Jump to content

How would you rank these singers: Tamia, Mya, Aaliyah, Ashanti, Monica, Brandy


Recommended Posts

Posted

imo pure bias no criteria

 

Monica  > Tamia >>> Aaliyah > Brandy >>>>>>>>> Mya >>>>>>> Ashanti

 

:gaynetcat3:

 

 

  • Like 1

  • Replies 63
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • Power love

    5

  • blown away

    4

  • Bey_Rihstan

    2

  • Keter

    2

Posted

Anyone rating Tamia in the bottom because they don’t know her should just stay quiet

  • Like 4
  • Thanks 2
Posted

1. Aaliyah

2. Brandy

3. Monica

4. Tamia

5. Mya

6. Ashanti

 

tamia is the best singer hands down

Posted

mya

aaliyah

brandy

tamia

ashanti

Posted

Brandy

Aaliyah

Mya

Christina milian

ashanti

 

never really cared for monica, but I would replace her with keyshia cole 

Posted

Aaliyah & Brandy are top1 then the rest of them

 

Posted

I don't know about the vocally, but based on their discography

 

1. Aaliyah

2. Ashanti

3. Brandy

4. Mya

5. Monica

 

I haven't heard a single song by Tamia, hence she wasn't included. Any recommendations from her?

 

Posted

Mess not people hating on Tamia when she’s the better singer in this group and she’s an actual sweetheart. 
 

Humble and kind queen lol 

 

Tamia 

brandy 

Monica 

aaliyah 

Ashanti

Mya

Posted
22 minutes ago, blown away said:

I don't know about the vocally, but based on their discography

 

1. Aaliyah

2. Ashanti

3. Brandy

4. Mya

5. Monica

 

I haven't heard a single song by Tamia, hence she wasn't included. Any recommendations from her?

 

 

 

Posted
7 hours ago, ultraviolence.xx said:

people putting Brandy bottom 2 :rip: be serious 

people putting aaliyah & ashanti above her :deadbanana4: 

Posted

The correct answer is …

 

- Brandy

- Aaliyah

- Monica / Tamia

- Ashanti

- Mya

Posted

People ranking Tamia last cuz they don’t know her…. :biblio: Brandy peaked with Never Say Never. Idk what y’all want me to tell you! :celestial5:

  • Thumbs Down 1
Posted
1 hour ago, WEEKND said:

 

 

Oh, I do know the first song. That one is really nice.

 

The second one doesn't work for me, it's a bit too cheesy. But she has an amazing voice nonetheless.

Posted

speaking of tamia

 

 

  • Like 1
Posted

Brandy > tamia > Monica > Ashanti > Aaliyah > mya

 

Why was mya even included :skull:

Posted

Vocally (live): Brandy or Tamia > Monica > Mya > Ashanti > Aaliyah 

discography: Brandy > Aaliyah > Monica > Mya > Tamia > Ashanti

Posted
13 hours ago, blown away said:

I don't know about the vocally, but based on their discography

 

1. Aaliyah

2. Ashanti

3. Brandy

4. Mya

5. Monica

 

I haven't heard a single song by Tamia, hence she wasn't included. Any recommendations from her?

 

Officially missing you, can’t get enough, Questions and Stuck With You are some faves 

  • Like 1
Posted (edited)

Tamia- Stranger in my house alone dusts every last one of these ladies.

 

Brandy/Monica-Equal to me. I prefer Monica’s conviction and tone overall but Brandy has the versatility both top tier vocalists in general

 

Mya- slightly above average skill.

 

Ashanti- Average voice but she at tries and utilizes different parts of her voice well also bops. 


Aaliyah- probably comparable to Mya but I’ve only listened to her singles but the girl never really ever attempted a chest belt and that breathy style singing mess isn’t really my style so she rounds out the bottom.

 

 

 

 

 

Edited by Hallad173
Posted

Vocally:

1. Brandy

2. Monica

3. Tamia

4. Aaliyah

5. Mya

6. Ashanti

 

Personal preference:

1. Aaliyah

2. Brandy

3. Monica

4. Tamia

5. Mya

6. Ashanti

Posted
14 hours ago, blown away said:

I don't know about the vocally, but based on their discography

 

1. Aaliyah

2. Ashanti

3. Brandy

4. Mya

5. Monica

 

I haven't heard a single song by Tamia, hence she wasn't included. Any recommendations from her?

 

And my personal favourite:

 

 

Posted (edited)

Based on preference. 
Aaliyah 

Mya 

Brandy 

Ashanti 

Monica 

Tamia 

Edited by Keeandga
Posted

Preference

1. Aaliyah

2. Brandy

3. Monica

4. Mya

5. Ashanti

6. Tamia

 

Vocal Ability

1. Brandy

2. Monica

3. Aaliyah

4. Tamia

5. Ashanti

6. Mya

 

:celestial5:

Posted
21 hours ago, Nippy'sReceipts said:

1.Brandy 

2.Tamia 

3.Murda Monica

4.Mya

5.Aaliyah 

6.Ashanti

 

 

 

 

 

 

Switch Tamia and Brandy and this is my list. 

 

Mya is very underrated as a vocalist. She's very disciplined and has a great technique. 

 

I love Ashanti and she has improved a lot over the years, but she's never been one with strong vocals. 

Posted

musical preference 

 

1. Aaliyah

2. Monica

3. Brandy

4. Mya = Ashanti

5. Tamia

 

vocal ability

 

1. Brandy

2. Tamia

3. Monica

4. Aaliyah

5. Ashanti

6. Mya

Posted
15 hours ago, blown away said:

I don't know about the vocally, but based on their discography

 

1. Aaliyah

2. Ashanti

3. Brandy

4. Mya

5. Monica

 

I haven't heard a single song by Tamia, hence she wasn't included. Any recommendations from her?

 

Stranger In My House. It also has a MAJOR remix album that tore through clubs in the early aughts.

 

1. Tamia

2. Brandy

3. Monica

4. Aaliyah 

5. Mya

6. Ashanti

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.