rate Mariah Carey's Discography Rate | Top 246-1 Revealed

[Pikachoo]

On 12/24/2022 at 2:38 PM, Saddy said:

131. O.O.C.
Score: 6.956

High score: 11 (Zaynsus, Limitless)
Low score: 0 (Bacardo Royale)

 

umm...this is such a fun song. why so low?

[naval23]

One Sweet Day outlasting ill be there 

[Pikachoo]

Migrate is already out.

 

i just... this rate is a mess and a half (and i'm loving it)

[suburbannature]

Literally how tf is Vanishing out that’s a top ten Mariah song 

[Chris]

3 hours ago, suburbannature said:

This song is SO mediocre. Why was it even this high 

I cannot believe you.

 

This is one of my favorites from E=MC

[BenAmuro]

Migrate is out?! 

[killer_rose]

3 hours ago, Pop culture said:

Love you @killer_rose don't take it personally

You've been serving obsessed mariah hater for the past week or so, so maybe take your meds.

[killer_rose]

2 hours ago, JoAddams said:

banned 

I'm glad you're okay now 

 

all of you... get out now! 

This rate is serving haters putting in their votes, so many gorgeous songs already being out...

 

[Ivory.]

3 hours ago, Saddy said:

That's all for today!  
Songs that are still in the game:

Mariah Carey (6/11)
Vision of love
I don't wanna cry
Someday
Alone in Love
Prisoner
Love takes time
 

Emotions (4/10)
Emotions
Can't let go
If it's over
Till the end of time
 

Music Box (4/10)
Dreamlover
Anytime you need a friend
Music box
Without you
 

Merry Christmas (4/10)
All I want for Christmas is You
O Holy Night
Christmas (Baby please come home)
Miss you most (at Christmas time)

 

Daydream (6/12)
Fantasy
Underneath the stars
Always be my baby
Melt away
Forever
Daydream interlude
 

Butterfly (10/14)
Honey
Butterfly
My all
The Roof (back in time)
Fourth of July
Breakdown
Babydoll
Close my eyes
Fly away (butterfly reprise)
Outside
 

Rainbow (4/14)
Heartbreaker
Bliss
Heartbreaker da brat & missy eliot
Crybaby
 

Glitter (5/12)
Lead the way
Didn't mean to turn you on
All my life
Never too far
Loverboy cameo
 

Charmbracelet (3/15)
Boy (I need you)
The one
Subtle Invitation
 

The Emancipation of Mimi (8/20)
It's like that
We belong together
Shake it off
Mine Again
Stay the night
Circles
Fly like a bird
Don't Forget about us
 

E=MC2 (4/16)
Touch my body
I'm that Chick
I'll be lovin' U long time
For the record
 

Memoirs of an imperfect angel (3/17)
Obsessed
H.A.T.E.U.
Candy bling
 

Merry Christmas II You (0/13)

 

Me. I am Mariah… The Elusive Chanteuse (3/17)
Faded
Dedicated
#Beautiful
 

Caution (6/11)
GTFO
Caution
The Distance
Giving me life
8th grade
Runway
 

The Rarities (3/15)
Do you think of me
Everything fades away
Slipping away

Other Singles (7/29)
When You Believe
I Know What You Want 
Fantasy Remix
I Still Believe
Thank God I Found You/Make It Last
My All/Stay Awhile
Fantasy Sweet Dub Mix

Alone In Love and Babydoll still alive. IKTR

[Pop culture]

37 minutes ago, killer_rose said:

You've been serving obsessed mariah hater for the past week or so, so maybe take your meds.

I've always hated Please Put That Away (Mariah's Worst) 

[Pop culture]

Why is Don't Forget To Make A Good Song still in?

 

[GraceRandolph]

6 hours ago, Saddy said:

108. Migrate
Score: 7.283

 

High score: 11 (Pikachoo)
Low score: 0 (Ken Lee)

 

Opinions:
pikachoo: "A BOP AND A HALF. lord have mercy"

Thank you to the prophet @Pikachoo for your exquisite taste and adamant defense of Queen Gaga. @Ken Lee what are you doing????? How could you????

[°ColdFire°]

7 hours ago, Saddy said:

120. When I saw you
Score: 7.097

 

High score: 11 (JoAddams, Onopka, °ColdFire°)
Low score: 1 (Sjane)

 

Literally her best song 

Years ago, a friend of mine recommended me to listen Daydream, and the first time I went through it, I reviewed an album for him and texted him how I didn't find anything special about WISY. He told me that he was surprised considering it was one of his faves on the album, and I decided to listen it again, and the way it snapped. No wonder I'm balding 

6 hours ago, Saddy said:

109. Say Somethin'
Score: 7.278

 

High score: 11 (Zaynsus)
Low score: 0 (Ken Lee)

 

Opinions:
pikachoo: "terrible"

Deserved better! 

6 hours ago, Saddy said:

108. Migrate
Score: 7.283

 

High score: 11 (Pikachoo)
Low score: 0 (Ken Lee)

 

Opinions:
pikachoo: "A BOP AND A HALF. lord have mercy"

138 positions too high 

6 hours ago, Saddy said:

104. Endless Love
Score: 7.292

High score: 10 (JoAddams, BenAmuro, Devin, Zaynsus, Keter, pop culture, Bacardo Royale, curiosity)
Low score: 1 (That Bad Eartha, xfreshkidxx)

 

I really want to like this song, but it's just forgettable. 

6 hours ago, Saddy said:

98. I'll Be There
Score: 7.333

 

High score: 11 (°ColdFire°)
Low score: 1 (xfreshkidxx)

 

Ugh, the way ATRL always wants to be edgy and disregard some amazing songs. 

 

#1 nevertheless.  

6 hours ago, Saddy said:

95. Make It Happen
Score: 7.381

 

High score: 11 (James_Dean)
Low score: 0 (Ken Lee) 

 

Opinions:
Killer_rose: "the studio version is just ****"
James_dean: "Infectious beat. Positive, motivating, inspiring message. We stan."

The vocals are incredible in this song, but the song itself doesn't hit me anymore the way it used to. 

5 hours ago, Saddy said:

90. One Sweet Day
Score: 7.419

 

High score: 10 (BenAmuro, Kiss It Better, Devin, Zaynsus, Keter, xfreshkidxx, suburbannature, curiosity)
Low score: 1 (killer_rose)

 

Opinions:
Killer_Rose: "I simply cannot stand it"

It's epic. It's dramatic. It's beautifully sung. It's beautifully written. 

However, it misses something. A melody? 

5 hours ago, Saddy said:

88. All In Your Mind
Score: 7.456

 

High score: 11 (jacklovesyou1, °ColdFire°)
Low score: 0 (Bacardo Royale)

 

Opinions:
Limitless: "an enjoyable BOP; island gyal tingz!"
Keter: "one of my all-time favorite MC songs."

Deserves top 20! So sad!

 

The way I know you guys have already sabotaged Without You too 

5 hours ago, Saddy said:

84. You Don't Know What To Do
Score: 7.495

 

High score: 11 (JoAddams, °ColdFire°, Quicksand)
Low score: 0 (Bacardo Royale)

 

Opinions:
Keter: "10 a BOP"

MIAMTEC is underrated! This song especially. Literally one of her best songs of the last decade 

5 hours ago, Melancholy said:

TASTE!!!

[Ken Lee]

6 hours ago, Saddy said:

95. Make It Happen
Score: 7.381

 

High score: 11 (James_Dean)
Low score: 0 (Ken Lee) 

 

Opinions:
Killer_rose: "the studio version is just ****"
James_dean: "Infectious beat. Positive, motivating, inspiring message. We stan."

Her most overrated song by FAR (alongside Anytime You Need a Flop). The power of my sabotage 

5 hours ago, Saddy said:

81. Oh Santa!
Score: 7.567

High score: 10 (JoAddams, Zaynsus, killer_rose, Ken Lee, Reverie, Melancholy, jacklovesyou1, Ivory., rocket, curiosity)
Low score: 0 (GraceRandolph, pop culture)

 

 

This whole album:

[Melancholy]

24 minutes ago, °ColdFire° said:

However, it misses something. A melody? 

It's right here "sorry...I never told you..." Guess she never told u bc u couldn't hear!!! 

[Miss Show Business]

So many good songs, OUT already...  Vanishing not being top rated for ha debut 

[xrosup]

9 hours ago, Saddy said:

103. Joy To The World
Score: 7.294

 

High score: 11 (JoAddams, xrosup)
Low score: 0 (Bacardo Royale)

 

Opinions:
Keter: "THE version of this song to listen to all the time, any time."

 

9 hours ago, Saddy said:

101. Sprung
Score: 7.321

 

High score: 10 (JoAddams, killer_rose, Keter, pop culture, sparrowblue, jacklovesyou1, Ivory., xrosup, curiosity)
Low score: 0 (That Bad Eartha, xfreshkidxx)

 

Opinions:
Keter: "another experiment that paid off!! This should have been on the regular damn album."

 

9 hours ago, Saddy said:

100. Yours
Score: 7.322

 

High score: 11 (Ivory.)
Low score: 1 (xfreshkidxx, rocket)

 

Not these already being out. I hate you tasteless GOATS

 

[suburbannature]

These results are more embarrassing than usual.

[Saddy]

1 minute ago, suburbannature said:

These results are more embarrassing than usual.

[Pikachoo]

4 hours ago, Pop culture said:

Why is Don't Forget To Make A Good Song still in?

 

Don't Forget About God is here to stay

 

[Pecinta Mariah]

1 hour ago, xrosup said:

 

 

Not these already being out. I hate you tasteless GOATS

 

This rate was rigged

 

 

[Guest]

11 hours ago, Saddy said:

Killer_rose: "This song helped me when I came out to my parents and they kicked me out of the house. It was a very difficult time in my life and this was the song that kept me going. They cannot take the light that shines brightly inside of me!"

@killer_rose this broke my heart and made me feel happy for you at the same time. I hope you found peace ♥️ 

[Guest]

10 hours ago, Saddy said:

pop culture: "One of Xtina's best songs"

nnnnn I can’t stand you @Pop culture but this made me SCREAM! Shdhdudhdhdhdhdggd

 

HELP?

[Guest]

9 hours ago, Pikachoo said:

umm...this is such a fun song. why so low?

 

9 hours ago, suburbannature said:

Literally how tf is Vanishing out that’s a top ten Mariah song 

 

7 hours ago, killer_rose said:

You've been serving obsessed mariah hater for the past week or so, so maybe take your meds.

HELP DJDHDJDHDHDHDHD

[SinnerCity]

13 hours ago, Saddy said:

118. Bringin' On The Heartbreak
Score: 7.106

 

High score: 11 (JoAddams, rocket)
Low score: 0 (sparrowblue)

 

Opinions:
pikachoo: "her best cover. The Ugly Ones wishes"

@sparrowblueYou will be dealt with.