poll Judas vs. Where Have You Been: Bigger Hit?

[FreeXone]

I enjoy judas better but whyb is more known by GP.

 

With the gays tho Judas is THAT SONG. 

[DoubleRainbow!]

WHYB for all

[BOOMBAYAH]

WHYB

[bad guy]

WHYB for all. The sales, chart run, views, and recurrent streams prove that. Judas is not remembered at all.

[terrorblade]

whyb was bigger but judas is better and probs more remembered too. the #10 peak was an injustice

[AMIT]

WHYB for all. 

[yeezytaughtme]

WHYB for all three. 

[Alldeezy]

Judas sadly flopped! song was great, music video even better but Rihanna wins all 3.

[Sharapov]

7 hours ago, BODERLINE said:

Obviously WHYB was bigger, but Judas is the better song and it's not even close. I also would argue Judas is much more remembered. 

WHYB - 414m

Judas - 198m

[Erreur2 La Nature]

Judas was not a hit so WHYB by default.

 

Better: WHYB.

 

More remembered: WHYB. 

[flower moon]

I dont think either are remembered at all

But I prefer Judas (song) and WHYB (video)

[BODERLINE]

2 hours ago, Sharapov said:

WHYB - 414m

Judas - 198m

Having more streams doesn't mean anything. I already said WHYB was bigger. And obviously more people are more likely to still listen to it than one of Gaga's most controversial singles. Having more streams is not the same thing as being more remembered. There are hundreds of songs, all more successful than Judas with higher peaks and streaming numbers, yet still aren't remembered. If Judas REALLY wasn't remembered it would not get brought up nearly as often as it does in threads like this one. 

[zzmyth]

I didnt even remeber judas until I saw this thread.

 

I liked it tho. And remember the video and the controversy when it came out.

 

Still WHYB is THAT SONG.

 

Everyone chants along when it drops TBH

[BGKC]

Judas had a bigger, more controversial moment. It came and went tho. WHYB had lasting stability and was played quite frequently by pop radio for years in my city. I prefer Judas tho. 

Edited June 30, 2022 by BGKC

[Mr. Duff]

Where Have You Been for all. I don't know if it's being delusional to think that Judas is more remembered than Where Have You Been or just pure bias for Lady Gaga.

[UnusualBoy]

WHYB for all three. I remember when a snippet of the song was released, I felt in love with it right away.

[modeblock]

Both mega bops, but the stats point to  WHYB.

 

My personal preference is Judas tbh. I used to think it was a hot mess Bad Romance flop-rehash, but it's grown on me immensely during the years, whereas I LOOOOVED WHYB when it came out and, while I still enjoy it, it does sound VERY VERY of-its-time in a bad way. 

[AlexandraDetillieu]

On 6/30/2022 at 11:07 AM, Erreur2 La Nature said:

Judas was not a hit so WHYB by default.

 

Better: WHYB.

 

More remembered: WHYB. 

Yet Judas is bigger s than any """"hit""""" by your fav as a lead artist in the 2010s and 2020s

 

Spotify:

 

Judas - 441,105,371

Hold Me Closer - 374,242,686

Work ***** - 323,211,273

Criminal - 246,866,345

TTWE - 170,128,903

I Wanna Go - 159,317,539

Make Me - 132,524,067

Hold It Against Me - 74,297,330

[Saddy]

Judas, Juda-ah-ah