base talk Will Gaga get a solo hit before this decade ends?

[SweetOreosOfHeaven]

4 minutes ago, Devin said:

LMAO do u want me to pull gagas recurrent streams of her solo hits from 2011-now? 

 

 

2 minutes ago, Chris said:

Better yet, why not pull her album sales from 2011 til now?

 

Why don't we have that discussion instead?

The stench

[Stuart]

Stupid Love smashed in this house

 

[IBelonginYourArms]

6 minutes ago, Devin said:

LMAO do u want me to pull gagas recurrent streams of her solo hits from 2011-now? 

 

Do it. I bet they are not as embarrassing as all Urinade singles, Break My Hole, Cuff It (and soon Texas Hold 'Em) streams 

[Devin]

1 minute ago, SweetOreosOfHeaven said:

The stench

direct this comment to @Giorgoc

__
 

bc i came in here with good intentions. 

 

1 hour ago, Devin said:

yea i think she will snatch a solo hit from this album or from the next album. 

 

[MonsterNavy]

2 minutes ago, Hector said:

The Hold My Hand and Bloody Mary erasure

hold my hand

spotify - 350m

youtube music - 385m

 

bloody mary

spotify - 605m

youtube music - 436m (1.1B+ with unofficial uploads)

 

 

 

1. stupid love - moderate hit

2. rain on me - smash

3. 911 - flop (not even a single)

4. hold my hand - successful soundtrack song

5. bloody mary - smash viral hit from 2011

6. die with a smile - biggest song of the decade

7. disease - underperformance

 

7 official singles in 5 years and 5 of them are successful I dont see the drag lol

 

[SweetOreosOfHeaven]

5 minutes ago, Devin said:

direct this comment to @Giorgoc

__
 

bc i came in here with good intentions. 

 

 

My apologies miss gurl

16 Carriages soty 

[GagaChina]

when atrl says no then yes 

[Gangbaby]

3 hours ago, fememeist said:

She just can't keep relying on collabs forever. Once DWAS starts dying down and she moves onto promoting and releasing her new album next year, will the true lead single come soon?

 

No old 10+ year old songs going viral again, but actual new music from her
 

Thoughts

Hardly but you never know. Her solo projects are not really gp friendly tho she's experimenting and making whatever the hell she likes so I don't know why y'all bothered so much. As long as she has hits and at the same time doing whatever she likes it is what it is.

[Giorgoc]

31 minutes ago, Chris said:

Yes.

 

Halo?

 

Sweet Dreams?

 

Formation?

Tell me I'm wrong then proceed to validate what I said.

 

Halo and Sweet Dreams are from 2008. IF Formation is a hit with a #10 peak and 7 weeks on chart, isn't Stupid Love a hit with a #5 peak and 10 weeks on chart?

 

Please educate yourselves before pressing the "Submit Reply" button. Thanks.

[Chris]

2 minutes ago, Giorgoc said:

Halo and Sweet Dreams are from 2008

But they were technically released as singles in 2009.

 

So follow your own advice and educate yourself before hitting reply, madame.

[Chris]

I literally do not understand what Beyonce not having a hit single from 2009-2022 has to do with Gaga not getting a solo hit for the next five years.

 

 

And it's so telling how Monsters want to bring up Beyonce when the Swifties were also dragging Stefani through the dirt when Disease bombed as well.

 

 

[Giorgoc]

39 minutes ago, Devin said:

LMAO do u want me to pull gagas recurrent streams of her solo hits from 2011-now? 

 

 

37 minutes ago, Chris said:

Better yet, why not pull her album sales from 2011 til now?

 

Why don't we have that discussion instead?

The fact that y'all conveniently leave out 2008-2011 in order to create your own narrative is WILD. Either compare recent releases or all releases. But wait, that would paint Beyonce in a poor light, wouldn't it?

[Giorgoc]

8 minutes ago, Chris said:

But they were technically released as singles in 2009.

 

So follow your own advice and educate yourself before hitting reply, madame.

Forgive me in that case. She didn't have a solo hit in 13 years. Does that sound better?

 

8 minutes ago, Chris said:

I literally do not understand what Beyonce not having a hit single from 2009-2022 has to do with Gaga not getting a solo hit for the next five years.

 

 

And it's so telling how Monsters want to bring up Beyonce when the Swifties were also dragging Stefani through the dirt when Disease bombed as well.

 

 

I only said that to a Beyonce fan for mocking Gaga for not having a hit solo single in 13 years while Beyonce JUST got a solo hit single a couple of years ago after the same amount of time of being labeled a flop.

 

I'm not dragging Swifties because they own the music world atm, they are legit undraggable. And i'm trying to drag Beyonce either. GOD knows I love her old music SO much. It's just a bit annoying seeing her fans acting like that when they were in monsters' spot till a couple years ago.

[HASHTAGPOW]

1 hour ago, SweetOreosOfHeaven said:

Will OP get a life before the decade ends?

If OP collabs, yes

 

[Devin]

19 minutes ago, Giorgoc said:

The fact that y'all conveniently leave out 2008-2011 in order to create your own narrative is WILD. Either compare recent releases or all releases. But wait, that would paint Beyonce in a poor light, wouldn't it?

oh just like u conveniently left out bey's 1998-2008 (10 yrs compared to u mentioning gaga's 3 year 08-11) to formulate ur weird ass narrative? 

 

1 hour ago, Giorgoc said:

And she had no solo hits from 2009-2022. Am I wrong?

the mall is open and aint nobody shopping. learn how to troll better.

[Havoc]

12 minutes ago, Giorgoc said:

Forgive me in that case. She didn't have a solo hit in 13 years. Does that sound better?

 

I only said that to a Beyonce fan for mocking Gaga for not having a hit solo single in 13 years while Beyonce JUST got a solo hit single a couple of years ago after the same amount of time of being labeled a flop.

 

I'm not dragging Swifties because they own the music world atm, they are legit undraggable. And i'm trying to drag Beyonce either. GOD knows I love her old music SO much. It's just a bit annoying seeing her fans acting like that when they were in monsters' spot till a couple years ago.

The huge difference is that Beyonce was able to retain her status and significance regardless of where her singles were charting during those years.  The same cannot be said for Gaga in her drought.

 

Self titled and Lemonade may not have had a ton of hits, but they were such huge, cultural-shifting moments for her that it didn't matter. Could the same be said about Gaga during Artpop/Joanne/Chromatica?  

 

Beyoncé's name now somehow feels bigger now than it was during the Sasha Fierce. Could the same thing be said about Lady Gaga vs her TFM/BTW glory days? 

 

 

[Shelter]

22 minutes ago, Giorgoc said:

Forgive me in that case. She didn't have a solo hit in 13 years. Does that sound better?

 

I only said that to a Beyonce fan for mocking Gaga for not having a hit solo single in 13 years while Beyonce JUST got a solo hit single a couple of years ago after the same amount of time of being labeled a flop.

 

I'm not dragging Swifties because they own the music world atm, they are legit undraggable. And i'm trying to drag Beyonce either. GOD knows I love her old music SO much. It's just a bit annoying seeing her fans acting like that when they were in monsters' spot till a couple years ago.

Beyonce fucks up her releases so it's not the same. Gaga promoted the crap out of Artpop and Joanne, even Chromatica got more than what Beyonce has done. LG7 got more than what Beyonce did the last 2 eras until this halftime show. 

[Giorgoc]

14 minutes ago, Devin said:

oh just like u conveniently left out bey's 1998-2008 (10 yrs compared to u mentioning gaga's 3 year 08-11) to formulate ur weird ass narrative? 

 

the mall is open and aint nobody shopping. learn how to troll better.

I knew this was gonna come up.

 

Gaga's "last solo hit" according to y'all: 2011. Time from 2011 to now, 13 years.

Bey's "last solo hit" before Break My Soul: 2009. Time from 2009 to 2022, 13 years.

 

I was only trying to show to a Beyonce stan that their fave went through the same period of having no hits yet she managed to come back stronger than ever, hence why be nasty and think that Gaga might not do the same?

 

15 minutes ago, Havoc said:

The huge difference is that Beyonce was able to retain her status and significance regardless of where her singles were charting during those years.  The same cannot be said for Gaga in her drought.

 

Self titled and Lemonade may not have had a ton of hits, but they were such huge, cultural-shifting moments for her that it didn't matter. Could the same be said about Gaga during Artpop/Joanne/Chromatica?  

 

Beyoncé's name now somehow feels bigger now than it was during the Sasha Fierce. Could the same thing be said about Lady Gaga vs her TFM/BTW glory days? 

 

 

Are we in a different universe? Ever since C2C Gaga's name has been associated with a once in a generation voice, incredible performances, even some great acting. The GP respects her way more now than in her "glory days" because now they see her talent. Of course not as much as Beyonce, but that's because Beyonce has been consistently put out quality material while Gaga struggled during the ARTPOP/Joanne eras quite a bit with subpar albums. The GP respects Gaga a fuckton at this point in time, they just don't like her recent material.

 

You see ARTPOP/Joanne/Chromatica (a very well reviewed album, btw) while ignoring Oscars 2015, multiple Grammy's she's won during that period, ASIB and its' soundtrack, her Oscar win. Yes, the albums were bad. But somehow Gaga always found a way to show her talented side to the public.

 

I really do mean that I like Beyonce. She's the most talented girl out there at this point, I've always stood by that. But having stans of someone who was in the commercial gutters for over a decade come for Gaga who's been going through the same is quite ironic (and not even the same, Gaga had Shallow in the meantime, which even if not solo it IS a hit because of Gaga... Bradley isn't really a big name in music).

[Giorgoc]

8 minutes ago, Shelter said:

Beyonce fucks up her releases so it's not the same. Gaga promoted the crap out of Artpop and Joanne, even Chromatica got more than what Beyonce has done. LG7 got more than what Beyonce did the last 2 eras until this halftime show. 

So we're going to be using hypothetical scenarios that IF she promoted, she would have hits? I agree that she does **** up her releases, but that doesn't mean that IF she had promoted, the material would've clicked with the public (the songs wouldn've obviously done better but would they become hits? We'll never know). Just like it happened with this Halftime Show and Cowboy Carter.

[Devin]

22 minutes ago, Giorgoc said:

I knew this was gonna come up.

 

Gaga's "last solo hit" according to y'all: 2011. Time from 2011 to now, 13 years.

Bey's "last solo hit" before Break My Soul: 2009. Time from 2009 to 2022, 13 years.

in the 2010s

 

gagas last [real] solo hit was million reasons.

beys last [real] solo hit was formation.

 

both released in 2016. 

[Devin]

i cant 

[nadiamendell]

She will, but it really doesn't matter at this point. She's solidified her legend status and keeps releasing music the majority of her fans love, which is all that matters. 

[Giorgoc]

13 minutes ago, Devin said:

in the 2010s

 

gagas last [real] solo hit was million reasons.

beys last [real] solo hit was formation.

 

both released in 2016. 

?

Who made this specifically about the 2010s?

Thread title is implying that Gaga doesn't have a hit in the 2020s.

If we don't consider Stupid Love a hit, we can't consider Formation one either. IMO, both were hits. I'm just going by the OPs logic here.

[Chris]

The GP apparently respects Lady Gaga but they let Joker 2 go to shambles and let Disease go to waste.

 

[Joaco95]