base talk Touch My Body vs. Shake It Off

[naval23]

Which one do you prefer?

 

The 6 week #2 peaking single "Shake It Off" blocked by her own "We Belong Together" and Kanye's "Gold Digger" or the two week #1 "Touch My Body"

 

 

 

[Stepfon]

By the time you get this message, it's gonna be too late
So don't bother paging me 'cause I'll be on my way
See, I grabbed all my diamonds and clothes
Just ask your momma she knows
You're gonna miss me, baby
Hate to say I told you so

[Rocket]

Touch My Body devours.

 

[scenekiller]

Shake It Off and it's not even close

 

[GraceRandolph]

[stevyy]

the shake it off singer.

[mxoonlight]

I love both but prefer Shake It Off, all of the Mimi singles are so good

[blown away]

Shake It Off is okay, while Touch My Body is a bop. So the latter wins.

[Kayseri Mantisi]

Let's ask @suburbannature 

[Rocket]

Just now, Kayseri Mantisi said:

Let's ask @suburbannature 

Lets not.

 

[Year of Shadow]

This 

 

 

[ithinkheknowsoutsold]

Shake It Off is timeless and could still come out today with slight changes. It easily devours Touch My Body, which was only the third best single off Einstein.

[Armani?]

Touch My Body>>>>>

[JonginBey]

Touch My Body. 

[SuperCiC1]

SIO is a great breakup song, easy breezy, but TMB feels so playful and catchy.

[Blue Monday]

Love Touch My Body but Shake It Off is just that girl; both are great examples of the mightiness of Mariah's PEN because she can write a catchy song but it's going to be catchy AND well written

[Aaron]

They’re both SO good. I think the slight edge goes to Shake it Off though, what a masterpiece  

[suburbannature]

Shake It Off

[Homebrand]

Shake It Off is just slaps every time so that

TMB is also 10/10 tho 

[spree]

Touch My Body is a lot of fun, and the video is great, which isn't something a person usually says about a Mariah Carey video.  But this one is spot-on. 

[suburbannature]

5 minutes ago, spree said:

Touch My Body is a lot of fun, and the video is great, which isn't something a person usually says about a Mariah Carey video.  But this one is spot-on. 

If they missed the entire Emancipation and Butterfly eras, Heartbreaker, TMB, Obsessed, etc maybe? 
 

only artist to win an international Video Vanguard for a reason, I fear.

[Big Bad Wolf]

Oof both are so good. I don't think I can choose.

[tost1]

Touch My Body is the only Mariah song I liked while it was current, so definitely that.

 

[Cheers]

 

[Nightingale]

Overall they’re pretty tied but lately SIO