Xalric Posted April 9, 2023 Posted April 9, 2023 2 minutes ago, hétérosexuelle said: And are those AKMU and GD in the room with us right now? yes
Mel. Posted April 9, 2023 Posted April 9, 2023 9 minutes ago, armink said: You should check it out! I know you must be starved of good music with real choruses as a YG stan I definitely won’t and I’m definitely not.
Hazy Posted April 9, 2023 Posted April 9, 2023 Like Crazy is actually a nice track I just get the flashbacks from the encore when the song starts
Sheep Posted April 9, 2023 Posted April 9, 2023 (edited) 3 minutes ago, siratakexxx said: Jimin's best sing i fear A lot of ppl aren't ready to talk about it but Vibe singlehandedly proved that Teddy still has it and is just being forced to work with some of the worst idol groups of all time. Give him singers with natural appeal and a SMASH comes out. Edited April 9, 2023 by Century
Mel. Posted April 9, 2023 Posted April 9, 2023 1 minute ago, siratakexxx said: Jimin's best sing i fear And it not even being his is a ki!
cloudbusting Posted April 9, 2023 Posted April 9, 2023 Jimin vs Jisoo has to be the greatest example of a mid-off this thread has seen in a minute both released absolute horsesh*t i fear but they’re undeniably doing well commercially and at least Jisoo is beautiful
BellKat Posted April 9, 2023 Posted April 9, 2023 9 minutes ago, WhalieX said: Literally who cares if it debuts and then falls off the chart or doesn't debut at all? None of these songs are hits anyways and there's nothing to downplay here. Jisoo is smashing in her main market and that's all that matters. Good she is doing great in Asia but isn't Blackpink the biggest GG worldwide? Blinks have terrorised and mocked other GGs for years by showing off their "Western" appeal and now you are telling it did not translate into ANY sort of success? After all these years?? Blackpink is not on any different level to all the other groups they mocked? The guts to have come after the "local" groups... Blackpink is big in Asia, amazing! But did blinks lie all this time it? What Am I saying, ofc they did
hétérosexuelle Posted April 9, 2023 Posted April 9, 2023 1 minute ago, Xalric said: yes August 2021? Ok also AKMU make their own music, YG as a music label is 100% musically and creatively bankrupt right now (So are SM & JYP tho, but TWICE still had Talk That Talk and SM groups have the odd good album track here and there)
Adama Posted April 9, 2023 Posted April 9, 2023 1 minute ago, Hazy said: okay, I will give him that he’s a good dancer and has charisma and stage presence, but still it’s nothing groudbreaking - his vocal abilities are mid, armys brainwashed everyone into thinking he’s something extraordinary in that department when he’s not I would say he’s the jack of all trades and master of none, but it’s nothing new that male popstars are applauded for the bare minimum and mediocrity it’s such a shame he would be considered an outstanding (male) performer in the west when there are for sure more skilled idols in kpop than him Do you have exemple? Outside soloists like Baekhyun, Kei and GD/Taeyang + BI who can performs and sing well at the same time but otherwise I don’t see anyone that is better than him? Kai, Chimin, TAEMIN are amazing dancers but when they performs they aren’t singing live and their vocals are not strong. Kang Daniel is average, def not better than JK.
Mel. Posted April 9, 2023 Posted April 9, 2023 Not YG being musically bankrupt as if your favs companies haveht been using thier formula and concepts and not doing anything groundbreaking either…
Pluto6 Posted April 9, 2023 Posted April 9, 2023 (edited) 2 minutes ago, Adama said: Kai, Chimin, TAEMIN are amazing dancers but when they performs they aren’t singing live and their vocals are not strong. Kang Daniel is average, def not better than JK. Taemin not having strong vocals ???????? Edited April 9, 2023 by Pluto2022
Sheep Posted April 9, 2023 Posted April 9, 2023 (edited) Whining about the creativity of idol group music is like whining about the culinary excellence of McDonalds. If non-idols don't count then you need to bffr Edited April 9, 2023 by Century
New Edition Posted April 9, 2023 Posted April 9, 2023 See JYP when you promote songs that sound girls and girls who can actually SING them.....
smates Posted April 9, 2023 Posted April 9, 2023 9 minutes ago, Hazy said: it’s such a shame he would be considered an outstanding (male) performer in the west when there are for sure more skilled idols in kpop than him Can you name them? I can think of great rappers and dancers (like his bandmate J-Hope for example) and great singers like Chen and D.O. but I just genuinely cannot think of someone who can do all of that without relying on backtrack during intense routines and also look good while doing it. Maybe I need to check more boy groups.
Dialamba Posted April 9, 2023 Posted April 9, 2023 #9 melon but #43 Flo Interesting also Set me free didn’t enter on BB, Moonlight Sunrise did
Sheep Posted April 9, 2023 Posted April 9, 2023 1 minute ago, smates said: Can you name them? I can think of great rappers and dancers (like his bandmate J-Hope for example) and great singers like Chen and D.O. but I just genuinely cannot think of someone who can do all of that without relying on backtrack during intense routines and also look good while doing it. Maybe I need to check more boy groups. Literally all 5 members of SHINee.
ItsJustMe. Posted April 9, 2023 Posted April 9, 2023 2 minutes ago, BellKat said: Good she is doing great in Asia but isn't Blackpink the biggest GG worldwide? Blinks have terrorised and mocked other GGs for years by showing off their "Western" appeal and now you are telling it did not translate into ANY sort of success? After all these years?? Blackpink is not on any different level to all the other groups they mocked? The guts to have come after the "local" groups... Blackpink is big in Asia, amazing! But did blinks lie all this time it? What Am I saying, ofc they did but now you are assuming that a solo will do the same as a group release.. blackpink's latest singles all charted on billboard jisoo clearly doesn't have the same western appeal as her other members she still got a cute top 40 hit in the UK tho (which is the highest debut for a kpop female artist ) so I guess she does have western success as well
worldwide angel Posted April 9, 2023 Posted April 9, 2023 7 minutes ago, BellKat said: Good she is doing great in Asia but isn't Blackpink the biggest GG worldwide? Blinks have terrorised and mocked other GGs for years by showing off their "Western" appeal and now you are telling it did not translate into ANY sort of success? After all these years?? Blackpink is not on any different level to all the other groups they mocked? The guts to have come after the "local" groups... Blackpink is big in Asia, amazing! But did blinks lie all this time it? What Am I saying, ofc they did so bc they don’t have a number one they don’t have western appeal despite racking up a plentiful of top 40 hits? they may not be #1 smashes but at least they can chart for more than 3 weeks
Mel. Posted April 9, 2023 Posted April 9, 2023 Korea is awake and starting their day off streaming this HIT!
ItsJustMe. Posted April 9, 2023 Posted April 9, 2023 3 minutes ago, Century said: Literally all 5 members of SHINee.
New Edition Posted April 9, 2023 Posted April 9, 2023 Oh yikes. I love Ive and Kitsch but the choreo and dancing here stinks
Hazy Posted April 9, 2023 Posted April 9, 2023 (edited) 15 minutes ago, Adama said: Do you have exemple? Outside soloists like Baekhyun, Kei and GD/Taeyang + BI who can performs and sing well at the same time but otherwise I don’t see anyone that is better than him? Kai, Chimin, TAEMIN are amazing dancers but when they performs they aren’t singing live and their vocals are not strong. Kang Daniel is average, def not better than JK. and you would put those capable idols you mentioned together with Jungkook? he’s able to carry a note while dancing (which should be bare minimum) but so are Blackpink even though they are no Mariahs too and they are dragged in here on a daily I won’t lie, I’m not that into boy groups so I won’t make any **** up, I had Stray Kids phase and they have more capable members than BTS so I’m not impressed by Jungkook or any BTS member like I was when I was first introduced to kpop but maybe boy group stans can educate us and give examples! also, when it comes to people like Jungkook, it just comes down to the star factor, not some outstanding skills and I won’t even start it with female idols and female western artists because it would be embarrassing for him, but like I said, the standard is different for the male stars and it’s sad Edited April 9, 2023 by Hazy
Adama Posted April 9, 2023 Posted April 9, 2023 11 minutes ago, BellKat said: Good she is doing great in Asia but isn't Blackpink the biggest GG worldwide? Blinks have terrorised and mocked other GGs for years by showing off their "Western" appeal and now you are telling it did not translate into ANY sort of success? After all these years?? Blackpink is not on any different level to all the other groups they mocked? The guts to have come after the "local" groups... Blackpink is big in Asia, amazing! But did blinks lie all this time it? What Am I saying, ofc they did Last time I checked BP TT charted inside the hot100? Lisa and Rosé also charted in the hot 100 so
armink Posted April 9, 2023 Posted April 9, 2023 3 minutes ago, Century said: Literally all 5 members of SHINee. Shinee has to be the most overrated group by kpop fans as a whole, and especially by sheep. Only Taemin is an ace like JK. All the other members are a tier below in dancing, especially considering Shinee's choreo has never been as intense as BTS. And before the sheep lose their mind, yes Shinee can sing and yes Shinee has plenty of good music.
Recommended Posts