Cruel Summer Posted September 7 Posted September 7 Just now, FolkLover1989 said: Wait As much as I love 1989 Why are 6 1989 songs in Top 30 You all be serious. cowboy Like Me you deserved better When the top three is Style, Blank Space, and Clean 4
gagacasanova Posted September 7 Posted September 7 I can not even BEGIN to describe Treacherous... the bridge alone... MOTHER**** 2
folkloreking Posted September 7 Posted September 7 The way this is going, I think Born Again is next. Just hopeless.
frankvert Posted September 7 Posted September 7 TREACHEROUS BRIDGE IS LITERALLY GRADUATIONS, WEDDINGS, FUNERALS. WHAT THE **** IS WRONG WITH ALL OF YOU 5 1
holyground13 Posted September 7 Posted September 7 Treacher-slay at just #30 is just beyond ridiculous. Not when there's still just-good material here. "Nothing safe is worth the drive" is an amazing line in context. The whole song is but I'm too lazy to quote it all. 2
By the Water Posted September 7 Posted September 7 I can't believe I made the mistake of giving a 1939 song a 10 and now it's my only 10 left 5
FolkLover1989 Posted September 7 Posted September 7 Just now, Cruel Summer said: When the top three is Style, Blank Space, and Clean I think I have made some mistakes with my 11s now My 4 11s are still left
holyground13 Posted September 7 Posted September 7 1 minute ago, Cruel Summer said: When the top three is Style, Blank Space, and Clean I wouldn't be opposed to it!
Michael196 Posted September 7 Posted September 7 (edited) @Cruel Summer I want to tell you that soon it'll get better, but I would be lying edit: where's your 11?? Edited September 7 by Michael196
Brooklyn Baby Posted September 7 Author Posted September 7 29. champagne problems 8.577 Saviours (11s): Cruel Summer, llikeh Stans (10s): Heldenzeit, Bosque, wehavetostan, Starchild, Teen Spirit, Ms. Togekiss, heckinglovato, SoSickOfThatSOL, TMRA, K$Ellie, Bartender, Blood Magic, Rev8, Taylor fanboy, greeneyedsoul, chiliam, Where are you now?, Diarrhoea, fab, beagle, Hooker Barbie, ellis-bell, BOAZ, Holy Ground, ONOPKA, fridayteenage, Great Username, GuyNextDoor, LVP, Mezik, Tedwards, G.U.Y_Del_Rey, idkwiam, wastedpotential, Ampersand13, Fitzswiftie, PerfectSacrifice, AbeHicks, iamanearthling, halcyonday, Gorjesspazze9, AshleyLovescats887, Mr. Duff, Enrique523, reputation1989, chosensparkles, freakum., Vespertine, folkloreking, Life Savers, itsjem, Theluckyone, Tusk, 1989, Solaria, pinkbowvintage, NordicGuy, PaloSanto, SylMacPer, tb6591 Admirers (9s): Lorenzo22, Achilles., NewStanner, pavi, PoisonedIvy, Kyle-x, byzantium, Flames2Embers, Kyungsoowift, creativity, Catch22, Dear Reader, Ger.vaz, Mocha, burninredhot, Axolotl, D-@-N, Riverbank, Arrows, 305, Namigo, a_d_22, CamiloPg_, sanzo, Live To Tell, DevilsRollTheDice, terrorblade, Safe&Sound, Flower, roso, Velvet Night, greento, RihannaLoverrr, Miles., badideairght, gagacasanova, MidnightsAtPeace, Forever Winter, tjspy, Støned, Top Dash, TheArgonaut, The Music Industry Haters (1s): SleepingTigers Saboteurs (0s): TaylenaStan, NEX, FolkLover1989 Comments 1989 10 - "Arguably the best bridge of her career." Where are you now? 10 - "Heavenly ballad from our wintry album evermore. Aside from obvious praises for the song's storytelling and overall build, I'd like to highlight the instrumental section after the 2nd chorus containing the angelic choir of Taylor's ahhhh's - gives me goosebumps every time." wastedpotential 10 - "Give it up to Lord for triple faking us out here, on the album that's supposedly all about fantasy stories and is completely detached from Her personal life, She's out here writing a rejected engagement song from the perspective of the rejecter and their endless guilt, with Her boyfriend who we all secretly thought was engaged to Her for the LONGEST time. I think "poor, messed up girl who feels awful after rejecting a proposal" is quite possibly the most unique concept Lord has ever run with. I think this is going to stay a few steps behind august (and maybe never as popular) for a long time and become an enduring cult classic as more and more and more TayLovers pass this onto their children, much like my parents did to me with beloved Beatles album tracks. Lord's greatest skill is Her ability to write about a very specific and unique scenario, but make it applicable to You the Listener™, and to make it fit into Your life, and to make you think 'gosh, is She reading my diary?' This hymn is coming at that from a side-on angle, since it's not written as this universal experience (if every proposee was rejecting their ring, DeBeers would be in shambles nnn), but it's written as a universal hypothetical. I think we all imagine proposing to someone at some point in the future (or have proposed to someone, or have been proposed to, or want to be proposed to OR SOME OTHER PERMUTATION I CANNOT THINK OF RIGHT NOW), and even if you/they did (or you hope you/they do) say yes, there will always be that 'what if?' thought. Lord, being the genius that She is, took that thought (which probably came to Her while She was waiting for Hobo to propose to her), and spun it into this grand piano ballad that now gets several minute ovations, and spawned some of Lord's best one-liners (I think every OTH/THOTS who comes after Lord's lyricism on Twitter will be blasted with "Your Midas touch on the Chevy Door/November flush and your flannel cure" for the rest of time, and I think that's what they deserve), and has built an insane legacy for what seems to have been a hypothetical situation born out of waiting for her loser (ex-) boyfriend to take a step forward." Achilles. 9 - "Incredible song but not necessarily deserving of the way the fandom's singled it out over the rest of the album." SLUTTVFTV 8.3 - "Meh... I used to love it but it's grown off of me. ****** in the head is ICONIC but the song is just ok. Wish there was more production." blown away 7.3 - "Love the storytelling and the instrumentation used on the song. It sounds like a tale told around a campfire at night." holyground13 7 - "It's never been a favourite of mine but I don't want to tank it." Edge of Glory 6.5 - "'What a shame she's F*CKED in the head' is peak but the rest is kinda mid unfortunately." Reveal, Part 6 Results (So Far) Spoiler 50. Don't Blame Me - 8.127 49. Maroon - 8.129 48. willow - 8.138 47. Anti-Hero - 8.179 46. Cornelia Street - 8.181 45. Safe & Sound (feat. The Civil Wars) - 8.189 44. ...Ready for It? - 8.203 43. the 1 - 8.205 42. ivy - 8.206 41. cowboy like me - 8.210 40. seven - 8.220 39. Holy Ground - 8.268 38. Mine - 8.294 37. illicit affairs - 8.303 36. Dear John - 8.303 35. Long Live - 8.328 34. Call It What You Want - 8.467 33. You're on Your Own, Kid - 8.540 32. right where you left me - 8.550 31. Fearless - 8.562 30. Treacherous - 8.568 29. champagne problems - 8.577
frankvert Posted September 7 Posted September 7 5 minutes ago, Forever Winter said: Haters (1s): creativity All alone, in the corner of gym class, last to be picked for a game of kickball. How does it feel to be a fat, ugly, smelly b!tch? @creativity. 2
By the Water Posted September 7 Posted September 7 Out of the Charts, Getaway Fart, Corona Summer and disgust top 30 but y'all hate Hack?
Flower Posted September 7 Posted September 7 25 minutes ago, Forever Winter said: Reveal hidden contents 32. right where you left me 8.550 Comments Forever Winter 11 - "My Eras Tour surprise song and my #2 TS song of all time. The structure of this song is unlike any other song she's ever done. This is peak lyricism. Wordy in the best way possible with amazing, ever-changing melodies (TTPD Taylor, take note!). It was so wordy that she messed up during Santa Clara N1 (not that I was complaining because we got 2 extra minutes with her on stage. Did I mention AARON DESSNER was there too? That night was f**king insane. I still can't believe this song exists." Reveal hidden contents 50. Don't Blame Me - 8.127 49. Maroon - 8.129 48. willow - 8.138 47. Anti-Hero - 8.179 46. Cornelia Street - 8.181 45. Safe & Sound (feat. The Civil Wars) - 8.189 44. ...Ready for It? - 8.203 43. the 1 - 8.205 42. ivy - 8.206 41. cowboy like me - 8.210 40. seven - 8.220 39. Holy Ground - 8.268 38. Mine - 8.294 37. illicit affairs - 8.303 36. Dear John - 8.303 35. Long Live - 8.328 34. Call It What You Want - 8.467 33. You're on Your Own, Kid - 8.540 32. right where you left me - 8.550 I was also at N1 Santa Clara @Forever Winter (Outside of the Venue BUT ANYWAYS) I WAS FERAL when i heard it live as a surprise song. One of her best songs. 1
Cruel Summer Posted September 7 Posted September 7 YES GURL GODGOD GODBLEMS, YOU QUEEN This has become my FAVORITE Taylor song recently, and it's only grown over the years. +29 spots the year for a reason. Oh I love her, words fail me
Catch22 Posted September 7 Posted September 7 THE BEST SONG ON EVERMORE OUT WHEN THERE IS STILL TTDS?
FolkLover1989 Posted September 7 Posted September 7 Sorry guys but I hate to sabotage Champagne Problems I didn't want it in Top 10 But I didn't knew 6 1989 songs will make Top 28 Insanity 2
folkloreking Posted September 7 Posted September 7 2 minutes ago, Forever Winter said: 29. champagne problems 8.577 Saviours (11s): Cruel Summer, llikeh Stans (10s): Heldenzeit, Bosque, wehavetostan, Starchild, Teen Spirit, Ms. Togekiss, heckinglovato, SoSickOfThatSOL, TMRA, K$Ellie, Bartender, Blood Magic, Rev8, Taylor fanboy, greeneyedsoul, chiliam, Where are you now?, Diarrhoea, fab, beagle, Hooker Barbie, ellis-bell, BOAZ, Holy Ground, ONOPKA, fridayteenage, Great Username, GuyNextDoor, LVP, Mezik, Tedwards, G.U.Y_Del_Rey, idkwiam, wastedpotential, Ampersand13, Fitzswiftie, PerfectSacrifice, AbeHicks, iamanearthling, halcyonday, Gorjesspazze9, AshleyLovescats887, Mr. Duff, Enrique523, reputation1989, chosensparkles, freakum., Vespertine, folkloreking, Life Savers, itsjem, Theluckyone, Tusk, 1989, Solaria, pinkbowvintage, NordicGuy, PaloSanto, SylMacPer, tb6591 Admirers (9s): Lorenzo22, Achilles., NewStanner, pavi, PoisonedIvy, Kyle-x, byzantium, Flames2Embers, Kyungsoowift, creativity, Catch22, Dear Reader, Ger.vaz, Mocha, burninredhot, Axolotl, D-@-N, Riverbank, Arrows, 305, Namigo, a_d_22, CamiloPg_, sanzo, Live To Tell, DevilsRollTheDice, terrorblade, Safe&Sound, Flower, roso, Velvet Night, greento, RihannaLoverrr, Miles., badideairght, gagacasanova, MidnightsAtPeace, Forever Winter, tjspy, Støned, Top Dash, TheArgonaut, The Music Industry Haters (1s): SleepingTigers Saboteurs (0s): TaylenaStan, NEX, FolkLover1989 Comments 1989 10 - "Arguably the best bridge of her career." Where are you now? 10 - "Heavenly ballad from our wintry album evermore. Aside from obvious praises for the song's storytelling and overall build, I'd like to highlight the instrumental section after the 2nd chorus containing the angelic choir of Taylor's ahhhh's - gives me goosebumps every time." wastedpotential 10 - "Give it up to Lord for triple faking us out here, on the album that's supposedly all about fantasy stories and is completely detached from Her personal life, She's out here writing a rejected engagement song from the perspective of the rejecter and their endless guilt, with Her boyfriend who we all secretly thought was engaged to Her for the LONGEST time. I think "poor, messed up girl who feels awful after rejecting a proposal" is quite possibly the most unique concept Lord has ever run with. I think this is going to stay a few steps behind august (and maybe never as popular) for a long time and become an enduring cult classic as more and more and more TayLovers pass this onto their children, much like my parents did to me with beloved Beatles album tracks. Lord's greatest skill is Her ability to write about a very specific and unique scenario, but make it applicable to You the Listener™, and to make it fit into Your life, and to make you think 'gosh, is She reading my diary?' This hymn is coming at that from a side-on angle, since it's not written as this universal experience (if every proposee was rejecting their ring, DeBeers would be in shambles nnn), but it's written as a universal hypothetical. I think we all imagine proposing to someone at some point in the future (or have proposed to someone, or have been proposed to, or want to be proposed to OR SOME OTHER PERMUTATION I CANNOT THINK OF RIGHT NOW), and even if you/they did (or you hope you/they do) say yes, there will always be that 'what if?' thought. Lord, being the genius that She is, took that thought (which probably came to Her while She was waiting for Hobo to propose to her), and spun it into this grand piano ballad that now gets several minute ovations, and spawned some of Lord's best one-liners (I think every OTH/THOTS who comes after Lord's lyricism on Twitter will be blasted with "Your Midas touch on the Chevy Door/November flush and your flannel cure" for the rest of time, and I think that's what they deserve), and has built an insane legacy for what seems to have been a hypothetical situation born out of waiting for her loser (ex-) boyfriend to take a step forward." Achilles. 9 - "Incredible song but not necessarily deserving of the way the fandom's singled it out over the rest of the album." SLUTTVFTV 8.3 - "Meh... I used to love it but it's grown off of me. ****** in the head is ICONIC but the song is just ok. Wish there was more production." blown away 7.3 - "Love the storytelling and the instrumentation used on the song. It sounds like a tale told around a campfire at night." holyground13 7 - "It's never been a favourite of mine but I don't want to tank it." Edge of Glory 6.5 - "'What a shame she's F*CKED in the head' is peak but the rest is kinda mid unfortunately." Reveal, Part 6 Results (So Far) Reveal hidden contents 50. Don't Blame Me - 8.127 49. Maroon - 8.129 48. willow - 8.138 47. Anti-Hero - 8.179 46. Cornelia Street - 8.181 45. Safe & Sound (feat. The Civil Wars) - 8.189 44. ...Ready for It? - 8.203 43. the 1 - 8.205 42. ivy - 8.206 41. cowboy like me - 8.210 40. seven - 8.220 39. Holy Ground - 8.268 38. Mine - 8.294 37. illicit affairs - 8.303 36. Dear John - 8.303 35. Long Live - 8.328 34. Call It What You Want - 8.467 33. You're on Your Own, Kid - 8.540 32. right where you left me - 8.550 31. Fearless - 8.562 30. Treacherous - 8.568 29. champagne problems - 8.577 I- im just. Delicate above this. ZERO words.
ATRL Moderator Ampersand13 Posted September 7 ATRL Moderator Posted September 7 What is this honey? I really... I. Let me take a nap 2
TaylenaStan Posted September 7 Posted September 7 2 minutes ago, Forever Winter said: 29. champagne problems 8.577 Saviours (11s): Cruel Summer, llikeh Stans (10s): Heldenzeit, Bosque, wehavetostan, Starchild, Teen Spirit, Ms. Togekiss, heckinglovato, SoSickOfThatSOL, TMRA, K$Ellie, Bartender, Blood Magic, Rev8, Taylor fanboy, greeneyedsoul, chiliam, Where are you now?, Diarrhoea, fab, beagle, Hooker Barbie, ellis-bell, BOAZ, Holy Ground, ONOPKA, fridayteenage, Great Username, GuyNextDoor, LVP, Mezik, Tedwards, G.U.Y_Del_Rey, idkwiam, wastedpotential, Ampersand13, Fitzswiftie, PerfectSacrifice, AbeHicks, iamanearthling, halcyonday, Gorjesspazze9, AshleyLovescats887, Mr. Duff, Enrique523, reputation1989, chosensparkles, freakum., Vespertine, folkloreking, Life Savers, itsjem, Theluckyone, Tusk, 1989, Solaria, pinkbowvintage, NordicGuy, PaloSanto, SylMacPer, tb6591 Admirers (9s): Lorenzo22, Achilles., NewStanner, pavi, PoisonedIvy, Kyle-x, byzantium, Flames2Embers, Kyungsoowift, creativity, Catch22, Dear Reader, Ger.vaz, Mocha, burninredhot, Axolotl, D-@-N, Riverbank, Arrows, 305, Namigo, a_d_22, CamiloPg_, sanzo, Live To Tell, DevilsRollTheDice, terrorblade, Safe&Sound, Flower, roso, Velvet Night, greento, RihannaLoverrr, Miles., badideairght, gagacasanova, MidnightsAtPeace, Forever Winter, tjspy, Støned, Top Dash, TheArgonaut, The Music Industry Haters (1s): SleepingTigers Saboteurs (0s): TaylenaStan, NEX, FolkLover1989 Comments 1989 10 - "Arguably the best bridge of her career." Where are you now? 10 - "Heavenly ballad from our wintry album evermore. Aside from obvious praises for the song's storytelling and overall build, I'd like to highlight the instrumental section after the 2nd chorus containing the angelic choir of Taylor's ahhhh's - gives me goosebumps every time." wastedpotential 10 - "Give it up to Lord for triple faking us out here, on the album that's supposedly all about fantasy stories and is completely detached from Her personal life, She's out here writing a rejected engagement song from the perspective of the rejecter and their endless guilt, with Her boyfriend who we all secretly thought was engaged to Her for the LONGEST time. I think "poor, messed up girl who feels awful after rejecting a proposal" is quite possibly the most unique concept Lord has ever run with. I think this is going to stay a few steps behind august (and maybe never as popular) for a long time and become an enduring cult classic as more and more and more TayLovers pass this onto their children, much like my parents did to me with beloved Beatles album tracks. Lord's greatest skill is Her ability to write about a very specific and unique scenario, but make it applicable to You the Listener™, and to make it fit into Your life, and to make you think 'gosh, is She reading my diary?' This hymn is coming at that from a side-on angle, since it's not written as this universal experience (if every proposee was rejecting their ring, DeBeers would be in shambles nnn), but it's written as a universal hypothetical. I think we all imagine proposing to someone at some point in the future (or have proposed to someone, or have been proposed to, or want to be proposed to OR SOME OTHER PERMUTATION I CANNOT THINK OF RIGHT NOW), and even if you/they did (or you hope you/they do) say yes, there will always be that 'what if?' thought. Lord, being the genius that She is, took that thought (which probably came to Her while She was waiting for Hobo to propose to her), and spun it into this grand piano ballad that now gets several minute ovations, and spawned some of Lord's best one-liners (I think every OTH/THOTS who comes after Lord's lyricism on Twitter will be blasted with "Your Midas touch on the Chevy Door/November flush and your flannel cure" for the rest of time, and I think that's what they deserve), and has built an insane legacy for what seems to have been a hypothetical situation born out of waiting for her loser (ex-) boyfriend to take a step forward." Achilles. 9 - "Incredible song but not necessarily deserving of the way the fandom's singled it out over the rest of the album." SLUTTVFTV 8.3 - "Meh... I used to love it but it's grown off of me. ****** in the head is ICONIC but the song is just ok. Wish there was more production." blown away 7.3 - "Love the storytelling and the instrumentation used on the song. It sounds like a tale told around a campfire at night." holyground13 7 - "It's never been a favourite of mine but I don't want to tank it." Edge of Glory 6.5 - "'What a shame she's F*CKED in the head' is peak but the rest is kinda mid unfortunately." Reveal, Part 6 Results (So Far) Reveal hidden contents 50. Don't Blame Me - 8.127 49. Maroon - 8.129 48. willow - 8.138 47. Anti-Hero - 8.179 46. Cornelia Street - 8.181 45. Safe & Sound (feat. The Civil Wars) - 8.189 44. ...Ready for It? - 8.203 43. the 1 - 8.205 42. ivy - 8.206 41. cowboy like me - 8.210 40. seven - 8.220 39. Holy Ground - 8.268 38. Mine - 8.294 37. illicit affairs - 8.303 36. Dear John - 8.303 35. Long Live - 8.328 34. Call It What You Want - 8.467 33. You're on Your Own, Kid - 8.540 32. right where you left me - 8.550 31. Fearless - 8.562 30. Treacherous - 8.568 29. champagne problems - 8.577 nn obviously this is not a 0/10 song, its more like 8/10 but its not even top 10 on evermore for me and i know its a fan fav so i had to sabotage this
Taylor fanboy Posted September 7 Posted September 7 (edited) Tis The Divine Sermon above Coke Problems?! WE CHEER! Edited September 7 by Taylor fanboy 3 2
Recommended Posts