Florence Belch Posted March 31 Author Posted March 31 5 minutes ago, HonourableVomit said: As promised Took me ages to figure out wtf my old ATRL soundcloud account was so I didn't dox myself. Hate that the only vocals we have for this song are super grainy and probably Florence yelling into her macbook but it's such a beautiful song anyway. My downvote could mean anything from "I hate this result" to "**** this song" A riddle for the ages. Ohhhhh, you elevated it so much more! I feel like I'm in heaven now, thank you so much king I wholeheartedly approve (and am absolutely honoured for) the chosen pic too 1
killer_rose Posted March 31 Posted March 31 36 minutes ago, HonourableVomit said: As promised Took me ages to figure out wtf my old ATRL soundcloud account was so I didn't dox myself. Hate that the only vocals we have for this song are super grainy and probably Florence yelling into her macbook but it's such a beautiful song anyway. My downvote could mean anything from "I hate this result" to "**** this song" A riddle for the ages. I have a pretty clean isolated vocal if you want to try with it: https://voca.ro/1gVYXwdvy77Y 2
Achilles. Posted March 31 Posted March 31 2 hours ago, Florence Belch said: Ooooh, now I'm ready to fall into OUT-oblivion like the Queen of Peace I am, see y'all on the other side, my fellow Tuscan Machines Don't worry, you'll get your Spectrum Remix someday! 2
Florence Belch Posted March 31 Author Posted March 31 7 minutes ago, Achilles. said: Don't worry, you'll get your Spectrum Remix someday! Oh, so now you want my timeless quality to be set aside, only to follow trends for some quick hit Lemme call my agent, aka @CBC, we need to discuss where to place this type of payola 1
CBC Posted March 31 Posted March 31 Hey @Florence Belch, hey @Florence Belch, we can tank Spectrum Remix easy if we lift each other 2
ahauntingnearu Posted March 31 Posted March 31 her latest insta post! "Hire Witch Choir" sounds like it could be/mean something ... and a snippet of screaming (ddd) at the end? 👀👀👀👀👀 @ insiders!!!! 1
Florence Belch Posted March 31 Author Posted March 31 Hey @CBC, hey @CBC, we don't need Jack AntonOFF to ruin one more Florence's track 2
Florence Belch Posted March 31 Author Posted March 31 9 minutes ago, ahauntingnearu said: her latest insta post! "Hire Witch Choir" sounds like it could be/mean something ... and a snippet of screaming (ddd) at the end? 👀👀👀👀👀 @ insiders!!!! Ugh, she saw how Which Bleach was treated in the megarate and decided to avenge it by recording a whole witching album 2
MidnightsAtPeace Posted March 31 Posted March 31 58 minutes ago, Florence Belch said: Ugh, she saw how Which Bleach was treated in the megarate and decided to avenge it by recording a whole witching album I knew my obsession with Which Witch would make her consider making an album with that theme 1
Ewan Chaos Posted March 31 Posted March 31 Getting caught up... not too bad with most of 25-16 being where it is (Shake It Out not being in top 10 is genuinely shocking though). All of the DF songs, including Free which I gave a 10 cuz it's my fave DF song, is like at least 10 placements too high. My Love being the highest is........ a choice. I thought everyone hated it LOL I did not need Various Storms and Saints being so high........ I hoped Long & Lost leaving kinda early would have been an indicator but oh well. Only If For a Night just missing the top 10.... WHAT THE HELLLLLLLLLLL Hunger... cute song but what the hell is she doing in the top 10 NEVER thought No Light No Light was so beloved it'd be in the top 10, but you know what, I'm here for it. One of my favorites from day 1 that grew off me a little, but for the bridge alone I'll take it. WKOM missing the top 5 what the CHILE!!!! Honestly pretty good top 5, though I'd probably push HBHBHB to #1, Cosmic Love to #2, and replace Water with like... 5 other Ceremonials songs KII @Florence Belch this rate was crazy amounts of fun. Great participants but we couldn't have the fun we had without you being such a fun host. Lots of love! 1
Supervillain Posted March 31 Posted March 31 Turns out I missed the entire thing Oh well, at least I can say I'm very satisfied with the Top 10. Florence's discography is so complex & excellent that I'm unable to rank the songs myself so anything is gonna work for me at this point. With that being said, Cosmic Love being #1 feels so right. It's a classic. I'm also surprised at St. Jude being this high, I thought it was disliked for some reason due to being mellow but it's such a gorgeous song. Y'all came through. @Florence Belch thank you for organising and putting so much effort into this rate. 1
Florence Belch Posted March 31 Author Posted March 31 3 hours ago, Ewan Chaos said: Getting caught up... not too bad with most of 25-16 being where it is (Shake It Out not being in top 10 is genuinely shocking though). All of the DF songs, including Free which I gave a 10 cuz it's my fave DF song, is like at least 10 placements too high. My Love being the highest is........ a choice. I thought everyone hated it LOL I did not need Various Storms and Saints being so high........ I hoped Long & Lost leaving kinda early would have been an indicator but oh well. Only If For a Night just missing the top 10.... WHAT THE HELLLLLLLLLLL Hunger... cute song but what the hell is she doing in the top 10 NEVER thought No Light No Light was so beloved it'd be in the top 10, but you know what, I'm here for it. One of my favorites from day 1 that grew off me a little, but for the bridge alone I'll take it. WKOM missing the top 5 what the CHILE!!!! Honestly pretty good top 5, though I'd probably push HBHBHB to #1, Cosmic Love to #2, and replace Water with like... 5 other Ceremonials songs KII @Florence Belch this rate was crazy amounts of fun. Great participants but we couldn't have the fun we had without you being such a fun host. Lots of love! 8 minutes ago, Supervillain said: Turns out I missed the entire thing Oh well, at least I can say I'm very satisfied with the Top 10. Florence's discography is so complex & excellent that I'm unable to rank the songs myself so anything is gonna work for me at this point. With that being said, Cosmic Love being #1 feels so right. It's a classic. I'm also surprised at St. Jude being this high, I thought it was disliked for some reason due to being mellow but it's such a gorgeous song. Y'all came through. @Florence Belch thank you for organising and putting so much effort into this rate. It's such a shame that you both had too much going on though, cause I know we all would have loved to see more of your takes (and to cackle at the sabotages nnn) Still, thank you both for joining in! Knowing that both of you had fun really makes me happier and prouder 1 1
amamoy Posted March 31 Posted March 31 9 hours ago, HonourableVomit said: As promised Took me ages to figure out wtf my old ATRL soundcloud account was so I didn't dox myself. Hate that the only vocals we have for this song are super grainy and probably Florence yelling into her macbook but it's such a beautiful song anyway. My downvote could mean anything from "I hate this result" to "**** this song" A riddle for the ages. Ooooooh, the instrumental is p-r-e-t-t-y! Is this real guitar or midi? 1
HonourableVomit Posted March 31 Posted March 31 59 minutes ago, amamoy said: Ooooooh, the instrumental is p-r-e-t-t-y! Is this real guitar or midi? Thank you! Both actually. But the lovely verse guitar is real. 2 1
Achilles. Posted April 1 Posted April 1 On 3/30/2025 at 8:25 AM, Florence Belch said: 17. Shake It Out OVERALL SCORE: 8.545 Patricias (12, 11): Achilles., ahauntingnearu, Giovanni, makeawish, MidnightsAtPeace, Mikeymoonshine, Paddy, Taylor fanboy Lovers To Lovers (10): Album Leak, BlackoutZone, BowWow, CBC, Florence Belch, killer_rose, Mr. Peanutbutter, Ponzi, Supervillain, Why, yyy Tuscan Machines (9): 1989, crymelanie, Ewan Chaos, jacklovesyou1, PaloSanto, sparrowblue, Suka Bicza, Torment, Velvet Night Tuscan Tomato-throwers (2): HonourableVomit Haters to Haters (1): creativity. Joshuas (0, -1): Curaga, khalyan Thoughts: AshleyLovescats887: songs about shaking really are meant to be bangers huh Curaga: Overrated! Ewan Chaos: Iconic track, it did better than most would think (in the States) but I wish it was a smash MidnightsAtPeace: I have a tattoo inspired by this song and that should tell you how I feel about it. ONE OF THE BEST SONGS OF ALL OF TIME. Mikeymoonshine: Shake It Out is still my favourite florence song ever, something about her vocals on that track just obsesses me. Paddy: this is Florence's best song. True masterpiece. Everybody moved on but I stayed here. 2
ahauntingnearu Posted April 1 Posted April 1 I can't believe Tantalus went from being the title track to not even being a bonus track. It's a lovely song, but I agree I HATE the vocal editing on the leaked file. Ik it's a rough demo, but in no world does Florence need that much vocal effect I always imagine if the (known) original titles had been what she went with... Under Heaven Over Hell: kinda perfect for the Lungs collection (especially as UHOH) Violence: terrible Tantalus: so much better and more fitting imo The End Of Love: ICONIC Choreomania: SOOOO much more fitting 1
amamoy Posted Tuesday at 04:15 AM Posted Tuesday at 04:15 AM 5 hours ago, HonourableVomit said: Thank you! Both actually. But the lovely verse guitar is real. ATRLers aren't afraid of guitars, that's a new one 2
Florence Belch Posted Tuesday at 06:48 AM Author Posted Tuesday at 06:48 AM 2 hours ago, amamoy said: ATRLers aren't afraid of guitars, that's a new one Watch Florence go hard with them in the next album, that would be the ultimate kii 1
BrokenMachine Posted Wednesday at 04:12 PM Posted Wednesday at 04:12 PM On 11/28/2024 at 2:04 AM, Florence Belch said: 20. Drumming Song: 8.419 19. Delilah: 8.500 18. Cassandra: 8.543 17. Shake It Out: 8.545 16. Free: 8.547 15. Spectrum: 8.679 14. Howl: 8.710 13. Various Storms & Saints: 8.710 12. My Love: 8.800 11. Only If For A Night: 8.814 10. Hunger: 8.824 9. Rabbit Heart (Raise It Up): 8.933 8. Dog Days Are Over: 9.059 7. No Light, No Light: 9.197 6. What Kind Of Man: 9.282 5. Queen Of Peace: 9.410 4. Never Let Me Go: 9.485 3. How Big, How Blue, How Beautiful: 9.500 2. What The Water Gave Me: 9.588 1. Cosmic Love: 9.737 I went into blackout mode once I saw those results. Such a nightmare. My Love deserves its place, Free is way too high, should have left at #100. Queen Of Peace deserved top 3, Drumming Song and Delilah deserved top 15. Various Storms deserved top 10. Thank you everyone 3
HonourableVomit Posted Wednesday at 11:59 PM Posted Wednesday at 11:59 PM 78. I'm Not Calling You A Liar: 6.455 75: Hurricane Drunk: 6.727 72: My Boy Builds Coffins: 6.848 71: Remain Nameless: 6.909 70: 100 Years: 6.914 67: Falling: 6.968 65: Patricia: 7.000 64: Swimming: 7.063 1
crymelanie Posted Saturday at 07:33 PM Posted Saturday at 07:33 PM Nnnnn not Cosmic Orgasm winning the rate and winking us a resting ***** face lmaoooooo i wasnt here for nearly a week (ramadan holiday babies may God bless us) but i am reading your posts youre such a beautiful soul sis thank you thank you thank you for hosting and giving us a cup of quirky kii's i love you @Florence Belch Also Atrl served taste for the first time (shookT ) the blank stare bottom Jack FadtoneOff's Tango Feverthank you everyone Lungs have the last laugh hahaha 1
Recommended Posts