TayDuaStan Posted November 27 Posted November 27 (edited) 3 minutes ago, Carter said: remember there's a new rendition of this list in 10 years or so. Good. Beyonce will serve #1 - OUT just like her latest album. Longevity… where? With 0 albums & 0 songs currently charting anywhere Edited November 27 by TayDuaStan 1 3
Carter Posted November 27 Posted November 27 2 minutes ago, TayDuaStan said: Good. Beyonce will serve #1 - OUT just like her latest album. Longevity… where? With 0 albums & 0 songs currently charting anywhere i honestly think it was that kinda situation let's give it to her when it make the most sense. because imagine dropping this in 2034 1 1
Jon Snow Posted November 27 Posted November 27 4 hours ago, Bumba said: If this is about numbers, I don't get how Beyoncé is higher. Taylor sold more albums/singles/tour gross. Beyoncé is a good artistic artist, but she is a flop nowadays. Beyoncé gets no press anymore, her business ventures flop, her tour kinda flopped because it didn't sell out every date, it just had high concert prices, her latest music release was a huge flop, the lead single was very frontloaded, ask anybody if they know her latest music, they will think it's Break My Soul or Drunk In Love, her concert movie also was a flop (grossed 40 million dollar, taylor did 300 million), her catalog isn't getting streamed because she is not as remembered as people think she is by the GP (beyonce gets 10m daily streams, taylor gets 60m daily streams on spotify), her visuals also are lowley viewed (Texas has 50 million, fortnight 130 million). Taylor has a bigger career by stats over the last 10 years. Maybe they added DC's stats but then do this list in 5 more years and Taylor will have passed that. open the schools 8
Arrows Posted November 27 Posted November 27 Let's be honest, Beyoncé deserves this, and I say that as a swiftie Bey was smashing in the year 2000 and is smashing now, in the year 2024, which is extremely impressive. She's defined this century so far. Taylor might overtake in the future, as the century is far from over, but so far, Beyoncé has the edge. Taylor has enough achievements already. Purely statistically, she's the first female artist to be top-selling artist of a century since Hildegard Van Bingen in the 12th Century
Jon Snow Posted November 27 Posted November 27 (edited) 9 minutes ago, TayDuaStan said: Good. Beyonce will serve #1 - OUT just like her latest album. Longevity… where? With 0 albums & 0 songs currently charting anywhere she's the only artist that had #1s on Billboard in both 2001. and 2024. hope that helps Edited November 27 by Jon Snow 1 1
piotrert Posted November 27 Posted November 27 1 hour ago, Burn said: The "twitter vibes" thing #they try to push makes no sense when Bey was a superstar LONG before Twitter and will be here long after it, and she gets the most criticism of any pop star on Twitter/social media. Look at how many people dogpiled on her by trying to make Diddy's crimes her responsibility smh. But sure, "twitter vibes" i thought swifties were pressed we made fun of she knows and moved on
NextBish90 Posted November 27 Posted November 27 (edited) 3 hours ago, Badgalbriel said: You guys arw giving this list too much credit. And being second to Beyonce is no drag at all. Beyoncé IS the greatest artist of the century. She's not the biggest (far from it), but this is not what this list is about. I thought POP STARS are made for producing mass pop POP P O P hits. Beyonce hasn't had a hit for more than a decade. No difference than Madonna, for example. Why her name and status are still a thing when her mass appeal is not responding to these bought articles by media !? Edited November 27 by NextBish90 2
Jon Snow Posted November 27 Posted November 27 2 minutes ago, NextBish90 said: I thought POP STARS are made for producing mass pop POP P O P hits. Beyonce hasn't had a hit for more than a decade. No difference than Madonna, for example. Why her name and status are still a thing when her mass appeal is not responding to these bought articles by media !? 2024: TEXAS HOLD 'EM #1 (and not counting high peaks for II MOST WANTED and JOLENE) 2022: BREAK MY SOUL #1; CUFF IT #6 2020: Savage Remix #1 and that's just from the past couple of years. both THE and CI were viral songs 2 1
Rigalo Posted November 27 Posted November 27 6 minutes ago, NextBish90 said: I thought POP STARS are made for producing mass pop POP P O P hits. Beyonce hasn't had a hit for more than a decade. No difference than Madonna, for example. Why her name and status are still a thing when her mass appeal is not responding to these bought articles by media !? Beyonce had a #1 BBH100 hit this year 2 1
TipToe Posted November 27 Posted November 27 I understand the uproar, Billboard should be about objective metrics within the charts realm and i may be mistaken but Taylor devours everyone else in this sense but anyway, her fans should not be resorting to attacks to Beyoncé, this is childish. Are they eternally 15 yo like their muse sound? Touch grass!
Buffy Posted November 27 Posted November 27 Ohhhh is this like a fan fiction piece? Must be hard living in a reality where Taylor is #1! 1
Kristie Kuwa Posted November 27 Posted November 27 (edited) 3 minutes ago, Buffy said: Ohhhh is this like a fan fiction piece? Must be hard living in a reality where Taylor is #1! Yeah, it truly is hard seeing such a talentless person succeed with such corny and basic music. Its borderline offensive. Worse singer than most random choir singers, worse performer than any 6 year old, hailed as a supreme songwriter with lyrics such as "Charlie Puth should be more famous" or "Karma is a cat". The cringe is unfathomable to me Edited November 27 by Kristie Kuwa 5 1
Kill Me Posted November 27 Posted November 27 4 minutes ago, Kristie Kuwa said: Yeah, it truly is hard seeing such a talentless person succeed with such corny and basic music. Its borderline offensive. Worse singer than most random choir singers, worse performer than any 6 year old, hailed as a supreme songwriter with lyrics such as "Charlie Puth should be more famous" or "Karma is a cat". The cringe is unfathomable to me Omg all this seething... let it all out. I know the Hive are pressed that the only thing the GP consumes by their fave is Single Ladies and Halo but that doesn't mean everyone else is only known for making awful cringe music... and people are consuming entire albums from them... ELEVEN OF THEM to be exact. 6
Kristie Kuwa Posted November 27 Posted November 27 (edited) 2 minutes ago, Kill Me said: Omg all this seething... let it all out. I know the Hive are pressed that the only thing the GP consumes by their fave is Single Ladies and Halo but that doesn't mean everyone else is only known for making awful cringe music... and people are consuming entire albums from them... ELEVEN OF THEM to be exact. Its like comparing McDonalds to a Michellin 5 Star Restaurant. Im sure Michellin is not sad about having less people eating at their place than McDonalds, but take pride in ur artificial cheeseburgers and chicken nuggets @Kill Me, metaphorically speaking. I know ur eager for that next Big Mac Edited November 27 by Kristie Kuwa 4
ScorpiosGroove Posted November 27 Posted November 27 3 hours ago, NextBish90 said: So this whole chart by Billboard was a paid advertisement for SHE KNOWS! That's it, a paid article. Changes and means nothing. why are you crying then ? 1 6 1
brraap Posted November 27 Posted November 27 Technically Taylor started out as a country artist and then overlapped into pop midway Beyonce has been a pop superstar since the age of 14 and now legend, so it would make sense to give her #1
Kill Me Posted November 27 Posted November 27 1 minute ago, Kristie Kuwa said: Its like comparing McDonalds to a Michellin 5 Star Restaurant. Im sure Michellin is not sad about having less people eating at their place than McDonalds, but take pride in ur artificial cheeseburgers and chicken nuggets @Kill Me, metaphorically speaking. I know ur eager for that next Big Mac McDonald's has a lot of people eating at their place because it is mass produced GARBAGE made by CHEAP ingredients with no human input. That fits Beyoncé and her 80+ people writing camps that shits out one song after another than it does Taylor, but I guess she is too much of a flop to be called a McDonalds, maybe she can be the Burger King (We all got crowns). I'm sure Taylor and her 4* AOTY winning discography fits the criteria for a Michelin Restaurant better than the one whose album is filled with scraps and rejects from Drake, Miley Cyrus and other artists. 2 1
faceclef Posted November 27 Posted November 27 Meltdowns like this make more sense when you realize alot of the users are non-americans 1
Burn Posted November 27 Posted November 27 These Taylor stans have got to be deluded to say Taylor has a better discography than thee BEY-ON-CÉ. Who do they think they're kidding? Have they heard Taylor's "music"?! The ***** can't even ******* sing! 10
Burn Posted November 27 Posted November 27 Like please tell me which Taylor albums are touching Lemonade, ST, Renaissance, B'Day… I'll wait. 1
ScorpiosGroove Posted November 27 Posted November 27 13 minutes ago, Kill Me said: McDonald's has a lot of people eating at their place because it is mass produced GARBAGE made by CHEAP ingredients with no human input. That fits Beyoncé and her 80+ people writing camps that shits out one song after another than it does Taylor, but I guess she is too much of a flop to be called a McDonalds, maybe she can be the Burger King (We all got crowns). I'm sure Taylor and her 4* AOTY winning discography fits the criteria for a Michelin Restaurant better than the one whose album is filled with scraps and rejects from Drake, Miley Cyrus and other artists. you really thought you ate
Buffy Posted November 27 Posted November 27 51 minutes ago, Kristie Kuwa said: Yeah, it truly is hard seeing such a talentless person succeed with such corny and basic music. Its borderline offensive. Worse singer than most random choir singers, worse performer than any 6 year old, hailed as a supreme songwriter with lyrics such as "Charlie Puth should be more famous" or "Karma is a cat". The cringe is unfathomable to me
Recommended Posts