poll GUTS vs midnights- Better Album?

[Starkboy]

Midnights standard edition has like 4 good tracks so...

[Steve Johnson]

I mean GUTS has 0 good songs. Poor lyrics, horrible melodies. So Midnights wins by default. 

Edited September 9, 2023 by Steve Johnson

[4Real]

I love Taylor and i'm a fan but Midnights is AI music.

Would've could've should've might be better than any Olivia song tho.

[supaspaz]

This is so rude to Guts.

[freakum.]

Such a random comparison. 

 

As a Taylor stan I have to admit I didn't like midnights on first listen but it grew on me alot but I liked GUTS on first listen. I needa listen more though but Olivia created a great second album. Def a mother and daughter that needa reconnect. 

[KatyPrismSpirit]

People coming for Midnights…. I prefer Guts too but Midnights is literally one of the best pop albums this decade. Its an amazing project lets be serious. 

[Bloo]

Midnights and it's not even close. 

 

Guts is such a downgrade from Sour, I'm a bit baffled.

[TayDuaStan]

Sweet Nothing alone is better than Olivia’s entire discography and it’s like at the bottom of Midnights so… 

[naval23]

Midnights has nothing that touches vampire sorry

 

The one with 90+ on Metacritic 

[Eclass]

Even 'I Am Me' by Ashlee Simpson is a better pop rock album than GUTS 

so...

Edited September 13, 2023 by Eclass

[Unusualyou]

Guts

 

Midnight is an horrible album and an huge dowgrade for Folklore and Evermore 

[SixWholeYears]

it's a mid off as both are very boring and bland but i prefer midnights

[thatsmydemi]

I like both but Guts is on another level. 

[Komet]

MIDnights wishes 

 

Edited September 13, 2023 by Komet blu

[UnusualBoy]

Logical alone takes it to another level.

[FakeInsider]

Im not into Disney teen music because Im grown ass adult so Midnights by default

[kimberly]

Midnights vs. GUTS

Lavender Haze vs. all-american *****

Maroon vs. bad idea right?

Anti-Hero vs. vampire

Snow on the Beach vs. lacy 

You're on Your Own, Kid vs. ballad of a homeschooled girl

Midnight Rain vs. making the bed

Question vs. logical

Vigilante **** vs. get him back!

Bejeweled vs. love is embarrassing 

Labyrinth vs. the grudge

Karma vs. pretty isn't pretty

Sweet Nothing vs. teenage dream

Mastermind (+1 for Taylor)

Midnights 6 - 9 GUTS

[Ale]

vampire alone is better than anything on midnights

[Ichinaru19]

GUTS is a significant decline compared to sour IMO. Midnights, while not Taylor's best, is still a decent pop record. Vampire got me so stoke for Olivia's album but none of the songs really live up to it at all sadly. Too bad, sour was a no skip album