base talk Who could've replaced Gaga in ASIB?

[FOCK]

Lucy Laduca. 
 

 

 

 

[Roberto]

11 minutes ago, livelikemusic said:

If we go the indie route, it would be Alexz Johnson. She's a singer who can act. But the suggestions of Sara Bareilles & Anne Hathaway work for me, as well.

Sara and Anne are the only coherents ones I have read here, tbh. 

[GentleDance]

[bliaz]

55 minutes ago, alejandreaux said:

she’s very talented but it’s important to note that without Gaga, the songs go away too. the Shallow song and scene in general was pretty much the driving force behind ASIB’s acclaim.

[WildAmerican]

No one else would've had the clearance to write Shallow, so the movie wouldn't have been as big a deal with anyone else, so it's a moot point

[Sheep]

Bey if she worked with a great acting coach(Gaga had to do this as well)

[glacier76]

ImI like the idea of Anne, songwriting abilities aside. Maybe Kate Hudson? Someone from the music industry, not sure. Maybe Janelle? I cannot see Adele act but beyond that, her singing Hair Body Face?

[Selenasworld]

Well Gaga is a good match to Bradley due to the age gap is nothing too bad, I can't imagine anyone in their 20s with Bradley daddy Cooper 

[Kiss It Better]

fellow oscar winner H.E.R.

[Taylor fanboy]

No one.

[little legend]

No one

[Maroon13]

Beyonce will eat Gaga Alive

[Vespertine]

No Gaga no Shallow

 

No Shallow no TABS

[Dzjxdzjx]

Hilary Duff proved herself for this in The Lizzie McGuire Movie

[industry baby]

Beyonce just for the kiis about her funny&awful acting 

[blackoutbaby]

Jessica Simpson, I fear…

[Ratviolo]

No one. The music Gaga made - along with it being her acting debut - is what made the movie as big as it was.

[GraceRandolph]

[punisher]

i feel like lana could’ve pulled it off very well with some acting lessons

[Dolce Vita]

miley cyrus 

[dussel_06]

Yalitza Aparicio 

 

Both her and Gaga have the same range as they’re both nominated.

[Mystic Boy]

5 hours ago, alejandreaux said:

she’s very talented but it’s important to note that without Gaga, the songs go away too. the Shallow song and scene in general was pretty much the driving force behind ASIB’s acclaim.

 

5 hours ago, Chasing Comet said:

ARUTW exists because gaga in it so no one 

 

4 hours ago, WildAmerican said:

No one else would've had the clearance to write Shallow, so the movie wouldn't have been as big a deal with anyone else, so it's a moot point

Thank you, cause some are still so pressed that they tend to forget the songs weren't handed to her

[Soobin]

Demi Lovato for sure

[Johnny Jacobs]

Anne hathaway 

Scarlett Johansson 

Amanda Seyfried 

Bethany Joy Lenz

 

Why are ya'll acting like gaga is the only one that can sing and act? 

 

[Fancyhoodlum]

Pryianka chopra jonas