poll GUTS vs midnights- Better Album?

[MingYouToo]

The Midnights highlights are literally just LH, Anti Hero and WCS. The rest are ok to bleh

 

GUTS is just outstanding from start to finish, the bops cant un bop themselves and the ballads are so well written melody wise!

[Taylor fanboy]

1 hour ago, Klein said:

Didn't take long to prove me right 

 

Not quite!

 

 

[Punky Rooster]

25 minutes ago, Klein said:

Time for an ear-check then 

 Not really, she sings everything the same, her range doesn’t move, the tempo may change slightly but it all blends together.

[AaronBryceSufjan]

I can't even find a song to like in guts

at first listen I picked 3 or 4 tracks, but when I listened to them again they became plain

Edited September 8, 2023 by AaronBryceSufjan

[Axelios]

Just now, Punky Rooster said:

 Not really, she sings everything the same, her range doesn’t move, the tempo may change slightly but it all blends together.

Yes you urgently need the ear-check

[Mr. Duff]

It’s hard to decide now as GUTS just came out but I love GUTS more right off the bat, but Midnights did some longevity damage to me because I love it more and more a time passed by, I am still obsessed with it, I don’t get the “mid” jokes because it’s a top tier Taylor album for me.

 

I am going to vote for Midnights because of the chokehold it had on me for a long time.

[MALAMENTE]

Guts does not have a song as good as WCS or YOYOK. 

[Punky Rooster]

8 minutes ago, Axelios said:

Yes you urgently need the ear-check

Ok x

[Badgalbriel]

Midnights is outstanding. Guts is good too. 

[elliot_ta]

Midnights is truly MID but GUTS is unlistenable so I'd say Midnights for the win

[Lemon]

I quite enjoyed Guts on my first listen, but Snow on the Beach and The Great War are too perfect to be destroyed easily. 

[Taylena]

Midnights is amazingly good & I’m still not convinced users on ATRL aren’t pretending to hate it more than they actually do. 

[PopKills]

GUTS of course 

[KatyPrismSpirit]

I love both but GUTS is more cohesive and has more interesting production

[blueberries]

guts by far

[centillion]

Midnights.

[Maxxxine]

I just tried giving this Olivia chick a spin and... y'all can't be serious

 

The epitome of highschool diary lyrics paired with the most irritating indie girl bananees and avovadees cursive singing. .

 

Taylor I am SO sorry they keep comparing you to this little Teen Vogue girl.

[Noodles]

GUTS is much more believable.

[HausofNick]

Midnights by far.

[georgechxng]

this is such a unserious comparison. midnights is bland and dull and boring. guts is incredible. not really fair to taylor.

[byzantium]

Both are two of the best albums released in the last 12 months.  We are all winners. 

[illicit affairs]

Love Guts, but Midnights excels.

[NoOneDiesFromLove]

Midnights is not my favorite from Taylor but Guts felt like such a downgrade for me  

 

so Midnights

[sourprint]

guts by olivia rodrigo

 

[lostcause]

Guts by FAAAAAAAAAAAAR

 

 

midnights is a blatantly boring, basic, bad album. 
 

Guts is a brilliant and beautiful work of art. Not a fare comparison 

Edited September 9, 2023 by lostcause