poll Judas vs. Where Have You Been: Bigger Hit?

[Scotland]

 

 

Which was bigger?

 

 

 

[GoodGuyGoneGhetto]

“Where Have You Been” for literally all. 
 

At least compare it to “The Edge Of Glory”, a song from that era that wasn’t forgotten about after the first week of release. 
 

[luckythisway]

WHYB but they’re equal quality size, in their own unique ways. Won’t tolerate pitting 2 of these legends’ best singles against each other 

 

[TalkThatRihanna]

WHYB for all

[Katamari]

eog outsold both

 

[RihFenty20]

Judas was iconic and it deserved more love. But WHYB is slightly better. 

[tshwark]

Judas hits like a truck, in WHYB Rihanna sounds bored.

[Jooj]

WYHB for all 3, its amazing 

[xxxlamb]

wwyb for 3...but Judas video is iconic.

this was a very hard choice wow 

[Fanta]

This is the most RANDOM comparison ever. 
 

WHYB for all but Judas is still a bop. 

Edited June 29, 2022 by Fanta

[unclefloprry]

WHYB but I like Judas too

[dirrtydiana]

WHYB sweetie I’m SO sorry

[NicoleAMatty]

Judas for all.

 

[Ampersand13]

Was Judas even an actual single? WHYB feels much much bigger but I genuinely love both 

[ninasayers]

i mean, WHYB is obviously the bigger song, it's not even a fair comparison, but i think Judas is better

[JoAddams]

WHYB for 3

[lex]

3/3 WHYB, but there are much better songs on BTW to compare it to 

[DiamondHoe]

Judas is gut-punching electro pop bliss. WHYB sounds like a random demo radio fodder. 
 

Judas is also more remembered 

[CrimsonX]

WHYB for all. The disrespect. The songs aren’t even in the same league.

[CrimsonX]

Marry the night would’ve actually been a more appropriate comparison. 

[TeemoR]

Judas is DEFINITELY better than the other one.

[Jude]

WHYB is obviously bigger.

Edited June 30, 2022 by Jude

[naval23]

The multiweek top 5 hit

[BODERLINE]

Obviously WHYB was bigger, but Judas is the better song and it's not even close. I also would argue Judas is much more remembered. 

[Phaunzie]

WHYB: Better Video ( One of Rihanna best) and a great song, I would say Judas is the better song however I wish the video was more heavy handed with religious imagery and less biker gang. The video always seems like it missing something to pull all together narrative wise.