Jump to content

HIKARU UTADA ~ the discography rate [完了]


Recommended Posts

Posted

Okay I could've been nicer to this one

  • Replies 1.2k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • Graves

    332

  • Suilen

    157

  • Curaga

    131

  • Cruel Summer

    112

Posted
2 minutes ago, confide in me said:

BABY LET ME TOUCH YOU
愛だけの愛でいい

giphy.gif

a mega bop but only the girls who get it, get it

 

giphy.gif

  • Thanks 1
Posted
1 minute ago, Subomie said:

Started out so simple and innocent...

 

SO SIMPLE AND INNOCENT!

 

4Jx3.gif

She would've eaten on this one 

Posted

To my surprise, it's been received very well

 

Even Hikaru can't believe this track is liked

  • Haha 4
Posted

it's indeed a basic bop but considering the other options they gave us on that album we can't really ask for much else I fear

 

4Jx3.gif

  • Like 1
Posted
4 minutes ago, Subomie said:

Cackling at you posting this as I was doing the write up. My apologies miss girl. :heart2:

I CANNOT :snowball:  Let me go stream it and cry and bop

Posted

81.png

 

HIGHEST SCORE: 10 x 2 (bestfiction, Hey Dude)

LOWEST SCORE: 5 x 1 (Suilen)

MY SCORE: 5.5

 

Such an odd choice, isn't it? I mean, to write a teen love song centered around them being Bonnie & Clyde. I'm not the only one who finds it a bit weird, right? Look, plenty of love songs have been written about the infamous duo, but most of them are... like, more sultry affairs with an emphasis on a dark romance (just think the Jay-Z and Beyoncé song). This is an upbeat and peppy love song. I mean, maybe it's just too subversive for my lil brain, but I'm not sure what the logic was with this one.

 

This track was featured as a B-side on the Movin' on without you CD about a month before it came out on the album proper, so there's that! I wonder if any people were sold on First Love off of the strength of the Bonnie & Clyde song? I think my favorite/least-favorite part of this are the sounds of tires screeching in the back towards the end. Is Utada trying to imply that this teen romance will end in a grizzly shootout just like B&C? Maybe there's a reason that guy wouldn't call her back on Movin' on without you...

 

 

Curaga gagged me when I first got their ballot, by mostly slating First Love but deciding that B&C was the track they were gonna stan: "Wow, I like this one a lot better this time! This one sounds nice. Ooh, love the autotune near the end."

There's room for everybody I guess!

  • Haha 2
Posted

I love youtube comments cuz people will spill their life story and change your perspective on a song that went out at #82 on an ATRL rate

 

 

4a70c87d32270c694e8458af207511ba.png

  • Haha 7
Posted

Normally that's where I'd leave you, but #80 is kind of a huge cackle so I think I'm just going to do it now. Give me five seconds!

Posted

Parody is a favorite of mine. :jonny: I've never really used Drama though. 

At least 2 of my 3  top faves from Distance are still here I think though(For You and Sunglasses). I'll just think pretend that y'all voted out the remix version of Hayatochiri instead of the original mix of it which is still one of her best R&B cuts. :jonny:

  • Like 1
Posted (edited)
4 minutes ago, Reverie said:

I love youtube comments cuz people will spill their life story and change your perspective on a song that went out at #82 on an ATRL rate

 

 

4a70c87d32270c694e8458af207511ba.png

The way I learned the amount of people in YouTube comments who dedicated Sugababes songs to their dead relatives that didn't even hit top 40 in the This Was Pop 2007 rate I hosted like 10 years ago... people really air it out down there like it's a free therapy session!

Edited by Ewan Chaos
  • Haha 3
Posted

Yeah I was so confused to hear her sing bonnie & clyde but I'm a sucker for that bubblegum sound

Posted

I might have been a little generous with my 7 for B&C, but I would hardly call that stanning :laugh:

First Love (the album) just isn’t it for me. :michael: 

Posted

80.png

 

11 x 1: gingguu

 

HIGHEST SCORE: 10 x 1 (Hey Dude)

LOWEST SCORE: 3 x 1 (AMIT)

MY SCORE: 6.5

 

This is a big one, innit? First Love is THE Utada song for the Japanese GP. This is their most streamed track by a huge margin and still gets used to this day for commercial tie-ins, just look at the Netflix show... First Love. Well ****, named the whole damn program after the song - that's impact! Would you believe it wasn't even a #1 then? Well, it's not that crazy. It was a post-album single after all, and since we're talking about an album that sold over seven million copies... I think Hikki's okay with settling for a #2 peak.

 

Just like Automatic, First Love got a 2008 ringtone release to celebrate a decade of Hikaru Utada, and a digital release in 2014 for the First Love fifteenth anniversary, and then another re-release, paired with Hatsukoi, in 2022 for the show I mentioned above... dang, can this song stop charting for two minutes?? Give another song a chance!

 

Though not my favourite Hikki ballad, there's a sweetness to this that helps to understand why so many adore it. I mean, it's a song that gets these old ******* nostalgic for their idealized teen romances. The first time they held somebody's hand and got their young hearts broken. Eugh. As a milennial homosexual, I can't quite relate... but the video sure is pretty!

 

 

Curaga is really gonna drag a 15yo for their vocals: "Classic song, but this is my number one example of her sounding like she doesn’t feel comfortable in her vocal performance. I don’t listen to this anymore because she sounds so shaky and nervous to me (mostly on the higher notes, like at 3:31–3:33)." Gurl.

AMIT just drags EVERYTHING: "It's TOO sappy :deadbanana: sorry."

  • Haha 1
  • Confused 1
Posted
4 minutes ago, Ewan Chaos said:

The way I learned the amount of people in YouTube comments who dedicated Sugababes songs that didn't even hit top 40 in the This Was Pop 2007 rate I hosted like 10 years ago... people really air it out down there like it's a free therapy session!

My favorite is when people comment on their unedited Gmail/Google connected account instead of their Youtube usernames. Like if everyone on here had to post with their full government name and some numbers idk how I would act

  • Like 1
  • Haha 2
Posted

I also gave B&C a 7, but that was on the lower end for me for First Love tracks! She really did something right with the sound of that album, it just clicks in that perfectly nostalgic way. It sounds very of its time without sounding dated and bad IMO.

Posted
6 minutes ago, Taste of Honey said:

Parody is a favorite of mine. :jonny: I've never really used Drama though. 

At least 2 of my 3  top faves from Distance are still here I think though(For You and Sunglasses). I'll just think pretend that y'all voted out the remix version of Hayatochiri instead of the original mix of it which is still one of her best R&B cuts. :jonny:

another Hayatochiri original mix truther! @Subomie see there are TWO OF US now! :wave2:

  • Thanks 1
Posted
1 minute ago, Reverie said:

My favorite is when people comment on their unedited Gmail/Google connected account instead of their Youtube usernames. Like if everyone on here had to post with their full government name and some numbers idk how I would act

U better drag @willmcclure9 !

  • Haha 3
Posted

:rip:

Posted
2 minutes ago, Subomie said:

80.png

 

11 x 1: gingguu

 

HIGHEST SCORE: 10 x 1 (Hey Dude)

LOWEST SCORE: 3 x 1 (AMIT)

MY SCORE: 6.5

 

This is a big one, innit? First Love is THE Utada song for the Japanese GP. This is their most streamed track by a huge margin and still gets used to this day for commercial tie-ins, just look at the Netflix show... First Love. Well ****, named the whole damn program after the song - that's impact! Would you believe it wasn't even a #1 then? Well, it's not that crazy. It was a post-album single after all, and since we're talking about an album that sold over seven million copies... I think Hikki's okay with settling for a #2 peak.

 

Just like Automatic, First Love got a 2008 ringtone release to celebrate a decade of Hikaru Utada, and a digital release in 2014 for the First Love fifteenth anniversary, and then another re-release, paired with Hatsukoi, in 2022 for the show I mentioned above... dang, can this song stop charting for two minutes?? Give another song a chance!

 

Though not my favourite Hikki ballad, there's a sweetness to this that helps to understand why so many adore it. I mean, it's a song that gets these old ******* nostalgic for their idealized teen romances. The first time they held somebody's hand and got their young hearts broken. Eugh. As a milennial homosexual, I can't quite relate... but the video sure is pretty!

 

 

Curaga is really gonna drag a 15yo for their vocals: "Classic song, but this is my number one example of her sounding like she doesn’t feel comfortable in her vocal performance. I don’t listen to this anymore because she sounds so shaky and nervous to me (mostly on the higher notes, like at 3:31–3:33)." Gurl.

AMIT just drags EVERYTHING: "It's TOO sappy :deadbanana: sorry."

:bibliahh:

 

this was the BEST update yet even if I had to take some hits with it

 

no matter what I WON now

 

4Jx3.gif

  • Haha 3
Posted

Um. Okay. It feels like this is really low but it also feels like idk why I'd expect it to chart higher :rip: It's a totally serviceable 6.5/7 song.

Posted
1 minute ago, AMIT said:

another Hayatochiri original mix truther! @Subomie see there are TWO OF US now! :wave2:

It's a whole different song and vibe. :lmao:I don't care for that remix at all, but the OG version is so good and should've been on the album instead.

  • Like 1
Posted

Didn't really like this song when i first heard it but it GREW... lemme give it a stream

Posted

I mean I have to agree a bit...I love the sound of the first two albums but her vocals get a bit screechy which can become a lot to bear in a 4-5 minute song for my social media induced ADHD brain. Like giving karaoke session with my friends and I. Don't get me wrong we give it our all which is what matters

 

4Jx3.gif

  • Like 2
Posted
3 minutes ago, Subomie said:

U better drag @willmcclure9 !

I respect it, it means you have nothing to hide and stand behind everything you say!

  • Like 1
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.