base talk Midnights > Red. Agree?

[prettyinpink940]

 

Midnights is better than Red. Agree? 

[Taylor fanboy]

Red is messy while Midnights is consistent.

 

I would have to say YES.

[Blackout2006]

The Red title track alone washes anything on MIDnights, let us not 

[Feanor]

Well yes!

[Brooklyn Baby]

 

In no world does Midnights top an album with State of Grace, Red, Treacherous, All Too Well, The Last Time, Holy Ground, Sad Beautiful Tragic, Begin Again, Better Man, Nothing New, and Forever Winter.

[aotearoa]

No 

[blown away]

Oh hell no. State Of Grace alone is better than half of Midnights.

 

Red could've used some trimming, I will admit that. But there is a solid 12-track album in there.

[PerfectCure]

Red is an album written from the heart unlike the other option

[BlackoutZone]

No? State of Grace clears Midnights

[Nico Robin]

No but Midnights is lowkey her best pop alberm

[mxoonlight]

Please get your hearing checked.

[Stepfon]

28 minutes ago, Brooklyn Baby said:

 

In no world does Midnights top an album with State of Grace, Red, Treacherous, All Too Well, The Last Time, Holy Ground, Sad Beautiful Tragic, Begin Again, Better Man, Nothing New, and Forever Winter.

 

25 minutes ago, blown away said:

Oh hell no. State Of Grace alone is better than half of Midnights.

 

Red could've used some trimming, I will admit that. But there is a solid 12-track album in there.

 

11 minutes ago, BlackoutZone said:

No? State of Grace clears Midnights

Finally, I see some stanning for State of GOD and the answer is NO, sacRED is better than MIDnights. 

[smartalek22]

Absolutely not 

[SinnerCity]

Message in a bottle >>>>>>>>> MIDnights (sans Hits Different)

 

 

[gagacasanova]

If this was me talking in 2023, I would disagree. But after re-listening to all the albums last year, I can definitely say Midnights >> Red

Edited 3 hours ago by gagacasanova

[xperience30]

[ahauntingnearu]

1 hour ago, prettyinpink940 said:

 

Midnights is better than Red. Agree? 

This is a heinous question.

[Klein]

Only 3 albums are either better or on the same level as Red in her discography and sadly Midnights is not one of them. 

 

Huge fan of Midnights though, but Red just has waaaaaaaaaaay too many career highlights (the most of her entire discography).

 

29 minutes ago, SinnerCity said:

Message in a bottle >>>>>>>>> MIDnights (sans Hits Different)

Not you stanning the worst song (maybe second worst) out of 30 

[naval23]

Red is chaotic while Midnights is neutral

 

And has a holy trinity of "All Too Well", "State of Grace" and "Red" which is eons above anything you'll find on Midnights (other than Anti-Hero)

[liam13]

red sweetie, im so sorry that a ugly ahh bii would even say that. my goodness are u fkng insane? RED? you know what midnights sounds like? it sounds like 1989 rejects that taylor kept deep inside the vault.

[Illuminati]

29 minutes ago, Klein said:

Not you stanning the worst song (maybe second worst) out of 30 

Stay Stay Stay and Girl At Home, trashies...

[Klein]

4 minutes ago, Illuminati said:

Stay Stay Stay and Girl At Home, trashies...

I gotta admit I had forgotten about Vanessa At Home, so that would make MIAB the 3rd worst song on Red. My bad. 

[talentress]

Red has career highlights like ATW and Begin Again but, is not as interesting and well thought out a concept as Midnights especially 3AM tracks.

Edited 2 hours ago by talentress

[Gladiator]

Hmm, I don't think so. Certainly Midnights > the more pop songs on Red.

 

1 minute ago, Klein said:

I gotta admit I had forgotten about Vanessa At Home, so that would make MIAB the 3rd worst song on Red. My bad. 

I'm still peeved at Taylor's Version of that song. It's so, so bad.

[Bussea]

just gon head and delete this big dog