duybeeGAshantiGA Posted August 2 Posted August 2 1 hour ago, allforyou said: I think Cowboy Carter pretty much has AOTY on lock. I don't think Gaga will ever win that category. Gaga was close many times before. If it wasnt for 21 BTW would have won. TFM and Love for Sale were close to.
Comedor Posted August 2 Posted August 2 I don't see it for Gaga. And the academy is running out of time to give Beyonce AOTY. She deserves it, but the way she creates music (samples and collaboration with multiple songwriters) is apparently not what the Grannies see as AOTY worthy.
Kiss It Better Posted August 2 Posted August 2 Bey? maybe Gaga? nope, unless she made something that's really incredible and super successful and caught gp attention the way Shallow did
Solaria Posted August 2 Posted August 2 3 hours ago, FolkLover1989 said: Gaga massively acclaimed where?? Bey will soon enough and she will deserve it. There is barely any Gaga album in Decade end lists or all time lists. The Fame is getting retrospective acclaim that's it. ASIB was great but other than that there is no universal acclaim. When Gaga makes a good album , we will talk about AOTY Gaga is very much acclaimed, what are you talking about? She might have not won AOTY but she has won 13 Grammys and an Oscar for BOS, that's plenty of acclaim from two of the biggest institutions in entertainment
Bey'Knight Posted August 2 Posted August 2 I wouldn't bet on either but I reckon Gaga is more likely to win than Bey.
Badgalbriel Posted August 2 Posted August 2 10 minutes ago, Solaria said: Gaga is very much acclaimed, what are you talking about? She might have not won AOTY but she has won 13 Grammys and an Oscar for BOS, that's plenty of acclaim from two of the biggest institutions in entertainment Gaga is acclaimed as a performer mostly. But her music has not been that acclaimed, tbh. 1
Eternal220 Posted August 2 Posted August 2 Beyonce will eventually. But how is gaga acclaimed other than her debut?
OrgVisual Posted August 2 Posted August 2 23 minutes ago, Solaria said: Gaga is very much acclaimed, what are you talking about? She might have not won AOTY but she has won 13 Grammys and an Oscar for BOS, that's plenty of acclaim from two of the biggest institutions in entertainment Rihanna won 9 Grammys too, can we bet on R9 winning AOTY too?
mons†er Posted August 2 Posted August 2 Beyonce has a better chance with Cowboy Carter as well as with the final installment from of the ACT trilogy being Rock. I don't see LG winning it and I'll tell you why. She doesn't command the power that she used to back in the day and her influence on music isn't as impactful as it used to be. She also hasn't had an album that has shifted the conversation, changed the curve of music or has had a big album outside of ASIB. As a former LG stan, it's unfortunate because she really deserved it for TFM or BTW. AP could've won had she not made the plot of the album so pretentious IMO.
Erreur2 La Nature Posted August 2 Posted August 2 No shade but I can't imagine Lady Gaga winning this. Beyoncé is among the most awarded artists of all time at the Grannys, they'll probably end up giving it to her at least once.
elincomprendid Posted August 2 Posted August 2 4 hours ago, Lagerfeld said: Do we think there is a chance that either could win with their upcoming albums? I think current state Beyonce has already reached her limit in audience approval. Meaning I don't think right now she can release something that could make voters have a much different perspective tuve about her music. So the only chance I see as she a stablished name is if when she is significantly older releases some "sentimental" album Gaga I think is long gone in acclaim reach and I don't think her figure is as established as Beyonce to get a Grammy from an old album situation so kinda can't see it happening
Baegalme Posted August 2 Posted August 2 I think Beyonce can still win one I don't think Gaga ever will unfortunately tbh
Kukai Posted August 2 Posted August 2 3 hours ago, allforyou said: The album was very acclaimed though and I think that because of it being a country album it'll impress the voters Let's be real Taylor Swift's album is winning AOTY. She's had a huge album campaign and her Beetle-like mania has been crazy. Beyoncé's album was quickly forgotten and didn't sell as much.
elincomprendid Posted August 2 Posted August 2 4 hours ago, OreGuy said: Just like Taylor will get an Oscar nom the more she desperately attempts to write a song for a movie that cannot be considered an album reject. If you think that's the reason Taylor doesn't have Oscars noms yo user so out of touch with reality it's concerning 💀 Or maybe you know but you are just an OTH guess we'll never know!
elincomprendid Posted August 2 Posted August 2 Just now, Kukai said: Let's be real Taylor Swift's album is winning AOTY. She's had a huge album campaign and her Beetle-like mania has been crazy. Beyoncé's album was quickly forgotten and didn't sell as much. Taylor ain't winning AOTY this year Also she has barely done an album Grammys campaign for Midnights (and even less for TTPD)😭
Kukai Posted August 2 Posted August 2 Just now, elincomprendid said: Taylor ain't winning AOTY this year Also she has barely done an album Grammys campaign for Midnights (and even less for TTPD)😭 Yes she is bookmark me. Without a doubt, Taylor's album is by far the best selling album this year and had a huge media presence caused by the frenzy of Taylor's popularity. The fame and fan mania around Taylor rn is crazy. I love Beyoncé's album but it was quickly forgotten.
Kristie Kuwa Posted August 2 Posted August 2 Beyonce no. She doesnt play industry politics anymore, she doesnt promote, she doesnt hit the singer-songwriter crowd, she doesnt have a good narrative other than "she finally wins her AOTY" because shes already the most awarded artist ever. All the points lead to her never winning AOTY, and none of them have anything to do with the quality of the output
Shinning Posted August 2 Posted August 2 50 minutes ago, Kukai said: Let's be real Taylor Swift's album is winning AOTY. She's had a huge album campaign and her Beetle-like mania has been crazy. Beyoncé's album was quickly forgotten and didn't sell as much. But I though the Grammys were awards for music excellence without regarding commercial success?
Solaria Posted August 2 Posted August 2 2 hours ago, Badgalbriel said: Gaga is acclaimed as a performer mostly. But her music has not been that acclaimed, tbh. That's not true at all. TFM and Born This Way are very much acclaimed, a 78/100 in 2009 is basically equivalent to a 88/100 post poptimism. She just hasn't had a critically acclaimed album in the same vein after BTW
Badgalbriel Posted August 2 Posted August 2 2 minutes ago, Solaria said: That's not true at all. TFM and Born This Way are very much acclaimed, a 78/100 in 2009 is basically equivalent to a 88/100 post poptimism. She just hasn't had a critically acclaimed album in the same vein after BTW Exactly. It's been a decade since her music was acclaimed.
Rotunda Posted August 2 Posted August 2 Bey could sneak out a win during a year with the right artists splitting votes with each other, but it's clear the voting body's current makeup isn't favorable to her. Gaga is past both her commercial and creative peak I think. 1
Pheromosa Posted August 2 Posted August 2 Gaga hasn't had a great album in a long time. Not sure if she still has it in her. Bey well…some have a vendetta against her but they're expanding the committee by a lot this year so I'd say this is her best chance. 1
Enzo Posted August 2 Posted August 2 People talking about acclaim, please Grammys are all about sales and streams nowadays
Recommended Posts