album Taylor Swift - 'Speak Now (Taylor's Version)'

[Cloröx]

Critics say yes mattress! Removing it was a mistake 

 

https://consequence.net/2023/07/speak-now-taylors-version-review/

[sh0ckw4ves]

That Guardian reviewer is the same girl who recently apologised to Charli XCX for giving her a bad review a few years ago

 

she can't be trusted and will give it a 95 in 2 weeks 

[Cruel Summer]

15 minutes ago, Cloröx said:

OMG panned 

 

https://www.theguardian.com/music/2023/jul/07/taylor-swift-speak-now-taylors-version-review

This seems like a dull, joyless person who's mad they have to listen to an artist they don't actually like for their job. A touch of grass - and a career change - is needed.

[anastaciabby]

Just now, Cloröx said:

Critics say yes mattress! Removing it was a mistake 

 

https://consequence.net/2023/07/speak-now-taylors-version-review/

Do you really honestly believe that she wouldn't have gotten dragged if she kept it? It's such BS, they were going to ***** either way lbr

[enchanted0]

We don't care about reviews, like this album has literally stood the test of 13 years time so 

Edited July 7, 2023 by enchanted0

[Starkboy]

2 minutes ago, simmnfierzig said:

 

 

Must have still been glitching a bit, cause that's not a normal 2 hour update

 

I kinda hope Back To December takes over now

 

[Bonicap]

1 minute ago, Cloröx said:

Critics say yes mattress! Removing it was a mistake 

 

https://consequence.net/2023/07/speak-now-taylors-version-review/

Critics say yes mattress! because she changed it. If she didn't change it they would say no misoginy! terrible example for her young fans! 

[Cloröx]

1 minute ago, Cruel Summer said:

This seems like a dull, joyless person who's mad they have to listen to an artist they don't actually like for their job. A touch of grass - and a career change - is needed.

Where's him when we need him the most 

 

[enchanted0]

Just now, Bonicap said:

Critics say yes mattress! because she changed it. If she didn't change it they would say no misoginy! terrible example for her young fans! 

exactly 

[Lemon]

2 minutes ago, Cloröx said:

Critics say yes mattress! Removing it was a mistake 

 

https://consequence.net/2023/07/speak-now-taylors-version-review/

Well, they can have skinning-alive mattress from Hellraiser 2. 

[perfectillusion204]

Does Foolish One give anyone Alanis vibes? Kind of wish she was featured on it!

[omrimayo]

With The Guardian it’s gonna fall under 70. Really a shame. 
I love it but we’re the one to blame with all this self hating the album, people are are insane at most. 

[houndsoflove]

album gonna debut with lower than the original on meta 

[Magickarp]

2 minutes ago, Cruel Summer said:

This seems like a dull, joyless person who's mad they have to listen to an artist they don't actually like for their job. A touch of grass - and a career change - is needed.

[simmnfierzig]

Just now, houndsoflove said:

album gonna debut with lower than the original on meta 

Debuted with 74

[Cruel Summer]

1 minute ago, enchanted0 said:

We don't care about reviews, like this album has literally stood the test of 13 years time so 

Yeah, they're not touching it when it's performing like a new album and all the fans are loving the material 

[vale9001]

I agree with the Guardians and i wrote it yesterday. Speak now is a juvenile album written by a young woman so young vocals are part of it.

 

Saying that as a fan it's interesting to have whole albums from track 1 to 30 in a new version so it's fun to listen to them but her discoggraphy is that, with her 18 years old voice when she sings love story, a teen song and with a 30 years old song when she sings a mature song like cardigan.

This is what's fascinating in a discography.

 

The fact you start to have all early albums sang in the same way, with the same voice it's not what her discography is, so i will always listen to the original albums  too. Then having new versions of them is cool too. 

[Cloröx]

Just now, simmnfierzig said:

Debuted with 74

Oh well it's over. Success stan retreat!

 

[Bonicap]

Selling signed CDs once the normal ones have already shipped. The music industry knows how to play.

1 minute ago, omrimayo said:

With The Guardian it’s gonna fall under 70. Really a shame. 
I love it but we’re the one to blame with all this self hating the album, people are are insane at most. 

It's 74 already with the Guardian review.

[vale9001]

4 minutes ago, enchanted0 said:

We don't care about reviews, like this album has literally stood the test of 13 years time so 

"bad" reviews are not about the album but about the operation.

 

also metacritic average it's gonna be good, almost every other reviews is good...that user is always so tragic  

Edited July 7, 2023 by vale9001

[Theluckyone]

Should I listen with Dolby Atmos on or off on Apple music? Omg so confused 

[enchanted0]

Just now, vale9001 said:

"bad" reviews are not about the album but about the operation.

 

also metacritic average it's gonna be good, almost every other reviews is good...that user is always so tragic  

I get your point but quality is still there so 

[Cruel Summer]

Just now, Theluckyone said:

Should I listen with Dolby Atmos on or off on Apple music? Omg so confused 

Off for sure. For me, it ruins most of Taylor's music.

[sh0ckw4ves]

1 minute ago, Bonicap said:

Selling signed CDs once the normal ones have already shipped. The music industry knows how to play.

It's 74 already with the Guardian review.

Metacritic reviews are weighted differently (I think to do with how credible certain publications are) and The Guardian is weighted heavily

[chiliam]

Well the vault songs are grower with lyric videos. We love a solo songwritter.

But i really need her to release Battle and Drama Queen, those song deserve a spot