charts discussion Post's "Twelve Carat Toothache" 3rd day: 18.1M streams

[Bethenny Frankel]

4 hours ago, Billionaire said:

Chromatica - 48.3M

twelve carat toothache - 30.6M

funny how Chromatica is the bookmark for success now

 

[period sis]

lower debut than Happier Then Ever, a supposed 2019-fad. @Post Malone I need your thots on this

[magazine]

19 minutes ago, simmnfierzig said:

It would take 8.5 years to close a 10.2M gap with 3.300 daily 

 

And I mean if Katy's numbers are from 2019 it would take even longer than that, no?!

Seems almost impossible, but yeah who knows which catalog will be more remember in 5-10 years

katy perry is literally a 2008 popstar, ma'am

[More Than A Melody]

2 hours ago, Tusk said:

The excuses.   

I'm not even a stan. Y'all are just kinda horrible to everyone  

[Frozen99]

4 hours ago, aesthetic bih said:

Post Malone's (the atrl member) obsession with Billie is so random, like why would a Post stan care about Billie at all? 

ye obsession's not a good look

poor thang

[Dingdong123]

Nnn another fourth album curse

[Blade Runner]

A bigger decline than Katy (and that's something). Damnnn. 

[Blade Runner]

I feel like he's gonna get the Bieber treatment. Huge flops after a massive peak, but he'll rebound eventually. 

[fridayteenage]

5 minutes ago, Blade Runner said:

I feel like he's gonna get the Bieber treatment. Huge flops after a massive peak, but he'll rebound eventually. 

i don't like bieber, but his two albums after purpose were #1s, with a top 2 hit, and pop vocal album nominees. 

 

not what i would call huge flops...

[Blade Runner]

2 minutes ago, fridayteenage said:

i don't like bieber, but his two albums after purpose were #1s, with a top 2 hit, and pop vocal album nominees. 

 

not what i would call huge flops...

I'm talking about Journals (2013). He truly recovered thanks to Diplo. 

[bad guy]

9 hours ago, Billionaire said:

Less than HTE this is a POP EMERGENCY @Perfect Crime @bad guy 

And guarantee he won't have the longevity of HTE either since nothing on this album has a good classic song. Him being erased like this is no surprise. Everything @Post Malone touches bombs into oblivion.

 

[mikeyace16]

ONE THIRD of Taylor’s re-recording over an album that’s a DECADE old

[Aren]

some artists were just left in the pre-pandemic years.

[Cloudy]

The ATRL Post Malone user lashings

[terrorblade]

wrapped around your finger and I like you have grown on me tho hope he could snatch a hit or two wit h them

[Assassin]

happy for him.

[katara]

The way he was the last mumble rapper standing and now he is going extinct too.

 

Good riddance about damn time mumble rap is wiped off the music landscape.

[Assassin]

Day 2 streams: ~22.9M

[State of Grace.]

1st Day:

Happier Than Ever - 37.3m

Twelve Carat Toothache - 30.6m

Future Nostalgia - 29.2m

Rare - 25.3m

 

2nd Day:

Happier Than Ever - 29.1m

Future Nostalgia - 24.4m

Twelve Carat Toothache - 22.9m

Rare - 19.2m

 

Not him doing less than Future Nostalgia in his 2nd day, its OVER

 

 

The % drop isn't bad to be fair but chile

 

Edited June 5, 2022 by State of Grace.

[TaylenaStan]

Yeah just push ILY and WAYF, i feel like radio SHOULD love those 2 and maybe they can end up being cute hits with 500M+ streams and hopefully push the album to Plat but yeah after that cancel the era 
We'll see if he can rebound with his 5th album but even if not atleast he secured 3 mega smash eras with multiple 5XPlat+ albums and diamond singles 

[theintriguingone]

Is he even going to debut at #2 at this rate? It’s looking more and more like Harry’s third week might overtake TCT to #2 during the week.

[BigBangStan]

21 hours ago, aesthetic bih said:

Post Malone's (the atrl member) obsession with Billie is so random, like why would a Post stan care about Billie at all? 

@Post Malone was bandwagoning Billie during the WWFAWDWG era, but started dragging her when the HTE era started "flopping" and then he became a full-blown OBH. He used to drag Billie using Post stats. It's funny now how the tables have turned.

[SpaceMan]

That ILY song doesn't slap either, hmmm he might wan to start working on the next album

[Blue Ace]

[More Than A Melody]

4 hours ago, State of Grace. said:

1st Day:

Happier Than Ever - 37.3m

Twelve Carat Toothache - 30.6m

Future Nostalgia - 29.2m

Rare - 25.3m

 

2nd Day:

Happier Than Ever - 29.1m

Future Nostalgia - 24.4m

Twelve Carat Toothache - 22.9m

Rare - 19.2m

 

Not him doing less than Future Nostalgia in his 2nd day, its OVER

 

 

The % drop isn't bad to be fair but chile

 

The drop is not terrible, but it's not good.

 

Large percentage drops happen with albums that go viral first day and have huge streaming numbers, every big album has a large percentage drop second day (35% to 45% give or take).

 

Smaller debuts don't have large percentage drops. It's usually less than 25%. Posty dropped 25%+, even Rare had a smaller percentage drop second day.