poll Bigger career: Taylor Swift or Britney Spears?

[M!X]

Taylor has surpassed Britney, idk why Brit fans are struggling to accept that, Taylor is still going strong while Britney is literally not even an active popstar anymore

Edited April 16, 2023 by M!X

[Enrique523]

1 hour ago, M!X said:

Taylor has surpassed Britney, idk why Brit fans are struggling to accept that, Taylor is still going strong while Britney is literallt not even an active popstar anymore

I think it's because Britney stans are still living in the time where they believed the only other female artist above her was Madonna. They still act as of it's the 1998-2003 period.

[Intuition]

Taylor and it's not even close. 

Anyone saying anything different is delusional or living in 2003.

[Ms. Togekiss]

the misogyny coming from the Britney stans  why are swifties taking the bait and entertaining such delusional Britney stans 

[TrieLz]

Bigger overall career: Taylor

 

Bigger peak: Britney

[FSXP]

Taylor has the bigger career, but Britney is more iconic and more influential. 

[Enrique523]

One thing i also find funny is how Britney stans are saying Taylor has no "impact", which is a EXTREMELY subjective argument to make yet they say it so confidently 

 

The way her music and lyrics are so constantly dissected, analyzed and taken seriously by so many people is impact. I mean there's a reason she managed to cultivate and maintain such a massive and loyal fanbase in a way no other female artist has EVER done. You can't accomplish that if you have no impact. Do you think Britney's music would ever by as analyzed and taken seriously as Taylor's is?

 

If we're talking about direct musical impact: she's the biggest inspiration of Olivia Rodrigo, one of the biggest female breakthrough artists of the 2020s. And Olivia definitively won't be the last, Taylor is massively beloved by so many celebrities.

 

I'm not denying that Britney had her own impact too, she did have an impact. But saying that Taylor has no impact is, as i said, extremely subjective and show a really shallow idea of what "impact" is.

[HappierJealousy]

If I was a Britney stan I would just let this thread tank instead of keeping fighting

[Headlock]

9 hours ago, Josh said:

Her feud with that actress; Camilla Belle was possibly her biggest career moment prior to the Kanye incident 

 

9 hours ago, Josh said:

It wasn't until her break up with Harry is when people started paying attention to her musically

I love this website 

[nickolsen]

1 hour ago, Intuition said:

Taylor and it's not even close. 

Anyone saying anything different is delusional or living in 2003.

Or living outside the USA…

 

Taylor is a superstar in the US, Britney and her legacy is… global. 

[Intuition]

3 minutes ago, nickolsen said:

Or living outside the USA…

 

Taylor is a superstar in the US, Britney and her legacy is… global. 

This lie again.

Taylor is massive in Asia, Australia, and even Europe currently.

[nickolsen]

2 minutes ago, Intuition said:

This lie again.

Taylor is massive in Asia, Australia, and even Europe currently.

When was the last time she performed in France ?  

[Intuition]

Just now, nickolsen said:

When was the last time she performed in France ?  

France is not the world.

Midnights went #1 in France. Last time Britney had a #1 album there was 20 years ago 

[Majka Jeżowska]

Talent - Taylor

Sales - Taylor

Impact - Taylor

Awards - Taylor

Tour - Taylor

 

Please... 

[Brooklyn Baby]

The France argument again 

[The Music Industry]

7 minutes ago, Intuition said:

France is not the world.

Midnights went #1 in France. Last time Britney had a #1 album there was 20 years ago 

Lash it 

[perfillusion]

5 hours ago, Richie.Valdez said:

Read a book gargoyle 

With today’s inflation the Circus Tour grossed $194,000,000 USD

 

 

 

 

Noooo not personal attacks and inflation Britney is bad at touring, hence no tour over 150M and coming up with all kinds of pathetic excuses when Domination got scraped. She's always been more of a TRL act.

[nickolsen]

2 minutes ago, Intuition said:

France is not the world.

Midnights went #1 in France. Last time Britney had a #1 album there was 20 years ago 

Yeah, not the world but an important market to label an artist « global ».

 

Quote

The only time Taylor Swift performed in our country, this former country darling had yet to put away her banjo. It was in 2011, in a barely full Parisian Zenith, for the album Speak Now (2010). “There were tarps to hide the empty rows,”

https://www.lepoint.fr/pop-culture/musique/pourquoi-taylor-swift-boude-t-elle-la-france-et-vice-versa-22-01-2018-2188713_2946.php

Again, she’s big in the USA i’m not gonna deny that.

 

Britney Spears is more famous and her hits are known all around the world.

[nickolsen]

16 minutes ago, The Music Industry said:

Lash it 

Lash what ? 
 

« britney jean » sold more than « midnights» 

[Rev8]

1 hour ago, HappierJealousy said:

If I was a Britney stan I would just let this thread tank instead of keeping fighting

The ones arguing here, are probably new users.
(who don't even speak for the large part of the fandom

but search for fights and are Bad at arguments)

 

A large part of the Britney fandom, hasn't even entered this/these threads

 

 

 

The Army has been fighting these types of threads for years now, so it's a bit pointless now

especially when Britney is "retired"

[Enrique523]

1 hour ago, nickolsen said:

Or living outside the USA…

 

Taylor is a superstar in the US, Britney and her legacy is… global. 

Taylor has been global for over a DECADE now. Stop these lies already, "global" isn't France only you know? Her numbers are massive everywhere.

[G.U.Y_Del_Rey]

Taylor sweetie...

[Enrique523]

1 hour ago, Intuition said:

France is not the world.

Midnights went #1 in France. Last time Britney had a #1 album there was 20 years ago 

The way they ALWAYS bring up France as "proof" that she's not global, it's so pathetic 

 

If France is the only country you can ever bring up as "proof" then it pretty much confirms the argument has no value whatsoever. Especially since Midnights went #1 in France, completely destroying this idea that she's flopping there.

[Enrique523]

1 hour ago, Taeyong said:

The France argument again 

It's literally a parody argument at this point 

[Enrique523]

1 hour ago, nickolsen said:

Lash what ? 
 

« britney jean » sold more than « midnights» 

Ok, you HAVE to be a troll at this point. Otherwise why would you set up Britney like that? 

 

Britney Jean more successful than Midnights, i'm CACKLING