Popular Post Lose My Breath Posted April 3 Popular Post Posted April 3 He's right. It's a tired argument that the clueless continue to have. 11 6 1
Josh Posted April 3 Posted April 3 (edited) An album doesn't need over a thousand of song writers just to write the most simplest lyrics Beyonce claims to write Edited April 3 by Josh 12 9 2 1 34
Queenyoncee Posted April 3 Author Posted April 3 2 minutes ago, Lose My Breath said: He's right. It's a tired argument that the clueless continue to have. The way her haters continue to lose 4 1
Lose My Breath Posted April 3 Posted April 3 Just now, Josh said: An album doesn't need over a thousand of song writers just to write the most simplest lyrics Beyonce claims to write Lets see the credits on your album though 1 8 6 2
Popular Post ks_dollar Posted April 3 Popular Post Posted April 3 (edited) It's the way she's inserted to the front of the credits, like she had the most songwriting contribution, that's questionable for me Edited April 9 by ks_dollar 16 5 1
Shelter Posted April 3 Posted April 3 Just now, Josh said: An album doesn't need over a thousand of song writers just to write the most simplest lyrics Beyonce claims to write Write a song there Josh. 3 2
Josh Posted April 3 Posted April 3 1 minute ago, Shelter said: Write a song there Josh. Why doesn't Beyonce write a song by herself? Why does she need more than one writer? 1 18 6
ATRL Moderator Popular Post feelslikeadream Posted April 3 ATRL Moderator Popular Post Posted April 3 It's kind of a strawman argument though; the issue with Beyonce and credits is not the number of writers, but the shady way she takes writing credits herself despite minimal/zero contributions. THE having 6 writers is not a problem. Bey taking royalties away from Jon McLaughlin for Crash Into You is a problem. And if she's doing the same for the other 5 writers on THE, that's also an issue. So this tweet and reply are ultimately just misdirection away from the actual issue. 33 3 6
Shelter Posted April 3 Posted April 3 1 minute ago, Josh said: Why doesn't Beyonce write a song by herself? Why does she need more than one writer? So you can't? 1 4
Burn Posted April 3 Posted April 3 1 minute ago, Josh said: Why doesn't Beyonce write a song by herself? Why does she need more than one writer? Britney stan really shouldn't be talking when Britney can't write nor even sing on her own 'songs' - if they can be called that. 3 2 1 1 6
Josh Posted April 3 Posted April 3 1 minute ago, Burn said: Britney stan really shouldn't be talking when Britney can't write nor even sing on her own 'songs' - if they can be called that. Britney never claims she's a song writer though. 8 1
campelo Posted April 3 Posted April 3 It's so hard and it takes craft and artistry to join different visions, to coordinate, to create, to sample (because it's music theory and knowledge). Its harder than sitting by yourself strumming the guitar melodies or piano and writing a piece of lyrics like so many do 3 2 1 2
Josh Posted April 3 Posted April 3 1 minute ago, Shelter said: So you can't? Is being a songwriter my profession? no but it's allegedly Beyonce's 10 2 1
Josh Posted April 3 Posted April 3 Just now, campelo said: It's so hard and it takes craft and artistry to join different visions, to coordinate, to create, to sample (because it's music theory and knowledge). Its harder than sitting by yourself strumming the guitar melodies or piano and writing a piece of lyrics like so many do It's never been hard for Madonna, Michael, Prince, Tina Turner 2 1
alfonso12 Posted April 3 Posted April 3 21 minutes ago, Josh said: An album doesn't need over a thousand of song writers just to write the most simplest lyrics Beyonce claims to write If they are that simple why are they universally acclaimed? Also, you gotta have a lot of nerve to throw that shade when you stan manufactured k-pop groups that not only have the simplest and most basic lyrics but also have people to write those for them cause they can't even do that. 4 2 4
Josh Posted April 3 Posted April 3 Just now, alfonso12 said: If they are that simple why are they universally acclaimed? Also, you gotta have a lot of nerve to throw that shade when you stan manufactured k-pop groups that not only have the simplest and most basic lyrics but also have people to write those for them cause they can't even do that. Did I say the girl groups I stan for were releasing Mozart? 1
alfonso12 Posted April 3 Posted April 3 1 minute ago, Josh said: Did I say the girl groups I stan for were releasing Mozart? No, but one would think if you say Beyoncé's lyrics are the the simplest is because you listen some kind of poetic lyrics in a daily basis but... 4 5
Kingdom Posted April 3 Posted April 3 19 minutes ago, feelslikeadream said: It's kind of a strawman argument though; the issue with Beyonce and credits is not the number of writers, but the shady way she takes writing credits herself despite minimal/zero contributions. THE having 6 writers is not a problem. Bey taking royalties away from Jon McLaughlin for Crash Into You is a problem. And if she's doing the same for the other 5 writers on THE, that's also an issue. So this tweet and reply are ultimately just misdirection away from the actual issue. You just contradicted yourself...you literally have no idea what their deal is. You have no idea what she actually contributed. A lot of assumptions and that is indeed tired. You are basing your opinion on TWITTER VIBES and threads. 6 3
Josh Posted April 3 Posted April 3 Just now, alfonso12 said: No, but one would think if you say Beyoncé's lyrics are the the simplest is because you listen some kind of poetic lyrics in a daily basis but... Both can be true. Beyonce's lyrics are simple as hell 2 2
QueenB Posted April 3 Posted April 3 12 minutes ago, Josh said: It's never been hard for Madonna, Michael, Prince, Tina Turner Every one of the people listed use song writers, even Prince. Everyone writes music differently, even Elton John would just play the piano over lyrics written by someone else to make it a song. 3 2
Chris Posted April 3 Posted April 3 20 minutes ago, Burn said: Britney stan really shouldn't be talking when Britney can't write nor even sing on her own 'songs' - if they can be called that. 3 1
Josh Posted April 3 Posted April 3 Just now, QueenB said: Every one of the people listed use song writers, even Prince. Everyone writes music differently, even Elton John would just play the piano over lyrics written by someone else to make it a song. But Prince has never needed 25 writers 2
satellites.™ Posted April 3 Posted April 3 19 minutes ago, Josh said: It's never been hard for Madonna, Michael, Prince, Tina Turner Well three of them are dead so what now? 4 4 4
Chris Posted April 3 Posted April 3 19 minutes ago, Josh said: It's never been hard for Madonna, Apparently, Madonna doesn't write her own songs said by a certain pop star.
Recommended Posts