base talk Billboard's Greatest Pop Stars of the 21st Century | #1 Beyoncé

[Pikacho]

Welp. This is such an ugly list lol.

[gerardsuxx]

So Female:

 

1. Beyoncé

2. Taylor

3. Rihanna 

4. Gaga

5. Britney

 

[Kristie Kuwa]

26 minutes ago, AxelFox said:

The dramatics over some silly list. Be careful she's even being spoken to in the same breath as someone like Beyoncé, 'cause there's a clear distinction between them.

 

Beyoncé's greatness brought her sales and numbers, whereas Taylor's sales and numbers are what brought her greatness. Remember that. 

This needs to be quoted every page going forward

[suneclipse121]

1 hour ago, Dom said:

Honestly, congrats to Beyonce for coming 1 and others respectfully?

 

But I don't get it, how did P!nk miss it? She has the hits, the album sales, huge grossing tours others wish about? Even beat out Beyonce.

 

How is P!nk not in top 20 and miss me with delusional, she really deserves at least top 15.

I mean this as respectfully as possible but Pink has been a non factor culturally for a loooong time. And that matters in the equation. She slays with touring. But commercially she has been declining for years at this point music wise. And the music also hasn't been giving in a long time from her either lbr. She never pushed her artistry forward instead she stayed in the same zone for years. 

 

Look at Beyoncé and put Pink next to her.  It's insane how worlds apart they are to each other in relevance. But you wouldn't think that if you just saw their touring stats on paper. There's more to it imo. 

[narid]

Agree with Taylor and Bey in the top 2, but really surprised Taylor is not number 1. By charts and metrics alone she should be. 

 

 

 

Edited November 26 by narid

[Shelter]

What's gross is how haters always degrade Beyonce's success. "She bought awards", "her husband paid" 

 

Like Beyonce hasn't worked hard all her life or isn't talented enough to be where she is. She is the only one spoken about like this. 
 

 

[DemDam92]

Payola by Ms. Knowles yet again

 

Taylor deserves #1 spot and I'm not even a fan.

[YellowRibbon]

Vibes community won I guess

[Burn]

 

[RihannaLoverrr]

Excellent top 3. Beyoncé is absolutely deserving of the top spot too. Debuting in the 90s still going strong and competing with the new girls

[Pepo]

Congrats to both ladies 

[BrokenMachine]

The meltdowns of certain people when Billboard was clear from the very first moment about what they were going to take into consideration for the ranking. Just stop playing the victim, enjoy the place your fave got, and leave in peace 

[piotrert]

Will the greatest pop star of this century by billboard™️ be able to chart at least one album on the billboard™️ chart after next week announcement? 

[Sazare]

4 hours ago, Khal said:

The banner

 

"Who will be #1", yeah I'm wondering the same, maybe Mandy Moore?

The girl reading this

[BrokenMachine]

1 hour ago, Dom said:

But I don't get it, how did P!nk miss it? She has the hits, the album sales, huge grossing tours others wish about? Even beat out Beyonce.

 

How is P!nk not in top 20 and miss me with delusional, she really deserves at least top 15.

In the own words of BB:

Quote

She's a touring legend with a deep catalog, but she's never strung enough huge hit songs and albums together in any one era to truly dominate the pop landscape.

Or in other words, she never had this 'total domination' era in the US full of impact in cultute beyond the music. Miss and TTAL were huge, but it stayed in the music and werent the biggest eras of their respective times

[Doogle]

1 hour ago, OhMyAlf said:

Beyoncé being my favourite artist of all time and Taylor a very close second has made the last few years so enjoyable for me. No petty stan wars just enjoying the 2 greatest pop stars of our time 

The correct response 

 

It didn't matter what way round they were. They both had a strong case. 

[BrokenMachine]

On 8/14/2024 at 11:05 AM, Gwendolyn said:

Greatest Pop Stars are NOT mathematically determined by stats like chart position, streams or sales numbers. Those play a big part in our final rankings, of course, but so do things like music videos, live performances and social media presence, and more intangible factors like cultural importance, industry influence and overall omnipresence. (And we're measuring this over all 25 years of this century so far, so if you were only heard from at the beginning or the end of that period — or only had one or two big songs, albums or eras — that's gonna significantly hinder your ranking here as well.)

People need to read this from the OP before going into endless rants and meltdowns 

[_Fey]

1 hour ago, AxelFox said:

The dramatics over some silly list. Be thankful she's even being spoken to in the same breath as someone like Beyoncé, 'cause there's a clear distinction between them.

 

Beyoncé's greatness brought her sales and numbers, whereas Taylor's sales and numbers are what brought her greatness. Remember that. 

Period.

 

Another way I look at it is - if Beyonce was #2, the Hive would definitely (and rightfully) be flooding our timelines with Beychella vids, Renaissance tour performances, music videos, etc.

 

Taylor at #2 is flooding our timelines with stats.

 

If the stans themselves can't use Taylor's songs, videos, performances (you know... her actual art) as justification for why she should be called the best pop artist of the century then no, she absolutely doesn't deserve the title.

Edited November 26 by _Fey

[BrokenMachine]

3 hours ago, Assassin said:

the meltdown. LMAO

 

Them bringing global receipts for a US ONLY list is the cherry on top for that meltdown 

[americanshameless]

29 minutes ago, YellowRibbon said:

Vibes community won I guess

In other words, maths lost science won

[Badgalbriel]

I'm so glad Taylor got the #2, tbh. People would hate on whoever ended up at #1 and Bey is being dragged on social media. Taylor deserves a break from the hate comments. 

[BrokenMachine]

2 minutes ago, americanshameless said:

In other words, maths lost science won

Is math related to science?

[TayDuaStan]

Hopefully Coldplay at #1 

 

 

1 minute ago, BrokenMachine said:

Them bringing global receipts for a US ONLY list is the cherry on top for that meltdown 

Oh Beyoncé, the local flop that you are 

[Badgalbriel]

3 minutes ago, americanshameless said:

In other words, maths lost science won

math is a science girl

[TayDuaStan]

1 minute ago, Badgalbriel said:

math is a science girl