charts discussion HDD: 5SOS #1 140k, THE CARTERS #2 124k (70k pure), XTINA 69k

[istan4badgalriri]

12 minutes ago, Lights and Waves said:

Notice how every single stan base is celebrating this flop. This is proof that Beyhive are even worse than Little Monsters were during Gaga's peak. Y'all brought this on yourselves.

let's not  

[cuneytb]

17 minutes ago, Lights and Waves said:

Notice how every single stan base is celebrating this flop. This is proof that Beyhive are even worse than Little Monsters were during Gaga's peak. Y'all brought this on yourselves.

Perfectly said  

[_Fey]

22 minutes ago, Lights and Waves said:

Notice how every single stan base is celebrating this flop. This is proof that Beyhive are even worse than Little Monsters were during Gaga's peak. Y'all brought this on yourselves.

Ummmm I wouldn't go that far. Even after ARTPOP and Joanne, monsters are the cockiest and most insufferable base.

[Lights and Waves]

1 minute ago, _Fey said:

Ummmm I wouldn't go that far. Even after ARTPOP and Joanne, monsters are the cockiest and most insufferable base.

Wrong.

[unclefloprry]

33 minutes ago, Lights and Waves said:

Notice how every single stan base is celebrating this flop. This is proof that Beyhive are even worse than Little Monsters were during Gaga's peak. Y'all brought this on yourselves.

No tears (left to cry available on iTunes) just tea. 

[SilencePlease]

Those desperate FadOf2008 and FadOf1999 stans were really waiting for a chance to come at Bey right?

 

Know your place. Blessings.

 

[Alena]

16 hours ago, Lil Mxnster said:

 im living

[Mariano]

20 minutes ago, _Fey said:

Ummmm I wouldn't go that far. Even after ARTPOP and Joanne, monsters are the cockiest and most insufferable base.

The lies. Gaga is really special tho, i love how during witness and this there are still some people who are trying to shift the hte towards Gaga still   i love how there are still people posting about the monsters/Gaga while ignoring the other fanbases who are doing currently much more than the monsters. Gaga her power of having people pressed  

[Mariano]

4 minutes ago, SilencePlease said:

Those desperate FadOf2008 and FadOf1999 stans were really waiting for a chance to come at Bey right?

 

Know your place. Blessings.

 

This coming right before my comment  thanks for the receipts

 

a katy fan calling Gaga a fad   and hoping that Bey Hive will be nice to the kats next time around  

Edited June 23, 2018 by Mariano

[Nein]

8 minutes ago, SilencePlease said:

Those desperate FadOf2008 and FadOf1999 stans were really waiting for a chance to come at Bey right?

 

Know your place. Blessings.

 

Your avi is literally from Bon Appetit. Know your place. Xo

[_Fey]

4 minutes ago, Mariano said:

The lies. Gaga is really special tho, i love how during witness and this there are still some people who are trying to shift the hte towards Gaga still   i love how there are still people posting about the monsters/Gaga while ignoring the other fanbases who are doing currently much more than the monsters. Gaga her power of having people pressed  

I was literally responding to someone who was making this thread about Gaga and her stans. If that isn't proof that monsters love making everything about themselves lmao

[ExHuman]

Tidal can't report big fake streams anymore even when they did yesterday cuz 14 million from spotify and 90 million from Tidal? Sure Jean.

 

But they can't fake huge streaming like they did for Lemonade they are under investigation so they are doing it carefully right now.

[Chemical X.]

4 hours ago, Starkboy said:

why did this turn into a Rihanna thread

 

yikes

ugh, her mind

[Liafen]

Who would've thought I'd live the day my fave would pull in 370k pure and Beyoncé & Jay Z TOGETHER would do 69k  

[Ryann]

1 hour ago, Lights and Waves said:

Notice how every single stan base is celebrating this flop. This is proof that Beyhive are even worse than Little Monsters were during Gaga's peak. Y'all brought this on yourselves.

Monsters post BTW and pre-Artpop were awful but I agree with everything else 

[Drive Bitch]

If you had told me last year a Carters album would barely outsell an Xtina album. 

 

[greeneyedsoul]

Beyuki is finally over.

 

[nick4bty]

I still can't believe they couldn't outsell a ****ing Gwen Stefani album

[A Million Lights]

[Oxygen]

This is so tragic  

[istan4badgalriri]

24 minutes ago, Mariano said:

The lies. Gaga is really special tho, i love how during witness and this there are still some people who are trying to shift the hte towards Gaga still   i love how there are still people posting about the monsters/Gaga while ignoring the other fanbases who are doing currently much more than the monsters. Gaga her power of having people pressed  

Yet little monsters invaded every EIL & APES**T related thread saying C2C/Joanne & The Cure outsold. Please  

[xproudofbritney]

At this point kpop stans did really helped? 

[Suspendedintheair]

12 minutes ago, Drive Bitch said:

If you had told me last year a Carters album would barely outsell an Xtina album. 

 

 

                                Nnnn .

 

                       

 

 

                           Sweet Jesus .

[cuneytb]

55 minutes ago, _Fey said:

Ummmm I wouldn't go that far. Even after ARTPOP and Joanne, monsters are the cockiest and most insufferable base.

The beyhive will forever be THIS. Not the monsters. 

[bntneyspears]

6 minutes ago, xproudofbritney said:

At this point kpop stans did really helped? 

they forgot to activate VPN.