Jump to content

WINNER REVEALED | Little Miss Obsessive: The Ashlee Simpson Discography Rate


Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)
22 hours ago, KillingYourCareer said:

#40

 

Phases

6.577

 

ab67616d0000b27312497f87f67dc906d46197b2

 

L.O.V.E. (11s):

I Want You (Highest): 1x10: AshleyLovescats887

Can't Have It All (Lowest): 1x1: memo90061

 

COMMENTARIES:

so cute..i hate evan's voice here but ashlee was too good – AshleyLovescats887 – AshleyLovescats887

The only A+E sing with a bit of sauce... She kinda put something in this one. Although the vibe is ruined when Evan's awful vocal comes in

Edited by Great Username

  • Replies 669
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • prézli

    223

  • KillingYourCareer

    65

  • MusicLoverDude

    53

  • Bussea

    47

Posted
22 hours ago, KillingYourCareer said:

#39

 

Unreachable

6.577

 

Ashlee_Simpson_-_Autobiography.jpg

 

L.O.V.E. (11s):

I Want You (Highest): 3x10: KillingYourCareer, Xtripped, AshleyLovescats887

Can't Have It All (Lowest): 2x3: CamiloPg_, ChooseyLover

 

COMMENTARIES:

absolutely stunning! This album has no skips. – AshleyLovescats887
Also filler. – MusicLoverDude

It's ok, but least essential sing on Autobiography for sure. Lyrics feel like a placeholder first draft, and the melodies are staid. 

Posted
22 hours ago, KillingYourCareer said:

#37

 

Nothing New

6.749

 

Ashlee_Simpson_-_Autobiography.jpg

 

L.O.V.E. (11s):

I Want You (Highest): 3x10: KillingYourCareer, Remmy, AshleeSimpsonFan

Can't Have It All (Lowest): 1x1: AshleyLovescats887

 

COMMENTARIES:

cringe. Taylor did it better. – AshleyLovescats887

Filler but a little better than the two tracks before it. – MusicLoverDude

You know how to GIVE it

BUT you can't take it

It's all just a WASTE

NOW you can save it

 

:heart:

 

She ate with that bridge 

Posted
22 hours ago, KillingYourCareer said:

#36

 

Burnin Up

6.846

 

1200x1200bf-60.jpg

 

L.O.V.E. (11s):

I Want You (Highest): 1x10: Fancyhoodlum

Can't Have It All (Lowest): 2x1: KillingYourCareer, MusicLoverDude

 

COMMENTARIES:

really great! – AshleyLovescats887

One of two duds on this album. This had me doing anything but burnin' up – MusicLoverDude

The Gwen cosplay again... This one is a valiant effort, but sadly still very irritating to listen to... Ashlee, put the reggae bass down...

Posted
22 hours ago, KillingYourCareer said:

#35

 

Say Goodbye

6.846

 

1200x1200bf-60.jpg

 

L.O.V.E. (11s):

I Want You (Highest): 3x10: undermyskin, AshleyLovescats887, Cherish

Can't Have It All (Lowest): 1x1: MusicLoverDude

 

COMMENTARIES:

one of the most sad and wholesome tracks – AshleyLovescats887

It pains me that she ended this banger of an album on this dud. – MusicLoverDude

"'Cause the broken in you doesn't make me run" :heart: Such a quintessential Ashlee lyric

 

Very lovely sing 

Posted
22 hours ago, KillingYourCareer said:

#34

 

What I've Become

7.058

 

Ashlee_Simpson_-_Bittersweet_World.jpg

 

L.O.V.E. (11s):

I Want You (Highest): 4x10: Alldeezy, ainadalkaz, Remmy, PaloSanto

Can't Have It All (Lowest): 3x2: KillingYourCareer, CamiloPg_, AshleyLovescats887

 

COMMENTARIES:

this and no time for tears were my ** in 2008/2009. – ainadalkaz

so angsty and boring – AshleyLovescats887

Pop rock with Timbaland tinged production. It's fine for what it is. – MusicLoverDude

Very representative of the worst parts of Bittersweet World... Underwritten and boring 

Posted
22 hours ago, KillingYourCareer said:

#33

 

Hot Stuff

7.135

 

Ashlee_Simpson_-_Bittersweet_World.jpg

 

 

L.O.V.E. (11s):

I Want You (Highest): 3x10: Bussea, AshleyLovescats887, memo90061

Can't Have It All (Lowest): 1x1: KillingYourCareer

 

COMMENTARIES:

An experimental BOP. Feels like partying in candyland, wonderland, Wonka factory, etc. :johnald: – attention

really hot!! – AshleyLovescats887

It's fine - the verses are pretty but I haven't really revisited it either. – MusicLoverDude

Trauma... This sing needs to be buried deep underground and DELETED from the archives. I'm surprised I gave it higher than a 1

 

Everybody look what I can do
I can bring my leg up all the way
Can she do it? Can she do it?
Piece of cake!

 

Pure HELL. 

Posted
22 hours ago, KillingYourCareer said:

#31

 

Harder Every Day

7.231

 

Ashlee_Simpson_-_Autobiography.jpg

 

L.O.V.E. (11s):

I Want You (Highest): 4x10: KillingYourCareer, Mighty Oaks, AshleyLovescats887, memo90061

Can't Have It All (Lowest): 1x4: Alldeezy

 

COMMENTARIES:

she sounds SO good here but this song never clicked with me for whatever reason. – ainadalkaz

a dealbreaker – AshleyLovescats887

Pretty forgettable – MusicLoverDude

The chorus is so so special :weeps:

 

Trying to be someone that you know you're not
It gets harder every day
All the lonely days
There's no one left to love
You wish life would go away

 

I love the energy switchup from verse 1 to verse 2 away as well. Ugh, I should've given this a 10. It's so good. 

Posted

King of Commenting All the Songs

 

D0vVUYd.thumb.gif.b604501b4938f3f8fb44a5

Posted
6 hours ago, prézli said:

#30

 

Ragdoll

7.307

 

Ashlee_Simpson_-_Bittersweet_World.jpg

 

L.O.V.E. (11s):

I Want You (Highest): 5x9: Fancyhoodlum, ChooseyLover, Cherish, memo90061, AshleeSimpsonFan

Can't Have It All (Lowest): 1x4: AshleyLovescats887

 

COMMENTARIES:

i mean..it's a good closer! – AshleyLovescats887

Cute but forgettable – MusicLoverDude

This sing is a serve 

Posted
6 hours ago, prézli said:

#26

 

No Time for Tears

7.404

 

Ashlee_Simpson_-_Bittersweet_World.jpg

 

L.O.V.E. (11s):

I Want You (Highest): 7x10: Alldeezy, Mighty Oaks, ainadalkaz, Remmy, Great Username, PaloSanto, AshleeSimpsonFan

Can't Have It All (Lowest): 1x3: AshleyLovescats887

 

COMMENTARIES:

This almost got my 11, I played this so much during high school. - Alldeezy

who wrote these lyrics? The ** – AshleyLovescats887

Another song I really enjoy off this album but I haven't really revisited over the years. – MusicLoverDude

Such a classic, bulletproof Ashlee chorus ugh her talent is actually too much. 

 

A MILLION MILES THAT I HAVE GONE

SIGNS THAT SAY TO GIVE IT UP

JUST TEAR ME DOWN OR LIFT ME UP

NO TIME FOR TEARS, NO TIME FOR TEARS

 

:cries:

 

GET UP! GET UP! GET UP TO FEEL BETTER! 

 

:cries: A literal hymn.

Posted
6 hours ago, prézli said:

#24

 

Catch Me When I Fall

7.519

 

1200x1200bf-60.jpg

 

L.O.V.E. (11s): –

I Want You (Highest): 6x10: Fancyhoodlum, Xtripped, Mighty Oaks, Great Username, AshleyLovescats887, MusicLoverDude

Can't Have It All (Lowest): 1x3: Alldeezy

 

COMMENTARIES:

so beautiful and stunning..just like a pirouette – AshleyLovescats887

Man, this hits more with time because being an adult is lonely AF. – MusicLoverDude

That was a classic, that was a classic... 

 

The shift from

 

Is anybody out there?
Does anybody see
That when the lights are off, something's killing me?

 

to

 

Is anybody out there?
Does anybody see
That sometimes loneliness is just a part of me?

 

At her best, her lyrics are so precise and affecting

 

I also love how she sings "so I walk around the city, anything, anything to clear my head" - so conversational, it compounds the emotion 

 

Ugh Ashlee the world was never ready 

Posted
6 hours ago, prézli said:

#23

 

Murder

7.596

 

Ashlee_Simpson_-_Bittersweet_World.jpg

 

L.O.V.E. (11s): 1x11: @AshleyLovescats887

I Want You (Highest): 3x10: Alldeezy, Saddy, SoldierofLove

Can't Have It All (Lowest): 1x3: KillingYourCareer

 

COMMENTARIES:

my fav from her discography, it's really cute. – AshleyLovescats887

For being a song about Murder, it's pretty mid. – MusicLoverDude

By far her best attempt at the white reggae vibe. She really commits to the bit with this one, and the sing is strong enough for that to be genuinely powerful rather than a cringy mess

 

So don't keep me in the DARK 'cause I'll find the light - FIND THE LIGHT

 

The beat goes crazy, by far the best Ashlee/Timbaland collab 

  • Like 1
Posted
6 hours ago, prézli said:

#22

 

L.O.V.E.

7.653

 

51-Y89VBrIL._UF1000,1000_QL80_.jpg

 

L.O.V.E. (11s): –

I Want You (Highest): 4x10: Alldeezy, Xtripped, MusicLoverDude, memo90061

Can't Have It All (Lowest): 1x1: Bussea

 

COMMENTARIES:

a classic, but it lacks a little something. it doesn't kick a punch like boyfriend or la la. – ainadalkaz

I used to love this song but I feel like it's going to be EXTREMELY overrated in this rate and now I kinda find it grating – Bussea

did someone force her to sing this? – AshleyLovescats887

Another banger! – MusicLoverDude

Baffling sing. Why she looked at all the sings on I Am Me and decided THIS one would be the blueprint for Bittersweet World is beyond me. Ashlee we can't help you if you won't help yourself 

Posted
6 hours ago, prézli said:

#21

 

Surrender

7.731

 

Ashlee_Simpson_-_Autobiography.jpg

 

L.O.V.E. (11s): –

I Want You (Highest): 2x10: attention, Remmy

Can't Have It All (Lowest): 3x5: Saddy, Bends, MusicLoverDude

 

COMMENTARIES:

My close contender to an 11. This song just feel good and makes you want to be an optimist. I've always likened the guitar solo being a nod to "My Sharona" by The Knack – attention

cuteeee.. – AshleyLovescats887

Filler. Not bad, but not really good. – MusicLoverDude

The verses are literally empty space, but that massive chorus more than makes up for it

 

The pre-choruses are amazing too:

 

Oooopen up your eyes, don't you know you only GET ONE LIFE?

Ooopen up your eyes, don't you know you're only WASTING TIME? 

Ooopen up your eyes, don't you know that IT'S YOUR LIIIIIFE?

 

:heart: Pure joy

  • Like 1
Posted

i saw 3 notifs and thought my 11 was out before top 20... i was ready to report everyone in this thread

 

thankfully i won't have to do that

WhE7BdD.png

Posted

Giving It All Away is such a beautiful song it deserved top 15. What happened, Boyfriends? :biblionana:

MURDER ALREADY OUT? :biblio:

LOVE NOT EVEN MAKING THE TOP 20??? :psyduck:

 

I'm trying to remain positive. :sadviolin:

Posted

Pretty pissed at how What I've Become and Burnin' Up are so low. Especially WIB - it's a lot better than several BW tracks ugh.

Posted

Harder Everyday too :weeps: I love that song, should've given it a 10 ugh. I will sabotage the other mid tracks next time!

Posted

RAGDOLL only #30??? This deserves top 15 at least!!!

Endless Summer and Giving It All Away above this??? HOWWWWWW :shakeno: 

 

I love Kicking and Screaming but I think it's fairly placed.

 

No Time for Tears is great too, I would put it top 25. Especially above Sorry which is sooo overrated.

Posted

Murder is great too, but I'm still pissed it's above Ragdoll, which is the superior song!

 

I'm surprised at L.O.V.E. :eek: It's not my favorite so I would also put it below top 20 but I thought it's well beloved here. Well happy to have my other favorites get in the top 20 :heart2:

Posted
  • Like 1
Posted
2 hours ago, prézli said:

By Wednesday, I hope you can't sleep! We'll see which songs miss out the Top 10 as the next update is coming at 4PM EDT today by @KillingYourCareer which means in 9 hours!

I'll have to miss this update :chick3: I'll be checking in afterwards though! 

Posted

I can't wait.

 

Better Off for Top 10.

Posted

hey gay people 

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.