yeezytaughtme Posted October 4, 2022 Posted October 4, 2022 vs Both of these female artists are hugely, talented, beautiful pop singers that dominated the 2010's. Katy dominated the early 2000's to the first half of the 2010's, while Ariana dominated the last half of the 2010's, to the early 2020's. But, which of these two successful female singers is the bigger household name and has the bigger career overall in 2022? Who has the better discography? This isn't meant to argue, be civil and discuss for fun.
queenoftheclouds Posted October 4, 2022 Posted October 4, 2022 Bigger Householdname: Katy Perry The rest: Ariana Grande
Michael196 Posted October 4, 2022 Posted October 4, 2022 Why the setup? the answer is obvious for all...
yeezytaughtme Posted October 4, 2022 Author Posted October 4, 2022 2 minutes ago, Michael196 said: Why the setup? the answer is obvious for all... Are you done? Lmao chill out...
Holiest Dreams Posted October 4, 2022 Posted October 4, 2022 Ariana is more known today, in fact she’s always been a bigger celeb than Katy who was never that relevant or big tabloid fodder. Neither makes timeless music but Katy’s catalogue of hits alone is more timeless than Ariana’s music, which is possibly the best example of music that’s of the moment Their overall careers are about even but Ariana still has a little bit of steam left I guess so she has the edge.
Great808 Posted October 4, 2022 Posted October 4, 2022 Ariana, although Katy may have the bigger hits. Ariana has lasted longer, remained consistent, and is the bigger pop culture icon.
Delirious Posted October 4, 2022 Posted October 4, 2022 Katy for all. Even the monthly listeners / daily streams prove it
NausAllien Posted October 4, 2022 Posted October 4, 2022 Katy for all except bigger career. Katy's music is just pop music excellence. All the singles of TD alone are bigger than Ariana's entire discography of forgettable songs. I can't even remember most of the songs she's put out since "7 Rings." But I will admit that Ariana's career is still thriving whereas Katy's has been in the decline since Witness. Ariana still has a chance to release a magnum opus, I just hope she stops doing this awful forgettable music she's been doing for the past 3 years.
MingYouToo Posted October 4, 2022 Posted October 4, 2022 (edited) I feel like Ariana Grande while having the longevity does not have the access and the ubiquity Katy Perry has, and its not her fault. Rather its a result of the climate Katy Perry thrived in vs when Ariana Grande hit it big. Katy came at a time when musicians were almost always massive celebrities. The era of Gaga, Beyoncé, 1D, etc. meant music and fame came hand in hand. Ariana came at a time when music has become so fractured and everyone has access to every subgenre they like at the tip of their finger. If Ariana came during Katy's era I dont doubt shed eclipse her but because of the nature of the musical climate during Ariana's time, Ariana's celebrity is much weaker with the older gen but definitely the strongest with Gen Z. Katy Perry has the bigger megahits but the sheer amount of hits Ariana has I feel like puts her above Katy. Katy has like 12 hits all megasmashes but Ariana has like 20+ songs that are all hits, varying from unavoidable Save Your Tears, 7 rings, thank u next, Problem and Bang Bang level to the longevity smashes like Into You and No Tears. Not to mention all of her hits are spread across nearly a decade since 2013. Overall I'd put Ariana above Katy. In terms of celebrity its Katy. In terms of hits its Ariana. Edited October 4, 2022 by MingYouToo
Safe&Sound Posted October 4, 2022 Posted October 4, 2022 Firework is a classic TGIF is a classic Every 4th of July, people will be reminded of once a pop phenomenon, Katy Perry, who sang Firework, from an album with 5 #1 hits, Teenage Dream So is TGIF, people still play it today to welcome the weekend Ariana is cute in the main pop girl list today A bigger celeb too But she will be easily forgotten with many female artists breaking through the mainstream market
Achilles. Posted October 4, 2022 Posted October 4, 2022 Katy has the bigger name and career. Neither has a good discography.
Blade Runner Posted October 4, 2022 Posted October 4, 2022 1 hour ago, Delirious said: Katy for all. Even the monthly listeners / daily streams prove it What?
Taylucifer Posted October 4, 2022 Posted October 4, 2022 Ariana for the first 2 and Katy for the bigger career overall Katy has like 2 amazing albums and 1 good album Ariana has 1 bad album and the rest is good/excellent
FightDragonsWithMe Posted October 4, 2022 Posted October 4, 2022 I'd give it to Ariana for all just based on her outlasting Katy & not ever having a Witness
BANKS Posted October 4, 2022 Posted October 4, 2022 i find this thread ironic considering the many times i’ve seen on this forum that Ariana “isn’t ready to headline the Super Bowl halftime show yet”. y’all really drive me crazy.
Siberian Tiger Posted October 4, 2022 Posted October 4, 2022 Ariana is bigger right now but I am not sure her hits will be remembered in 5-10 years like some Katy's so I say Katy for discography and overall career.
charot Posted October 4, 2022 Posted October 4, 2022 (edited) Ariana Katy Katy Edited October 4, 2022 by charot
CakeLikeLG Posted October 4, 2022 Posted October 4, 2022 1 hour ago, Delirious said: Katy for all. Even the monthly listeners / daily streams prove it ?
Recommended Posts