ericcartman Posted October 31 Posted October 31 It's a good spot for Britney. Keep in mind the majority of the first era is not counted, though a lot of its sales did happen in this century. She also lacked longevity as she burned out quickly and never recovered. The artists above her have maintained longevity (even Rihanna who retired early but she retired on top on her own terms plus her catalog is still huge)
dumbsparce Posted October 31 Posted October 31 Who tf is this girl who goes around calling ppl "stink" and why is she not banned yet?
NEUTRON Posted October 31 Posted October 31 17 hours ago, TeemoR said: No idea if they would place Beyonce or Taylor at #1, this will be a mess I thought Taylor initially but now I that I've really thought about it-- it's going to be Beyoncé. She's the only person to dominate the entire century thus far without hiccup. 2
IsidoraMarí Posted October 31 Posted October 31 5. Drake 4. Beyonce 3. Gaga 2. Taylor 1. Rihanna 3 1 1
PoisonPill Posted October 31 Posted October 31 It should be Taylor at #1 but I think they'll feel pressured to give it to Beyonce. 1
leyaris11 Posted October 31 Posted October 31 1 hour ago, ericcartman said: It's a good spot for Britney. Keep in mind the majority of the first era is not counted, though a lot of its sales did happen in this century. She also lacked longevity as she burned out quickly and never recovered. The artists above her have maintained longevity (even Rihanna who retired early but she retired on top on her own terms plus her catalog is still huge) I liked some of your post but this is wrong. She got an amazing run and stay on top of her game with her first 4 albums. Then semi repeak with Blackout and repeak again with Circus and FF, she fall short with BJ but the whole Vegas residency going on to keep her name afloat, and somehow managed to stay relevant with Glory. Her bio book sold over 3 millions WW and scored a top 10 on BB hot 100 just couple years ago. So your statement of lack longevity, burn out and never recover totally wrong. I known this site is hating on Britney but you have to give her credit when it's due. 3 1
RihannaLoverrr Posted October 31 Posted October 31 I think it'll go; 1. Taylor 2. Beyoncé 3. Drake 4. Rihanna 5. Gaga I want and think Rih should be top 3 but her hiatus will probably bring her down.
Starshine Posted October 31 Posted October 31 That Britney stan still trying to convince everyone that The Gift and Harlequin are studio albums. ijbol. 14
Smilers Posted October 31 Posted October 31 My prediction: 5. Gaga 4. Drake 3. Rih 2. Taylor 1. Bey 1
45seconds Posted November 1 Posted November 1 Just now, 45seconds said: 5. Gaga 4. Drake 3. Rihanna 2/1: Beyonce 2/1: Taylor If we're being real Rihanna should have just as much of a chance as Beyoncé and Taylor but her inactivity probably hurts her.
Miss Anthropocene Posted November 1 Posted November 1 5. Rihanna 4. Gaga 3. Drake 2. Beyoncé 1. Taylor
LosingHimWasBlue Posted November 2 Posted November 2 On 10/31/2024 at 10:34 PM, IsidoraMarí said: 5. Drake 4. Beyonce 3. Gaga 2. Taylor 1. Rihanna Bold of you to assume Gaga would be Top 5. 5. Maroon 5 / Beyonce 4. Maroon 5 / Beyonce 3. Rihanna 2. Drake 1. Taylor Swift if Katy on Top 25 with back to back gigantic era (TD & Prism), i could see Gaga on Top 30.
Aston Martin Posted November 2 Posted November 2 7 minutes ago, LosingHimWasBlue said: Bold of you to assume Gaga would be Top 5. 5. Maroon 5 / Beyonce 4. Maroon 5 / Beyonce 3. Rihanna 2. Drake 1. Taylor Swift if Katy on Top 25 with back to back gigantic era (TD & Prism), i could see Gaga on Top 30. Maroon 5 was already listed as an honorable mention, so they are not a contender for a top 5 slot
LosingHimWasBlue Posted November 2 Posted November 2 31 minutes ago, Aston Martin said: Maroon 5 was already listed as an honorable mention, so they are not a contender for a top 5 slot I didn't know that. Billboard didn't mention Morgan Wallen, i fear he would be Top 5 instead Gaga. I still believe Gaga wouldn't be Top 5 2
Blackout2006 Posted November 2 Posted November 2 On 10/31/2024 at 8:19 PM, leyaris11 said: I liked some of your post but this is wrong. She got an amazing run and stay on top of her game with her first 4 albums. Then semi repeak with Blackout and repeak again with Circus and FF, she fall short with BJ but the whole Vegas residency going on to keep her name afloat, and somehow managed to stay relevant with Glory. Her bio book sold over 3 millions WW and scored a top 10 on BB hot 100 just couple years ago. So your statement of lack longevity, burn out and never recover totally wrong. I known this site is hating on Britney but you have to give her credit when it's due. Exactly People here act like she completely fell out of discussion after 2007. She was releasing hit albums all the way till BJ.
Blackout2006 Posted November 2 Posted November 2 On 10/31/2024 at 2:35 AM, CandleGuy said: So this is Britney, minus her massive BOMT debut era, and she's still amongst your faves? The only one in the top 6 who started her solo career in the 90s with solo material that won't count for this list? And y'all are dragging her? OBHs remains booked and busy doing too much on the very MPG behind the formation of this site
Blackout2006 Posted November 2 Posted November 2 (edited) On 10/31/2024 at 2:32 AM, QueenBeyoncé said: Yes the GP doesn't, seeing why Beyoncé's career is STILL going while the other's career died almost two decade ago Ooo how I'd love me some dead career for two decades with a NYT best-selling autobiography and top-10 BB hit in the past two years Edited November 2 by Blackout2006
Aston Martin Posted November 2 Posted November 2 7 minutes ago, LosingHimWasBlue said: I didn't know that. Billboard didn't mention Morgan Wallen, i fear he would be Top 5 instead Gaga. I still believe Gaga wouldn't be Top 5 On 10/30/2024 at 3:21 PM, Feanor said: 5th place is "an artist who paid a particularly memorable tribute to Britney at one point in the early 2010s". 1
The Music Industry Posted November 2 Posted November 2 Objectively Taylor should be #1 but I wouldn't be surprised if Billboard gives in to stan culture pressure to avoid backlash and goes in with the safer PR pick (Beyoncé). 2 1
Recommended Posts