SuperCiC1 Posted April 28 Posted April 28 there have been a few anomalies but this list feels intuitive. it's making some sense. keep going! 1
Timber Posted April 28 Author Posted April 28 Next up, first artist without any red rankings. #34 Kelly Clarkson Sales Rank: #36/65 Critics Rank: #34/65 General Public Rank: #33/65 Total Points: 65.7
Tylerbv Posted April 28 Posted April 28 Screaming at Carrie's highest being critic rankings when country critics have bashed her for years for supporting gay marriage and starting on Idol 1
Timber Posted April 28 Author Posted April 28 @ithinkheknowsoutsold #33 Kylie Minogue Sales Rank: #38/65 Critics Rank: #33/65 General Public Rank: #23/65 Total Points: 69.7 4
Timber Posted April 28 Author Posted April 28 (edited) #32 Alanis Morissette Sales Rank: #25/65 Critics Rank: #49/65 General Public Rank: #16/65 Total Points: 71.0 Edited April 28 by Timber 2
ithinkheknowsoutsold Posted April 29 Posted April 29 8 hours ago, Timber said: @ithinkheknowsoutsold #33 Kylie Minogue Sales Rank: #38/65 Critics Rank: #33/65 General Public Rank: #23/65 Total Points: 69.7 Mother outperforming my expectations in every single aspect, nice. 1
Timber Posted April 30 Author Posted April 30 #31 Carly Rae Jepson Sales Rank: #61/65 Critics Rank: #15/65 General Public Rank: #13/65 Total Points: 71.3
?????? Posted April 30 Posted April 30 3 minutes ago, Timber said: #31 Carly Rae Jepson Sales Rank: #61/65 Critics Rank: #15/65 General Public Rank: #13/65 Total Points: 71.3 We declared Carly Rae Jepsen should be a bigger artist! 4
Timber Posted April 30 Author Posted April 30 #30 Alicia Keys Sales Rank: #29/65 Critics Rank: #26/65 General Public Rank: #30/65 Total Points: 72.7
Timber Posted April 30 Author Posted April 30 #29 Tina Turner Sales Rank: #19/65 Critics Rank: #49/65 General Public Rank: #16/65 Total Points: 73.0
Timber Posted April 30 Author Posted April 30 #28 Rihanna Sales Rank: #7/65 Critics Rank: #42/65 General Public Rank: #33/65 Total Points: 73.7 2 1
Timber Posted April 30 Author Posted April 30 A tie for #26.... #26 Barbra Streisand Sales Rank: #6/65 Critics Rank: #42/65 General Public Rank: #28/65 Total Points: 75.7 #26 Lorde Sales Rank: #58/65 Critics Rank: #10/65 General Public Rank: #8/65 Total Points: 75.7 1
Saintlor Posted April 30 Posted April 30 I'm sorry but how is Carly Rae Jepsen general public rank 13 and Rihanna is 33? 3 2 1
Brooklyn Baby Posted April 30 Posted April 30 Katy Perry below Ava Max, Selena Gomez, Demi Lovato, Halsey... what is this list babes
FolkLover1989 Posted April 30 Posted April 30 1 hour ago, Timber said: #28 Rihanna Sales Rank: #7/65 Critics Rank: #42/65 General Public Rank: #33/65 Total Points: 73.7 No way Rihanna is #28 lmfao She is easily Top 15 GP rank #33 lmfao Ig Beyonce will be Top 5 then , the biasedness is insane
FolkLover1989 Posted April 30 Posted April 30 31 minutes ago, Saintlor said: I'm sorry but how is Carly Rae Jepsen general public rank 13 and Rihanna is 33? A biased list I won't be surprised if Bey makes Top 5 1
Timber Posted April 30 Author Posted April 30 (edited) 36 minutes ago, Saintlor said: I'm sorry but how is Carly Rae Jepsen general public rank 13 and Rihanna is 33? I don't think the GP regards Rihanna as that great of an albums artist besides Anti, the rest are more seen as collections of singles which hurt people's opinions of each of the artist's albums. 21 minutes ago, Diesel is Desire said: Katy Perry below Ava Max, Selena Gomez, Demi Lovato, Halsey... what is this list babes Katy has some of the worst critic scores of all, complain to them not me. Anyway.... A tie for #24.... #24 Aaliyah Sales Rank: #54/65 Critics Rank: #5/65 General Public Rank: #8/65 Total Points: 76.0 #24 Olivia Rodrigo Sales Rank: #50/65 Critics Rank: #2/65 General Public Rank: #23/65 Total Points: 76.0 Edited April 30 by Timber 3
Saintlor Posted April 30 Posted April 30 Just now, Timber said: I don't think the GP regards Rihanna as that great of an albums artist besides Anti, the rest are more seen as collections of singles which hurt people's opinions of each of the artist's albums. Katy has some of the worst critic scores of all, complain to them not me. The GP don't think of Carly at all. The GP care more about a Rihanna album than a Carly album
Timber Posted April 30 Author Posted April 30 (edited) 11 minutes ago, Saintlor said: The GP don't think of Carly at all. The GP care more about a Rihanna album than a Carly album Frankly, I think the GP category has been the most accurate on determining who makes the best albums. Then critics, then sales. A tie for #22 #22 Norah Jone Sales Rank: #28/65 Critics Rank: #22/65 General Public Rank: #23/65 Total Points: 76.7 #22 Aretha Franklin Sales Rank: #16/65 Critics Rank: #51/65 General Public Rank: #6/65 Total Points: 76.7 Edited April 30 by Timber
Ratviolo Posted April 30 Posted April 30 (edited) What is the methodology for this? Are Critic reviews and General Public reviews based on Metacritic or what? Album equivalents on Chartmasters? Edited April 30 by Ratviolo
Timber Posted April 30 Author Posted April 30 Once again, a tie for #20 #20 Shakira Sales Rank: #14/65 Critics Rank: #23/65 General Public Rank: #33/65 Total Points: 77.7 #20 Tracy Chapman Sales Rank: #30/65 Critics Rank: #34/65 General Public Rank: #6/65 Total Points: 77.7 2
Recommended Posts