charts discussion HDD: Taylor Swift 13x #1 73k, Chappell Roan #4 54k, Charli #9 41k, Ice Spice #34 20k

[Popboi.]

4 minutes ago, Loca said:

Not Morgan about to outdo Taylor. Maybe HE is the music industry after all. 

We're sure you would love that

[dumbsparce]

The 13th week at number #1 being the most organic of them all. A Hufflepuff tea 

[LegaMyth]

Are people really streaming Morgan Wallen's music like that? 

Edited July 30 by LegaMyth

[Bosque]

9 minutes ago, LegaMyth said:

Are people really streaming Morgan Wallen's music like that? 

Americans are 

[Kitboga]

1 hour ago, dumbsparce said:

The 13th week at number #1 being the most organic of them all. A Hufflepuff tea 

Every single week was organic, including the 3 that wasn't secured from streaming only. 
 

She has the stardom, the demand & the capability to outsell others, therefore she…outsold the others: there's no complaining

[makeme]

Taylor blocking 

 

Can someone post Brat and Chappell album chart runs 

[Popboi.]

19 minutes ago, Kitboga said:

Every single week was organic, including the 3 that wasn't secured from streaming only. 
 

She has the stardom, the demand & the capability to outsell others, therefore she…outsold the others: there's no complaining

The ones most pissed are the ones that can't grasp a voice note memo was enough to block their precious favs 

[on the line]

1 hour ago, Bosque said:

Americans are 

This is an American chart lol

 

Anyway.

 

Good for Taylor, but wow the charts are sad overall. Good for Chappell and Charli for being top 10 at least.

[liam13]

Taylor's downfall is on leave for a brat summer vacation on chromatica it seemeth 

[Jay L]

Charli back in the top ten Brat summer going strong!

[MatiRod]

Charli is doing main pop girl numbers. I hope she writes an autobiography one day because she's had one hell of a ride in the music industry. Her and Sia have been through it, up and down, pop stars and songwriters for others, until finally hitting it big unexpectedly after 10+ years in the industry.

[naval23]

Brat being Charli's first album with longevity is insane 

[1989]

6 hours ago, DevilsRollTheDice said:

Am I misunderstanding the point you're trying to make? She's literally number 1 for a thirteenth week 

OTHs on ATRL being loud and wrong about Taylor as usual 

[Assassin]

Miss Fart really did turn out to be a fad.  

[Calvin]

13th week at top 

[Taylor fanboy]

Ms. Roan is one Deluxe away from the number 1 spot. WOW.

[Squall]

Can we send a message to HDD so they recount? It doesn't make any sense, ATRL told me no one cares about TTPD and ATRL are professionals  

[Brikenbur]

14 hours ago, By the Water said:

2024 pop girls' albums 15th week:

TTPD - #1(+3)

ES - #23 (-4)

CC - #51(-41)

 

She seems to be doing just fine 

2024's pop girls' album critics ranking overall (I could add user ratings too ):

 

CC:

Metacritic - 91  |  AOTY - 87

 

ES: 

Metacritic - 84 |  AOTY - 76

 

TTPD:

Metacritic - 76  |  AOTY - 71 

 

Don't worry this is ALL we care about; not her selfishly trying to remain No. 1 inauthentically for what?  Arts not charts babe, quality over quantity, but, thanks for the latest BB200 update!!! 

 

                       

Edited July 31 by Brikenbur

[Enrique523]

Ice Spice not even top 20 

 

Taylor back at #1, love to see it. But Morgan Wallen just won't go away 

[Feanor]

19 minutes ago, Brikenbur said:

Don't worry this is ALL we care about;

Clearly not, as you ran to this thread in 1. the chart section to make a post about 2. a Billboard 200 prediction in which you commented about 3. SPS numbers.

Maybe if you cared less about charts, you wouldn't be making non-sensical comments about an album with already 5M units experiencing a slow-down like every other 2024 album (the key difference being those album are already slowing down at just the 1M mark) 

 

19 minutes ago, Brikenbur said:

not her selfishly trying to remain No. 1 inauthentically for what?  

Inauthentic how? Can you point me to where Billboard is labeling Taylor's and her album's success as fraud? Not ATRL user Brikenbur now replacing Billboard as the new authority on what chart success is valid and authentic. 

 

19 minutes ago, Brikenbur said:

Arts not charts babe, quality over quantity,

Are those critic scores supposed to define quality? Cause I got news for you: They are just as subjective as the tastes of the masses. 

Quality is not defined by charts or two dozen journalists. 

 

19 minutes ago, Brikenbur said:

but, thanks for the latest BB200 update!!! 

 

                       

Enters a thread about BB200 predictions, proceeds to be bothered by BB200 stats being brought up.

 

[Enrique523]

Once again, seeing people talking about "arts not charts" as if all of your faves aren't extremely commercial pop stars making music for the charts to begin with, the jokes write themselves 

 

Just stop with the bullsh*t already, this is a POP MUSIC forum. Try to find new things to hate Taylor about, those tired hypocritical arguments are going nowhere at this point 

[Enrique523]

16 hours ago, Loca said:

Not Morgan about to outdo Taylor. Maybe HE is the music industry after all. 

Taylor is too busy being GLOBAL, his racist local ass can't relate 

[Brikenbur]

11 minutes ago, Feanor said:

Clearly not, as you ran to this thread in 1. the chart section to make a post about 2. a Billboard 200 prediction in which you commented about 3. SPS numbers.

Maybe if you cared less about charts, you wouldn't be making non-sensical comments about an album with already 5M units experiencing a slow-down like every other 2024 album (the key difference being those album are already slowing down at just the 1M mark) 

 

Inauthentic how? Can you point me to where Billboard is labeling Taylor's and her album's success as fraud? Not ATRL user Brikenbur now replacing Billboard as the new authority on what chart success is valid and authentic. 

 

Are those critic scores supposed to define quality? Cause I got news for you: They are just as subjective as the tastes of the masses. 

Quality is not defined by charts or two dozen journalists. 

 

Enters a thread about BB200 predictions, proceeds to be bothered by BB200 stats being brought up.

 

Girl what?

[Badgalbriel]

43 minutes ago, Brikenbur said:

2024's pop girls' album critics ranking overall (I could add user ratings too ):

 

CC:

Metacritic - 91  |  AOTY - 87

 

ES: 

Metacritic - 84 |  AOTY - 76

 

TTPD:

Metacritic - 76  |  AOTY - 71 

 

Don't worry this is ALL we care about; not her selfishly trying to remain No. 1 inauthentically for what?  Arts not charts babe, quality over quantity, but, thanks for the latest BB200 update!!! 

 

                       

Can you tell me what is inauthentic about this week's position? 

[Feanor]

2 minutes ago, Brikenbur said:

Girl what?

People's reaction to non-sense like this:

 

17 hours ago, Brikenbur said:

Seems like those Manuscript Deluxe Limited Edition CD's are starting to loose their weight up against the inevitable decline in SPS numbers