JO1s Posted yesterday at 01:37 PM Posted yesterday at 01:37 PM 2ne1 and SNSD both having 2 mil + monthly listeners 11 and 8 years since their last proper eras says a a lot. SKZ have a huge fandom but they'll probably be a tvxq or super junior type in terms of being remembered for their music. 1
Windy Day Posted yesterday at 01:37 PM Posted yesterday at 01:37 PM 1 minute ago, Pluto6 said: Why are you as a non korean worried about whether Stray Kids are popular in their home country or not, when they still managed to become one of the biggest kpop acts of all time globally this has to be the most unintelligent post in this thread you genuinely sounds like an imbecile NO SHADE 2
Gorjesspazze9 Posted yesterday at 01:37 PM Posted yesterday at 01:37 PM 1 minute ago, Ubermensch said: This is the US iTunes chart in 2012. This is before streaming and this was BY FAR the most important album chart in the entire world at the time. You could only ever buy an album ONE time on iTunes too, there were no streaming farm or bulk buy workarounds here. Heavy Bold "One Album" for these Gen Z kids. Let them know! We don't bulk buy in this house… unless it's I Got a Boy 9 versions👀… or EXO… 2
Ubermensch Posted yesterday at 01:39 PM Posted yesterday at 01:39 PM Just now, Gorjesspazze9 said: Heavy Bold "One Album" for these Gen Z kids. Let them know! We don't bulk buy in this house… unless it's I Got a Boy 9 versions👀… or EXO… IGAB only had 8 versions. 3 1
Darkling Posted yesterday at 01:39 PM Posted yesterday at 01:39 PM EN-karma To be honest I didn't like Loose that much, I mean, it was okay but I was hoping for a hoe anthem so it was a bit of a disappointment but anyway, excited for En-Chella in just one week!
Windy Day Posted yesterday at 01:39 PM Posted yesterday at 01:39 PM stray kids being one of the biggest kpop group of all time but their biggest song has... 400 millions streams and they have... 10m monthly listeners... okay 1
prettyinpink940 Posted yesterday at 01:42 PM Posted yesterday at 01:42 PM Me reading y'all arguing about SNSD's legacy
Pluto6 Posted yesterday at 01:42 PM Posted yesterday at 01:42 PM 29 minutes ago, Ubermensch said: BTS and Black Pink are the only groups that can truly claim to be on a totally different level to their 2nd gen counterparts, and even then its only because of endless media play and sajaegi to prop them up and kickstart their careers in the west, something that would have NEVER happened if Sone did not make the west into a viable market for kpop to seriously expand into. to act like groups like TWICE, Stray kids and NewJeans etc. aren't on a different level in the West compared to 2nd gen is just delusional worstie, sorry. And also, 3rd gen are the result of the global audience and the new wave of Kpop fans we have today that 4th gen groups are now benefitting from. For example, I Personally, got into K-pop thanks to BLACKPINK. At the time, no other group even came close to making it onto my radar. From there, I explored more and ended up getting into new groups and stanning groups like Stray Kids and TWICE etc.
Pluto6 Posted yesterday at 01:44 PM Posted yesterday at 01:44 PM 4 minutes ago, Windy Day said: stray kids being one of the biggest kpop group of all time but their biggest song has... 400 millions streams and they have... 10m monthly listeners... okay That still more than aespa's most streamed song though
Ubermensch Posted yesterday at 01:48 PM Posted yesterday at 01:48 PM (edited) 5 minutes ago, Pluto6 said: to act like groups like TWICE, Stray kids and NewJeans etc. aren't on a different level in the West compared to 2nd gen is just delusional worstie, sorry. NewJeans were definitely on track to be on that tier. I have literally never heard a normal person mention Twix or SKZ though. I'm a Twix fan too so its really really not about being shady or delusional. Twice are on that level in Asia but not ww, and if we're counting asian popularity then my stan list takes a wrecking ball to even BTS. 5 minutes ago, Pluto6 said: And also, 3rd gen are the result of the global audience and the new wave of Kpop fans we have today that 4th gen groups are now benefitting from. For example, I Personally, got into K-pop thanks to BLACKPINK. At the time, no other group even came close to making it onto my radar. From there, I explored more and ended up getting into new groups and stanning groups like Stray Kids and TWICE etc. And this happened because sone were in the trenches telling our friends that we listen to Korean music in a country so xenophobic that it tried to rename french fries into freedom fries. The endless spending on western marketing for BLACKPINK that included collabs with Dua, Cardi, Selena, and Gaga would have never happened if there wasn't a proven kpop fandom. Anyway thanks for another excuse to rant about SNSD's countless achievements and untouchable impact. It's the thing you're best for. Stream the greatest song ever recorded. Edited yesterday at 01:49 PM by Ubermensch 1
Pluto6 Posted yesterday at 01:50 PM Posted yesterday at 01:50 PM (edited) You guys are letting nostalgia get to you, cause how can you downplay SKZ or TWICE's numbers in the West and at the same time trying to make SNSD happen over there THE DELUSION Edited yesterday at 01:52 PM by Pluto6
Ubermensch Posted yesterday at 01:52 PM Posted yesterday at 01:52 PM Just now, Pluto6 said: You guys are letting nosstalgia get to you, cause how can you downplay SKZ or TWICE's numbers in the West and at the same time trying to make SNSD happen over there We witnessed the rise of bulk buying and spotify fraud so we're good at detecting it. Please stop setting up legends TWICE by putting them next to a group that literally nobody has ever heard of.
Gorjesspazze9 Posted yesterday at 01:53 PM Posted yesterday at 01:53 PM SNSD peaked changed all of kpop and literally started a new Hallyu wave. That's not nostalgia. They really did that. 4
Pluto6 Posted yesterday at 01:54 PM Posted yesterday at 01:54 PM 1 minute ago, Ubermensch said: We witnessed the rise of bulk buying and spotify fraud so we're good at detecting it. Please stop setting up legends TWICE by putting them next to a group that literally nobody has ever heard of. The nerve, when aespa are carried by Chinese bulk buys and SEA streaming farms globally
youresotoxic Posted yesterday at 01:54 PM Posted yesterday at 01:54 PM let me just sneak this SMASH in real quick 1 1
Pluto6 Posted yesterday at 01:55 PM Posted yesterday at 01:55 PM 1 minute ago, Gorjesspazze9 said: SNSD peaked changed all of kpop and literally started a new Hallyu wave. That's not nostalgia. They really did that. 1
Inspirit Posted yesterday at 01:56 PM Posted yesterday at 01:56 PM 2 minutes ago, Gorjesspazze9 said: SNSD peaked changed all of kpop and literally started a new Hallyu wave. That's not nostalgia. They really did that. 3 1
Ubermensch Posted yesterday at 01:58 PM Posted yesterday at 01:58 PM 3 minutes ago, Pluto6 said: The nerve, when aespa are carried by Chinese bulk buys and SEA streaming farms globally Meanwhile on planet earth, aespa has much better longevity on every relevant western chart both with albums and singles than your favs. 1
Windy Day Posted yesterday at 01:58 PM Posted yesterday at 01:58 PM 10 minutes ago, Pluto6 said: That still more than aespa's most streamed song though drama's daily streams 424,356 god's menu's daily streams 250,352 not for long i fear 1
Ubermensch Posted yesterday at 02:04 PM Posted yesterday at 02:04 PM 25 minutes ago, JO1s said: 2ne1 and SNSD both having 2 mil + monthly listeners 11 and 8 years since their last proper eras says a a lot. SKZ have a huge fandom but they'll probably be a super junior type in terms of being remembered for their music. The way this is an entire genre of boy group that falls off a cliff once they hit twink death and somehow new generations of fans keep getting duped into embarrassing themselves and all of the other kpop fans by putting them on a pedestal. 1
Windy Day Posted yesterday at 02:11 PM Posted yesterday at 02:11 PM also not comparing aespa and stray kids' daily streams when aespa only 84 tracks and does 4M while stray kids has 300+ and does 9M 1
MonsterNavy Posted yesterday at 02:14 PM Posted yesterday at 02:14 PM 1 hour ago, Ubermensch said: BTS and Blackpink did not pave the way we know and no blink is saying this. pluto is just inserting bp to this conversation to win cause bts, twice and stray kids combined "paving the way" isn't something anyone would take seriously 1 2
Recommended Posts