poll Bigger career: Taylor Swift or Britney Spears?

[nickolsen]

Just now, Enrique523 said:

Ok, you HAVE to be a troll at this point. Otherwise why would you set up Britney like that? 

 

Britney Jean more successful than Midnights, i'm CACKLING 

Britney jean debuted with 25k midnights at #1 with… 19k

 

Work ***** was a hit here

[raven]

It's Taylor but damn some of you are too comfortable disrespecting Britney

[Enrique523]

1 hour ago, nickolsen said:

Britney jean debuted with 25k midnights at #1 with… 19k

 

Work ***** was a hit here

So frontloaded "success" is all that matter to you? 

 

Pure sales have declined since 2013 so it's not a fair argument and you know it. I'm pretty sure people have streamed Midnights in France way more than they ever did Britney Jean, an album than even Britney stans acknowledge is one of her worst albums ever (as if the rest of her discography is any better )

 

And Work B*tch is a assault on good taste and music quality, like almost every Britney song 

[Smilers]

6 hours ago, Richie.Valdez said:

I mean considering Taylor Swift has slept with and got dumped by half of Hollywood and even 1 Kennedy family member I think she is very much a tabloid fodder.

 

 

Oh she definitely is, but I just want to give Britney something.

[nickolsen]

Just now, Enrique523 said:

So frontloaded "success" is all that matter to you? 

 

Pure sales have declined since 2013 so it's not a fair argument and you know it. I'm pretty sure people have streamed Midnights in France way more than they ever did Britney Jean, an album than even Britney stans acknowledge is one of her worst albums ever (as if the rest of her discography is any better )

 

And Work B*tch is a assault on good taste and music quality, like almost every Britney song 

What’s not fair is to compare the both of them.

 

Both… differently talented and successful… at different times.

 

Let’s just not act as if Britney’s career was random and normal. It was big and she was huge. 

[Enrique523]

1 hour ago, nickolsen said:

What’s not fair is to compare the both of them.

 

Both… differently talented and successful… at different times.

 

Let’s just not act as if Britney’s career was random and normal. It was big and she was huge. 

Britney was absolutely huge at the first part of her career, it's true. I've never denied that and anyone doing so would be delusional.

[Axelios]

12 minutes ago, nickolsen said:

Britney jean debuted with 25k midnights at #1 with… 19k

 

Work ***** was a hit here

Not you comparing the debut sales of a 2013 album to a 2022 one...

[Enrique523]

1 hour ago, Smilers said:

Oh she definitely is, but I just want to give Britney something.

The whole "sleeping with half of Hollywood" is so blatantly misogynistic, it really shows that so many gay men are not different from straight mlen when it comes to shaming women for their sexuality 

[WildHeart]

1 hour ago, nickolsen said:

Lash what ? 
 

« britney jean » sold more than « midnights» 

Midnights first week US sales - 1,578,000

 

Britney Jean WW sales to date - 1,573,000

 

Looks like France can only help so much

[Holiest Dreams]

1 hour ago, nickolsen said:

« britney jean » sold more than « midnights» 

Sig worthy 

[Into The Void]

1 hour ago, Enrique523 said:

 

 

And Work B*tch is a assault on good taste and music quality, like almost every Britney song 

Britneys music is iconic (and quality) as is Work *****

 

[Wewee]

Again wtf is this thread ?  

The answer is quite obvious 

[The Music Industry]

3 hours ago, nickolsen said:

Lash what ? 
 

« britney jean » sold more than « midnights» 

NURSE!!!

[brazil]

This thread still going? Britney is bigger, Taylor has no classics and is only big thanks to middle America. #threadclosed 

 

 

[Prism]

What an interesting comparison! 

 

I would definitely have to say Britney Spears.

 

Taylor doesn't have any iconic songs like Toxic or ...Baby One More Time or Oops!... I Did It Again so it's got to be the beloved Princess of Pop Ms. Britney Spears! She is beloved and successful in ways that Taylor just simply isn't... on a GLOBAL scale too!

[FightDragonsWithMe]

Imagine going up for a TRL Fad 

[perfillusion]

4 hours ago, nickolsen said:

Lash what ? 
 

« britney jean » sold more than « midnights» 

Wut??

[chiliam]

From artists who debut later than late 90s, Only Eminem can be comparable to Ms Swift.

So these thread are kinda pointless

[elincomprendid]

2 hours ago, brazil said:

This thread still going? Britney is bigger, Taylor has no classics and is only big thanks to middle America. #threadclosed 

 

 

Guess middle America is big enough to make Taylor stomp Britney in every possible metric that's wild

[God_Donna]

I- Bigger career?  Taylor Swift. More iconic in their prime ? Britney Spears. 

[Mystic Boy]

14 hours ago, Monster Queen said:

Why did this thread reach 10 pages when 80% of people vote for Taylor 

Because once again, the Britney delulus are in deep denial and refuse to acknowledge their fave total irrelevance besides tabloid fodders

Honestly, they should ve ignored this thread and save the utter embarrassment

[Rep2000]

20 hours ago, Josh said:

It wasn't until her break up with Harry is when people started paying attention to her musically

Yeah because she totally didn't win AOTY with Fearless at all . Harry who?

[Enrique523]

10 hours ago, Insanity said:

Britneys music is iconic (and quality) as is Work *****

 

There's ZERO quality in Britney's music, it's nothing but noisy overproduced trash with a "singer" whose voice sound like a chipmunk. But you're free to have no taste i guess.

 

Imagine unironically thinking that Work B*tch is "quality", what a joke 

[Enrique523]

8 hours ago, brazil said:

This thread still going? Britney is bigger, Taylor has no classics and is only big thanks to middle America. #threadclosed 

 

 

You guys really live in your own world, don't you? Just because you hate Taylor doesn't mean she has "no classics". In the real world Taylor is WAY more famous and beloved than Britney, her touring stats from the Eras tour alone speaks for themselves 

[Enrique523]

2 hours ago, Mystic Boy said:

Because once again, the Britney delulus are in deep denial and refuse to acknowledge their fave total irrelevance besides tabloid fodders

Honestly, they should ve ignored this thread and save the utter embarrassment

I mean look at Britney stans's posts in page 13 alone, just complete and utter delusion 

 

 

Edited April 17, 2023 by Enrique523