Jump to content
Login issues ×
Winter Emoji Return + Best Of Extended Through Jan. 15! ×

Lady Gaga

Phoenixstar

By Phoenixstar
in Base

 Share

Recommended Posts

MonsterNavy Grand Master

MonsterNavy

Posted
Posted

Stupid Love is a fun, cute mindless bop nothing more nothing less

 

:suburban:

  • Like 3

  • Replies 267.4k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • Infernal Paradise

    7819

  • Almodusa

    6773

  • opbranden

    5692

  • hausofbryan

    5663

Popular Days

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Days

Vroom Vroom Grand Master

Vroom Vroom

Posted
Posted
5 minutes ago, Puttanesca said:

I've never hated SL as a song but my god the video is atrocious. If you used AI to create a lady gaga video it would give you something like that. It's like she was performing as a caricature of herself and I'm so happy that era of her career is over. I could say more but I don't want to offend those who live on planet chromatica :suburban:

The SL music video was a rushed mess. I see the concept they were going for, but what a disaster 

 

The other night I was high watching the Disease mv and it was giving me old Gaga mv vibes. It's so good 

  • Like 1
  • Thanks 1
technoprayer Proficient

technoprayer

Posted
Posted (edited)
9 minutes ago, Puttanesca said:

I've never hated SL as a song but my god the video is atrocious. If you used AI to create a lady gaga video it would give you something like that. It's like she was performing as a caricature of herself and I'm so happy that era of her career is over. I could say more but I don't want to offend those who live on planet chromatica :suburban:

the record and era was entirely ruined by the people she was hanging around with

bloodpop ruined the album and that cheap crew working on SL's video was really a chop

 :jonny5:

i really wish we could hear the album drafts with boys noize and sophie -  it gave us good demos

Edited by technoprayer
JoeAg Grand Master

JoeAg

Posted
Posted
42 minutes ago, Dumbledore said:

I like Stupid Love's pre chorus way more than Disease's

I'm sorry I know we love revisionism on ATRL.NET WORLD. MOTHAF*CKA IT IS TRUEEEEEEEE (I haven't eaten yet and it's 8:30 pm and i'm still in my undies)

 

but just... no. I don't get it ! it's so milquetoast compared to pretty much all of her other songs (other than uhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh whatchamacallit. OH! I forget jk. wait (

frankvert Grand Master

frankvert

Posted
Posted

Gar's 5 bottom worst songs: 

 

5. The Queen 

4. Free Woman 

3. Heal Me  :3rdplace:

2. Stupid Love :2ndplace:

1. Jewels N Drugs :1stplace:

 

  • Like 1
  • Confused 1
  • Thumbs Down 3
JoeAg Grand Master

JoeAg

Posted
Posted

Stupid Love is just weak compared to all of her other leads idk how to fully explain it

 

and I don't even think Born This Way or Perfect Illusion are GREAT songs, but they still hit. and I won't deny that BTW is iconic just for being itself. Just Dance, Bad Romance, Applause, and Disease are all f*cking amazing pop songs :heart:

JoeAg Grand Master

JoeAg

Posted
Posted

Stupid Love is just weak compared to all of her other leads idk how to fully explain it

 

and I don't even think Born This Way or Perfect Illusion are GREAT songs, but they still hit. and I won't deny that BTW is iconic just for being itself. Just Dance, Bad Romance, Applause, and Disease are all f*cking amazing pop songs :heart:

GraceRandolph Grand Master

GraceRandolph

Posted
Posted

The fact that we're going to get LG7 before MTN hits 100M. :rip:

 

  • Haha 2
JoeAg Grand Master

JoeAg

Posted
Posted
10 minutes ago, frankvert said:

Gar's 5 bottom worst songs: 

 

5. The Queen 

4. Free Woman 

3. Heal Me  :3rdplace:

2. Stupid Love :2ndplace:

1. Jewels N Drugs :1stplace:

 

wait I'm so glad I'm not the only one who doesn't like The Queen :tornado: I remember people always defending it back in the day! it's just excessively cheesy and the production irks me for some reason. at least the pre-chorus is ALMOST cute ohwow.png

  • Like 1
Vroom Vroom Grand Master

Vroom Vroom

Posted
Posted

Applause has aged so well. It has really became a classic Gaga hit. We just need an ARTPOP song to go viral and make the album relevant again

 

It sucks that R. Kelly has writing credits on the solo version of the DWUW. That song being fully deleted really hurts AP

  • Like 6
  • Thanks 1
MonsterNavy Grand Master

MonsterNavy

Posted
Posted
8 minutes ago, GraceRandolph said:

The fact that we're going to get LG7 before MTN hits 100M. :rip:

 

the og gaga flop

 

we were supposed to have 10 #1 singles in the BTW era

:suburban:

 

 

  • Thanks 1
FailSafe Veteran

FailSafe

Posted
Posted (edited)
7 minutes ago, JoeAg said:

wait I'm so glad I'm not the only one who doesn't like The Queen :tornado: I remember people always defending it back in the day! it's just excessively cheesy and the production irks me for some reason. at least the pre-chorus is ALMOST cute ohwow.png

Bridge/Outro is a highlight tho so it's automatically not in her bottom 5 or even 10. Several tracks from debut and artpop are just downright atrocious from beginning to end

 

:clack:

Edited by FailSafe
GraceRandolph Grand Master

GraceRandolph

Posted
Posted
3 minutes ago, MonsterNavy said:

the og gaga flop

 

we were supposed to have 10 #1 singles in the BTW era

:suburban:

 

 

I would've loved to have 2 #1 singles but TEOG couldn't do it. 

Puttanesca Veteran

Puttanesca

Posted
Posted
21 minutes ago, technoprayer said:

the record and era was entirely ruined by the people she was hanging around with

bloodpop ruined the album and that cheap crew working on SL's video was really a chop

 :jonny5:

i really wish we could hear the album drafts with boys noize and sophie -  it gave us good demos

Yeah I genuinely think she was in a mental place where she couldn't actually put in the passion for her work, so she relied on the people around her to come up with material and well.... :cm:

 

At least this time around she's mentally in a great space and the music sounds incredible. She just needs to remember she has an album coming out next month ooop

  • Thanks 1
longjohn9898 Experienced

longjohn9898

Posted
Posted

Songs that aged well for me: Judas (might be my favorite song these days and my most played of 2025 aside from DWAS), Applause (never gets old), So Happy I Could Die (wasn't a huge fan when released but it's a bop)

 

Songs that didn't: Monster (one of my faves when it was released but just good now), Stupid Love (a cute bop but I never voluntarily play it, if it comes on in the club it's aiiight)

 

Disease is a grower and a show-er though…underappreciated song :clap3:

Infernal Paradise Grand Master

Infernal Paradise

Posted
Posted

@Stupid Love

 

 

  • Thanks 1
  • Haha 11
Dylangaga Veteran

Dylangaga

Posted
Posted

I just watched Call Me By Your Name for the first time and omg I'm so depressed!!:cries:

 

GAGA ANNOUNCE SOMETHING to relieve me of this sadness!!

  • Haha 5
hausofbryan Grand Master

hausofbryan

Posted
Posted

Winds are slowing down significantly in LA, so hopefully Gaga and her loved ones are safe and the entire community gets relief soon. 

  • Like 3
frankvert Grand Master

frankvert

Posted
Posted
34 minutes ago, JoeAg said:

wait I'm so glad I'm not the only one who doesn't like The Queen :tornado: I remember people always defending it back in the day! it's just excessively cheesy and the production irks me for some reason. at least the pre-chorus is ALMOST cute ohwow.png

 

29 minutes ago, FailSafe said:

Bridge/Outro is a highlight tho so it's automatically not in her bottom 5 or even 10. Several tracks from debut and artpop are just downright atrocious from beginning to end

 

:clack:

If the bridge & outro were a separate song then it wouldn't even be a conversation. But the first upbeat half is SO. BAD. And not in a redeemable way. I can't think of any Gar songs I like less so that's why it's in my bottom 5. Maybe Money Honey but at least that one's fun 

 

:khalyan:

  • Thanks 1
GraceRandolph Grand Master

GraceRandolph

Posted
Posted
6 minutes ago, Dylangaga said:

I just watched Call Me By Your Name for the first time and omg I'm so depressed!!:cries:

 

GAGA ANNOUNCE SOMETHING to relieve me of this sadness!!

spacer.png

  • Haha 4
hausofbryan Grand Master

hausofbryan

Posted
Posted
55 minutes ago, frankvert said:

ROM I understand but Happy Mistake? All of a sudden I hear "if I could bottle up a sunny day" clear as ever and my head literally whipped around at a 90 degree angle cause I thought I was hallucinating 

 

:suburban:

you were in the presence of another liddo

 

:lakitu:

 

it's the only song on Harlebomb worth revisiting, so I get it!

Valgorie Explorer

Valgorie

Posted
Posted
49 minutes ago, frankvert said:

Gar's 5 bottom worst songs: 

 

5. The Queen 

4. Free Woman 

3. Heal Me  :3rdplace:

2. Stupid Love :2ndplace:

1. Jewels N Drugs :1stplace:

 

The Queen and Heal Me strays, you take that back rn 

 

:khalyan2:

  • Like 2
Dylangaga Veteran

Dylangaga

Posted
Posted
9 minutes ago, GraceRandolph said:

spacer.png

asdlkckskak

 

Depression CANCELLED!

 

I AM SO BACK!!

JoeAg Grand Master

JoeAg

Posted
Posted
40 minutes ago, FailSafe said:

Bridge/Outro is a highlight tho so it's automatically not in her bottom 5 or even 10. Several tracks from debut and artpop are just downright atrocious from beginning to end

 

:clack:

PFFFFF I wouldn't say SEVERAL from debut are atrocious! Money Honey ain't good, and Starstruck is incredibly dated, but otherwise the album is a pop masterclass imo ohwow.png

  • Confused 1
 Share
Go to topic listing

Obsessed with Pop Culture. Copyright © 1999-2024, ATRL

Navigation

About Us

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.