discussion Is Emma Stone *thee* actress of our time?

[BrandNewBrandon]

The following comment is not a joke. I repeat, THE FOLLOWING COMMENT IS NOT A JOKE. But...

 

Lady Gaga sort of has a mega-impressive filmography and accolades when taking into perspective how many movies she's done. It's quite impressive to say the least. While Emma is talented, that filmography isn't yet giving "2x Oscar winner" even though she could very well win her second one. It's the fact that she's done so many comedies. She's great but still not versatile. I think if Gaga devours Joker 2 and has another Oscar-nominated role in another heavily-praised movie and it potentially being 5 out of 5 critically-acclaimed and heavily-nominated roles, then the title belongs to her. 

[tost1]

30 minutes ago, BrandNewBrandon said:

The following comment is not a joke. I repeat, THE FOLLOWING COMMENT IS NOT A JOKE. But...

 

Lady Gaga sort of has a mega-impressive filmography and accolades when taking into perspective how many movies she's done. It's quite impressive to say the least. While Emma is talented, that filmography isn't yet giving "2x Oscar winner" even though she could very well win her second one. It's the fact that she's done so many comedies. She's great but still not versatile. I think if Gaga devours Joker 2 and has another Oscar-nominated role in another heavily-praised movie and it potentially being 5 out of 5 critically-acclaimed and heavily-nominated roles, then the title belongs to her. 

I love Gaga, but she made 2 movies and one of those was pure garbage, so… lets not do this

[Bones]

I don’t know how she does it but she makes every character so so different and with so many angles

[playboi]

Nah Scarlett Johansson has a bigger name and is more loved by the GP 

 

I think Emma is behind Margot Robbie as well

Edited February 24 by playboi

[BrandNewBrandon]

17 minutes ago, tost1 said:

I love Gaga, but she made 2 movies and one of those was pure garbage, so… lets not do this

Yeah but we're talking about her acting. And ironically, that movie was pretty much just praised for Gaga's performance. She's got two movies and both have given her major award nominations. That's very noteworthy. 

Edited February 24 by BrandNewBrandon

[uusagii]

Anyways it's Parker Posey

[єѕℓαм]

Yes she’s one of the very few actresses that i enjoy watching almost all of her movies 

[Digitalism]

From her generation she is 

for girls in thir 30s it's her 

Girls in their 20s it's saoirse ronan

[Flanders]

Wait, she’s the front runner for Best Actress? She was great in Poor Things but not amazing. Anyway I really like her so good fa ha

[Space Cowboy]

2 hours ago, BrandNewBrandon said:

The following comment is not a joke. I repeat, THE FOLLOWING COMMENT IS NOT A JOKE. But...

 

Lady Gaga sort of has a mega-impressive filmography and accolades when taking into perspective how many movies she's done. It's quite impressive to say the least. While Emma is talented, that filmography isn't yet giving "2x Oscar winner" even though she could very well win her second one. It's the fact that she's done so many comedies. She's great but still not versatile. I think if Gaga devours Joker 2 and has another Oscar-nominated role in another heavily-praised movie and it potentially being 5 out of 5 critically-acclaimed and heavily-nominated roles, then the title belongs to her. 

This is some next level delusion 

[Hunter_13]

She's cute, but she's no Gaga 

[chiliam]

She is good and probably come in 2nd.

Jennifer Lawrence still hold the title. She is a much bigger celeb and can actually carry a movie on box office side and she can get back doing those award films whenever she wants.

[RideOrDie]

5 hours ago, chiliam said:

She is good and probably come in 2nd.

Jennifer Lawrence still hold the title. She is a much bigger celeb and can actually carry a movie on box office side and she can get back doing those award films whenever she wants.

i love jenny but she was a fad 

[Konril]

Love my fellow Asian, so yes. Yes she is. 

[chiliam]

4 hours ago, RideOrDie said:

i love jenny but she was a fad 

Last summer, she just carried the success of a R Rated comedy base on her charisma alone so a lot of people wants to be a fad like that

And you guys need to stop treating actresses like pop girls lol, it`s entirely another industry. Actress can pick bad projects for years and then come back with a right roles, it happened all the time. 

[Feanor]

[Triton]

[Konril]

On 2/26/2024 at 6:13 AM, Konril said:

Love my fellow Asian, so yes. Yes she is. 

And she double cemented that today.

[Katamari]

yes tbh 

[Rainbows]

She's a great actress and well on her way to being one of the greats but at this stage i would say no

[shyboi]

Gaga is.

[Life Savers]

Yes 

[KanMap]

Yes 

[Donquizote]

Yes, but she needs to prove herself in drama movie first before she can claim that "Queen" title.

[Shelter]

Probably. Better than Jennifer Lawrence who was being pushed as a mega star.