smartalek22 Posted October 31 Posted October 31 I really don't get Taylor's massive appeal when she's so unoffensive to culture... Madonna was (and still is) an interesting artist and individual - Taylor isn't even capable of a 'Like A Prayer' or a 'Vogue' moment. And 'Ray Of Light' outdoes any singer-songwriter indie stuff she's been trying to pull off for the past few years. I mean I'm not saying Taylor is incapable of serving like she did with 'Delicate' and that video was great - and a few moments (of her insanely large discography), but Madonna just has something that Tay does not and idek what it is but she's definitely the greatest 4
Sweetness Posted November 1 Posted November 1 On 10/30/2024 at 4:44 PM, cat1867 said: I am using Billboard's greatest of all time ranking. https://www.billboard.com/charts/greatest-of-all-time-artists/ records combine both single and album sales so aren't a great methodlogy to use. But regardless, Madonna is the greatest pop star not because she sold the most. But because she pioneered being a female pop star that was so influential on future pop stars. Billboard also says Madonna is the most successful solo act on Billboard top 100 and only behind the Beatles?
Chris Posted November 3 Posted November 3 This thread has been done a billion times. Why do you gays always fall for it? 1
Chris Posted November 3 Posted November 3 On 10/30/2024 at 3:33 PM, Charmed Life said: When did Mariah and Elton sell 400m records? Never.
GraceRandolph Posted November 4 Posted November 4 Madonna is actually a pop star. Taylor feels like a country singer who is just existing in pop as a business move. 1
dumbsparce Posted November 4 Posted November 4 Madonna will always be the greatest. Taylor is great at what she does too but Madonna literally invented the pop girl game and shattered every boundary imaginable on top of the massive sales. 1
Charmed Life Posted November 4 Posted November 4 (edited) I don't mind Taylor, but Madonna is in on a whole other level for me. Edited November 4 by Charmed Life
Bubble Tea Posted November 4 Posted November 4 Imagine voting Taylor Madonna is the greatest female pop star of all time. Even if Taylor outsells her and lands more hits, the cultural impact and literal impact upon LGBT+ rights and acceptance, and feminism, will never be touched by success-addicted Taylor. There's nothing valiant about doing whatever it takes to maintain fame and popularity, that is not "great." 22 hours ago, Chris said: This thread has been done a billion times. Why do you gays always fall for it? It struck a chord with me this morning Sick of seeing Madonna compared to people who are simply not on her level. 4 1
cuteboyzay Posted November 5 Posted November 5 (edited) Biggest: Madonna Greatest: Madonna Stop lumping her in with Madonna, it's embarrassing atp. Taylor is great in her own way but should neverrrr be in the same sentence as the same Woman who has culturally lead us to the progressiveness we see in society today. Edited November 5 by cuteboyzay 1 2
Doctor Dick Posted November 5 Posted November 5 On 10/30/2024 at 4:48 PM, Badgalbriel said: Madonna for now, but Taylor is surpassing her very soon. If her next tour is half as big as the Eras Tour, that's still enough to make her the biggest solo artist of all time. Biggest FEMALE solo artist of all time. I cannot stress this enough. She's not going to overtake Michael Jackson or Elvis Presley, especially Michael whose hotly anticipated biopic could lift his catalogue sales to more unprecedented levels.
Badgalbriel Posted November 5 Posted November 5 6 minutes ago, Doctor Dick said: Biggest FEMALE solo artist of all time. I cannot stress this enough. She's not going to overtake Michael Jackson or Elvis Presley, especially Michael whose hotly anticipated biopic could lift his catalogue sales to more unprecedented levels. Yep! Thanks. 1
Recommended Posts