base talk Delete one Taylor Swift album: reputation, Lover, Midnights, TTPD

[Brooklyn Baby]

 

 

 

[wehavetostan]

rep ofc

[Josh]

All of them have some redeeming qualities imo. but I'd delete Lover I go back to that one the least.

[makeawish]

the answer is still midnights, it will always be midnights

[Heldenzeit]

I never listen to rep or (standard) Midnights besides YOYOK. So these two I guess.

[ultraviolence.xx]

cant decide between lover or midnights

[WitnessOblivia]

Accidentally voted for Lover. It should be Midnights.

[WEEKND]

Lover and we can just add Cruel  Summer to the Eras Tour live album 

[Garbaj]

midnights. she could put out an album full of ukulele sounds... and the answer will still be midnights. 

[Paddy]

Lover. That album has only 3 good songs. 

[Nicholai]

12 minutes ago, Josh said:

All of them

 

[Aaron]

Midnights  

Just putrid. Genuinely worrying that it has the least votes. 

Edited April 29, 2024 by Aaron

[Cruel Summer]

I have to go for Lover. It has some great songs and Cruel Summer's resurgence as part of the Eras Tour narrative was amazing to witness, but it feels less essential to the canon of her artistic growth, development, and identity than any of the others. I couldn't bring myself to get rid of Reputation, Midnights feels too essential to her current career arc, and TTPD is now my favorite album in her discography. Lover's role could essentially have been served by a completely different pop album.

[aotearoa]

rep  her worst album

[Venice B]

Lover easily

[Space Cowboy]

TTPD is easily the worst and most boring album out of those

[byzantium]

No thanks:

 

1) I am not waiting 5 years between 1989 and Lover so Rep needs to stay. 
 

2) Lover and its backlash gave us folklore.  Also I don't want to erase Cruel Summer, Lover (s), Death by 1,000 cuts and false god.

 

3) Midnights is full of career highlights: Maroon, Midnight Rain, Anti-Hero, Karma, The Great War, WCS, Paris, You're Losing Me, Hits Different, YOYOK.  
 

4) TTPD:  I really love this album and think it has some of her most personal and strongest writing.  This album and its 31 tracks are a Swiftie dream. 

[305]

5 minutes ago, Cruel Summer said:

I have to go for Lover. It has some great songs and Cruel Summer's resurgence as part of the Eras Tour narrative was amazing to witness, but it feels less essential to the canon of her artistic growth, development, and identity than any of the others. I couldn't bring myself to get rid of Reputation, Midnights feels too essential to her current career arc, and TTPD is now my favorite album in her discography. Lover's role could essentially have been served by a completely different pop album.

Exactlyyyyy

[brraap]

Lover is camp and c*** 

 

TTPD is just too long. I'd delete it and make her start over with just Matty drags. Leave joe out of it henny 

[SLUTTVFTV]

i'll miss you, cruel summer 

[Taylor fanboy]

Lover will not be missed.

[Price of Fame]

i think reputation is easily her worst record but at least it actually feels like she was trying there

 

ttpd is just a total bore and adds nothing to her discography

[CandleGuy]

Can't lose Maroon.

 

Can't lose Cruel Summer.

 

TTPD is the best full body of work of all of them.

 

Gotta be Rep. I would like to forget some of the cringe on that album anyway tbh.

[Kimi]

Each album is weaker than the previous one lmao. She really should stop making synth pop. TT PTSD is definitely the worst one yet

[DeadInside]

Although Lover may be my least favorite Taylor album, it gave us Cruel Summer and Lover and idk if I would give that up. I like TTPD A LOT more than lover but I'd choose that just to not lose those Taylor classics.