poll Born This Way and Joanne vs. Cowboy Carter and Renaissance

[bjorn]

Liddos lost again 

[Burn]

One thing I noticed is @GraceRandolph is obsessed with making Gaga vs Bey comparison threads lol.

 

Just watch, there'll be another one within 48 hours.

[Florence Belch]

4 hours ago, Space Cowboy said:

I don't have to imagine. BTW is lowkey an incredibly overrated, painfully mediocre album that screams dated from start to finish. Some gays overhype it because they refuse to let go of nostalgia.

 

It's nowhere near the same level as Renaissance or CC 

I'm sorry, but I can't take seriously someone that says so, and I'll tell you why.

 

Ren and BTW are genuinely great albums for daring to push sounds and narratives in pop music, but what makes them stand out compared to the other twos (and many other pop albums) is how much they are replayable. They don't take themselves too seriously in being serious, and that's why they are so much fun to listen to and are genuinely aging the best.

 

You can say it's not your cup of tea, and that's fine. However, your belittling statement is clearly affected by your bias towards Gaga, and, honestly, that's a shame

[Feanor]

'RENAISSANCE' >>> 'Born This Way' >>> 'COWBOY CARTER' >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> 'Joanne'

 

Beyoncé takes this one.

[John Slayne]

BTW > Renaissance > Joanne > CC 

 

 

so Godga wins 

[LVP]

42 minutes ago, Burn said:

One thing I noticed is @GraceRandolph is obsessed with making Gaga vs Bey comparison threads lol.

 

Just watch, there'll be another one within 48 hours.

Better Italian roots? Gaga or Beyonce just to make sure she finally takes one

[Riverbank]

Renaissance >>>>> BTW

 

And I'd pick any album over Joanne so 

[Riverbank]

40 minutes ago, LVP said:

Better Italian roots? Gaga or Beyonce just to make sure she finally takes one

Not on Ann Marie Lastrassi's watch

 

[Shelter]

Renaissance clears anything Gaga has done 

[momal]

Born This Way has Marry The Night so it wins. Don't care about the rest.

[Maroonx]

BTW > R > J > CC

 

so I had to go with Gaga on this one x

[prézli]

lol

[Kiss It Better]

this setup