base talk Will Gaga get a solo hit before this decade ends?

[By the Water]

11 pages for a "yes" or "no" question

 

 

I guess deep down we're all on the same page

 

[Mariano]

2 hours ago, BnPac said:

You are lying out of your teeth. 

The solo thing is something Monsters weaponized against both the Hives and navy. 

 

Even if they had wanted to, Hives simply could not use it when people on Atrl kept bringing the fact that CIL, Check On It and a lot of Beyoncé's songs had features. 

 

Quick little singles is also completely irrelevant to the issue of solo songs. 

 

OT : She doesn't need to, I guess. And please, we are at not yet even in the middle of the decade. 

The lies  ofc it's always the monsters lmfaoooo bye, there's no arguing with ATRLers. 
 

We really gonna act like hive and navy weren't using those arguments before liddos were  liddos only started dragging Bey after she did those remixes but ok. 

[Weld_E]

I have never seen a stanbase as delusional and unhinged as liddos. The audacity to come for ANY artist when your fave just had 3 nuclear BOMBS in a row needs to be studied. Y'all might've reported the disease thread to death, but that doesn't erase the fact that despite major play listing many artists dream of, her lead single embarrassingly bombed into oblivion. The fact that y'all are still mentioning ASIB's stats to inflate her success and relevance FIVE YEARS later is telling on its own lmfaoooo. 
 

The lack of self awareness to still have the nerve to come for Beyonce when she had a #1 single and #1 album that debuted with over 400k (something yall are desperately salivating to have) with the year Gaga had…

[Eternal220]

4 minutes ago, Weld_E said:

I have never seen a stanbase as delusional and unhinged as liddos. The audacity to come for ANY artist when your fave just had 3 nuclear BOMBS in a row needs to be studied. Y'all might've reported the disease thread to death, but that doesn't erase the fact that despite major play listing many artists dream of, her lead single embarrassingly bombed into oblivion. The fact that y'all are still mentioning ASIB's stats to inflate her success and relevance FIVE YEARS later is telling on its own lmfaoooo. 
 

The lack of self awareness to still have the nerve to come for Beyonce when she had a #1 single and #1 album that debuted with over 400k (something yall are desperately salivating to have) with the year Gaga had…

their pivot to DWAS as the "lead" single must be studied.

 

we have the facts however…

 

https://www.billboard.com/music/pop/lady-gaga-first-lg7-single-release-date-october-1235765998/

[SweetOreosOfHeaven]

19 minutes ago, Weld_E said:

I have never seen a stanbase as delusional and unhinged as liddos. The audacity to come for ANY artist when your fave just had 3 nuclear BOMBS in a row needs to be studied. Y'all might've reported the disease thread to death, but that doesn't erase the fact that despite major play listing many artists dream of, her lead single embarrassingly bombed into oblivion. The fact that y'all are still mentioning ASIB's stats to inflate her success and relevance FIVE YEARS later is telling on its own lmfaoooo. 
 

The lack of self awareness to still have the nerve to come for Beyonce when she had a #1 single and #1 album that debuted with over 400k (something yall are desperately salivating to have) with the year Gaga had…

Didn't Cowboy Carter last roughly the same as ARTPOP on the charts?

Why are you acting like it was this smash era just because it got a #1 hit song that is already more forgotten than most of Gaga's hit singles? 

If Disease bombed into oblivion why is it on track to outstream EVERY track on Cowboy Carter (excluding THE) someday this week (including singles 16 Carriages and A-list collab with Miley Cyrus)? Was that an embarassing bomb too? 

Edited December 30, 2024 by SweetOreosOfHeaven

[PoisonPill]

She already did, the #5 peaking Stupid Love.

[Joaco95]

1 hour ago, By the Water said:

11 pages for a "yes" or "no" question

 

 

I guess deep down we're all on the same page

 

and instead of replying yes or no, you added NOTHING to the conversation

[Mariano]

34 minutes ago, SweetOreosOfHeaven said:

Didn't Cowboy Carter last roughly the same as ARTPOP on the charts?

Why are you acting like it was this smash era just because it got a #1 hit song that is already more forgotten than most of Gaga's hit singles? 

If Disease bombed into oblivion why is it on track to outstream EVERY track on Cowboy Carter (excluding THE) someday this week (including singles 16 Carriages and A-list collab with Miley Cyrus)? Was that an embarassing bomb too? 

Don't even bother, that person is prolly not even a Bey stan, because the rhetoric he is using implying that Bey is as big as her last #1 is literally one that OBH would use the next time a single of hers underperforms. Bey is an untouchable legend and it has nothing to do with her getting a #1 "SOLO!111!!" hit   BMS is literally in the same bracket as Stupid Love.  Texas is def bigger, but point is, Bey being the biggest legend of the century has very little to do with her getting a solo hit in the year of 2024   Without it her career and status wouldn't flinch. Just like how it doesn't flinch even when she is below Katy Perry on global spotify with both her SOLO and Collabs together. By the same nasty logic they apply to GAGA, Bey would be considered over, but we all know and agree she is quite literally the biggest female legend of the century.

 

They play this stupid game with Gaga where they act like she is as big as her last single, but if u apply this to their favs they will cry. Bey's last single - a collab with Miley bombed. But somehow collab guarantees a smash for Gaga  It's never logic with OGH, it's just constant shifting of the goal post. Remember when they used to drag her for not collabing with other artists and for the fact that only gays liked her and blah blah, now it's the opposite

 

 

 

 

[Pop Art]

1 hour ago, Weld_E said:

I have never seen a stanbase as delusional and unhinged as liddos. The audacity to come for ANY artist when your fave just had 3 nuclear BOMBS in a row needs to be studied. Y'all might've reported the disease thread to death, but that doesn't erase the fact that despite major play listing many artists dream of, her lead single embarrassingly bombed into oblivion. The fact that y'all are still mentioning ASIB's stats to inflate her success and relevance FIVE YEARS later is telling on its own lmfaoooo. 
 

The lack of self awareness to still have the nerve to come for Beyonce when she had a #1 single and #1 album that debuted with over 400k (something yall are desperately salivating to have) with the year Gaga had…

And I've never seen a stanbase as stubborn in their self righteousness as the Hive. I'm sorry you're having a hard time with this to the point you're lashing out, but the plain reality is your fave is about on the same level as Lady Gaga, whether you like it or not. Is she ahead of her? In some ways, yes; in others, no. The fact that you think we are "delusional and unhinged" for even daring to compare them is embarrassing, especially when, again, they're not that far apart all things considered.

 

Does Beyoncé having "a #1 single and #1 album that debuted with over 400k" this year really put her that far ahead that even comparing them is "delusional" when that single lasted less weeks on the entire Hot 100 than Gaga's current Top 10 entry will last in the Top 10 alone and that album lasted less weeks on the Billboard 200 than Gaga's take on the genre that you all dragged to filth for how it charted in 2016? How is it that you feel you can drag Gaga in one breath for being frontloaded (you didn't here but I'm confident you have knowing your stance on Gaga), then in the next breath claim that Beyonce's arguably frontloaded units this year indicate she's lightyears bigger, and then in the next breath claim it is us who are "delusional and unhinged"?

[Disconnect]

No. / end thread

[edutada]

19 hours ago, Colmillo said:

Mind you Always Remember Us This Way is outstreaming ALL of Beyonce's #1s on a daily basis 

At least people knows that is Beyonce singing those songs

People don't even know that Arizona Sky is a song by Lady Gaga 

 

Bradley my dear, can we do "A Star Is Reborn"?

[Weld_E]

1 hour ago, Pop Art said:

Does Beyoncé having "a #1 single and #1 album that debuted with over 400k" this year really put her that far ahead

Since the Renaissance era, yes. I might have given Liddos the benefit of the doubt for not fully grasping just how massively Gaga flopped this year with her three historic bombs—Harlequin, Joker 2, and Disease—but they've dragged other artists for far less, so no excuses. A month ago, y'all were barely managing to brag about her doing better than Katy Perry, and now you're pretending Disease never happened while dragging out stats from five years ago to compare her to artists who are leagues ahead of her in 2024. Be serious—I don't see anyone talking about Gaga outside of this forum.

Edited December 30, 2024 by Weld_E

[Femininomenon]

No. I think it's very clear that Gaga as a solo artist is a thing of the past 

[BrokenMachine]

12 hours ago, Infernal Paradise said:

Does the Hive really want to play the streaming hits game when:

 

No. of songs above 2B streams:

Lady Gaga - 1

Beyonce - 0

 

No. of songs above 1B streams:

Lady Gaga - 7

Beyonce - 2

 

No. of songs above 500M streams:

Lady Gaga - 15

Beyonce - 14

 

No. of songs pulling 300k streams daily:

Lady Gaga - 13

Beyonce - 5 (including Telephone )

 

No. of songs pulling 500k streams daily:

Lady Gaga - 8

Beyonce - 4

 

No. of songs pulling 1M streams daily:

Lady Gaga - 2

Beyonce - 0

 

Only one of them has released TWO whole studio albums since 2020, a massive world tour with theatrical release and recently did a whole Superbowl performance. Guess who

 

Also kii at the OP being a Kat hiding behind an Ariana avi. The NERVE to troll when this is what her 10 year chart history on Billboard looks like  she's FINISHED. OVER. NO HITS, SOLO OR COLLAB.

 

- Birthday: 17
- This Is How We Do: 24
- Rise: 11-43
- Chained to the Rhythm (feat. Skip Marley): 4-8-12
- Bon Appétit (feat. Migos): 59
- Swish Swish (feat. Nicki Minaj): 46
- Save as Draft: OUT
- Hey Hey Hey: OUT
- Cozy Little Christmas: 53
- 365 (with Zedd): 86-OUT
- Con Calma (Remix) [with Daddy Yankee & Snow]: 22
- Never Really Over: 15-28
- Small Talk: 81-OUT
- Harleys in Hawaii: OUT
- Never Worn White: OUT
- Daisies: 40-79
- Smile: OUT-OUT
- Not the End of the World: OUT-OUT
- Electric (from "Pokémon 25: The Album"): OUT-OUT-OUT
- When I'm Gone (with Alesso): OUT-OUT-OUT-OUT-97-OUT-90-91-100-OUT-OUT-OUT-OUT

- Where We Started (with Thomas Rett): OUT-OUT-OUT-OUT-OUT-OUT-OUT-OUT

- Woman's World: 63-OUT

- Lifetimes: OUT-OUT

 

 

Y'all are just PISSED that DWAS is way bigger than most of y'all fave's hits, past or present. How or why is "Fadga", whose career was supposed to be over with ARTPOP, still getting #1s and streaming smashes?? 

 

Well, stay mad! It's not like that's going to stop her from collecting actual GLOBAL smash hits. Meanwhile, her SOLO smash ARUTW (that doesn't fit y'alls bogus narratives) continues pulling almost 1M streams daily and pacing towards 2B (also more than y'alls faves recent SoLo #1 "hits") 

 

Since we're using AI pics, #ThankYouGaga for being a generous collaborator and giving each one of your smash collab partners something they can brag about 

 

 

Maybe if the time spent into this was spent into streaming Disease, she would have gotten a solo hit sooner 

[BrokenMachine]

4 hours ago, Pop Art said:

for each of their solo singles released this decade:

 

Lady Gaga

Bloody Mary: 904M

Yeah, whatever 

[Kimi]

6 minutes ago, BrokenMachine said:

Maybe if the time spent into this was spent into streaming Disease, she would have gotten a solo hit sooner 

maybe who who needs a solo hit when you have a hit bigger than Flowers right at this moment? 

[Abracadabra]

That one Madonna stan having a legit meltdown in here. Poor thing

 

[Infernal Paradise]

30 minutes ago, BrokenMachine said:

Maybe if the time spent into this was spent into streaming Disease, she would have gotten a solo hit sooner 

Took me 5 minutes to clock some of the BS going on all while I was streaming Disease and some of her other songs but I clearly and solely don't have the power to make a song a hit. Your concern is duly noted, though   

 

OT: She already has solo hits but since the definition per this thread is very narrow aka a #1, yes she will. And when that happens, It's going to be a fun and interesting day for sure

[Abracadabra]

3 hours ago, SweetOreosOfHeaven said:

If Disease bombed into oblivion why is it on track to outstream EVERY track on Cowboy Carter (excluding THE) someday this week (including singles 16 Carriages and A-list collab with Miley Cyrus)? Was that an embarassing bomb too? 

[charot]

47 minutes ago, BrokenMachine said:

Yeah, whatever 

It blew up this decade and was released as a single this decade 

 

Edited December 30, 2024 by charot

[SweetOreosOfHeaven]

8 minutes ago, Abracadabra said:

Nobody seems to have an answer to that question

Inb4 "It's country!!11!!"

[bliaz]

I don't think so, but

 

[Mariano]

6 minutes ago, A Million Lights said:

I wonder which excuse will be when LG7 struggles to debut with half of Cowboy Carter's numbers 

What do you have to do with Beyonce?   You stan early 2000s relic, who will always be below both Gaga and Bey, worry about that! 

OT: Yes. 

[Bookmark99]

This thread is hands down the funniest and most entertaining thread we've had on this boring ass site for a while

[BrokenMachine]

1 hour ago, charot said:

It blew up this decade and was released as a single this decade 

 

I know, but still deserves an asterisk, given how it had almost a full decade to gather some of those streams