The music video ruined the song sadly. Would have been better without it dd 1
Sheep Posted August 20 Author Posted August 20 4 minutes ago, JO1s said: So you admit she hasn't evolved and you're okay with dated rehashes? baby your username on this account is the 19th produce group, your real ult is possibly the only pop act with more cringe value than Lady Gaga I don't know what you think you're accomplishing here. I stan kpop I'm always down for some safe dance pop and don't have a weird complex about it.
JO1s Posted August 20 Posted August 20 (edited) 12 minutes ago, Sheep said: baby your username on this account is the 19th produce group, your real ult is possibly the only pop act with more cringe value than Lady Gaga I don't know what you think you're accomplishing here. I stan kpop I'm always down for some safe dance pop and don't have a weird complex about it. I haven't listened to vixx more than 50 times since like 2020. I moved on from them, it's time to moved on from your tired attempted drags. JO1 have become way more than just a produce group and have litterally started reshaping the Japanese idol industry. Edited August 20 by JO1s
Norte Posted August 20 Posted August 20 I think, it should had been a promo single, but it's fun simple bop
Sheep Posted August 20 Author Posted August 20 (edited) 7 minutes ago, JO1s said: it's time to moved on from your tired attempted drags. you're the one who entered the thread to drag on your nth forum account, I just downvoted you and didn't drag until you tried again and again, just like you did with ATRL signups 7 minutes ago, JO1s said: JO1 have become way more than just a produce group and have litterally started reshaping the Japanese idol industry. just like how vixx was above idol groups because of their flop status and marketing to weirdos? Edited August 20 by Sheep
Spicy Pisces Posted August 20 Posted August 20 It still holds strong as one of my favorites from Chromatica but what damaged the perception of this song: - song leaked a month before - video shot on iPhone - amateurish video with bad costumes and bad SFX - the polarizing "empty chorus" among the fans Had she done a video with more intent on cinematography, quality, polish and cvntiness it would've slayed and it wouldn't have gotten so much hate period!! 1 1
JO1s Posted August 20 Posted August 20 1 minute ago, Sheep said: marketing to weirdos? A lady gaga fan trying to make fun of this.... you lost the plot.
Sheep Posted August 20 Author Posted August 20 3 minutes ago, JO1s said: A lady gaga fan trying to make fun of this.... you lost the plot. I don't have any weird cognitive dissonance and/or impairment about recognizing the kooky and campy acts I stan. So sad that you can't relate, maybe people would have accepted you the first time around in the stan community if you were more self-aware. These dupe drags are like you, they just keep coming back with slightly different wording.
vanishingbee Posted August 20 Posted August 20 it's fine, its only real relevance is that it sounds like a better version of woman's world - max martin is getting lazy
GrandeVersace Posted August 20 Posted August 20 I'd say it's a mediocre song. The production is enjoyable but the chorus is so repetitive that it gets to my nerves. Replay was literally robbed of its rightful lead single material status.
JO1s Posted August 20 Posted August 20 1 minute ago, Sheep said: I don't have any weird cognitive dissonance and/or impairment about recognizing the kooky and campy acts I stan. So sad that you can't relate, maybe people would have accepted you the first time around in the stan community if you were more self-aware. These dupe drags are like you, they just keep coming back with slightly different wording. Girl if you want to bring up the past you literally got kicked out of a discord because you took any slight towards your fav personally and you still do all these years later. Notice not once have I gone off topic about gaga and gone after your other favs. This thread is about gaga, so keep it on topic.
Sheep Posted August 20 Author Posted August 20 (edited) 12 minutes ago, JO1s said: Girl if you want to bring up the past you literally got kicked out of a discord because you took any slight towards your fav personally and you still do all these years later. Notice not once have I gone off topic about gaga and gone after your other favs. This thread is about gaga, so keep it on topic. I got invited back to a discord more than once in private because a problematic psycho who tries to paint every stan of acts they don't like in a bad light was in charge of kicking me. I didn't come back because of edgelord freaks who come in guns blazing at the sight of people liking something they don't and coordinate in spreading in spreading misinformation and trying to silence opposition through spam reports and using duplicate accounts to dominate conversations. Go ahead and report me for being off topic though, I can take a wp for clapping back at somebody with a years old grudge dragging both my friend and favorite song and you can be forced to start over yet again. I'll be unbothered with my single ATRL account and single OH account before that, not everybody can express how they really feel and show who they really are without being yeeted off of every platform. Your posts about VIXX and jo1 were equally as off topic anyway. Edited August 20 by Sheep
JO1s Posted August 20 Posted August 20 1 minute ago, Sheep said: I got invited back to a discord more than once in private because a problematic psycho who tries to paint every stan of acts they don't like in a bad light was in charge of kicking me. I didn't come back because of edgelord freaks who come in guns blazing at the sight of people liking something they don't and coordinate in spreading in spreading misinformation and trying to silence opposition through spam reports and using duplicate accounts to dominate conversations. Go ahead and report me for being off topic though, I can take a so for defending my fav and clapping back at somebody dragging both my friend and favorite song and you can be forced to start over yet again. I'll be unbothered with my single ATRL account and single OH account before that, not everybody can express how they really feel and show who they really are without being yeeted off of every platform. Good god girl get a grip.
Sheep Posted August 20 Author Posted August 20 3 minutes ago, JO1s said: Good god girl get a grip. I don't get removed from every space where I'm not in charge, I have a handle on things
Recommended Posts