charts discussion Midweek predictions (11/9/2024): ABS vs. DWaS for #1, Lose Control #7, Disease #18

[Bloodflowers.]

Caught up in your show, at least now I know 

 

 

[shimind]

16 minutes ago, Digitalism said:

Meanwhile Bruno is smashing and smashing 

Yeah I'm sure Rose will soon have 100m+ listeners on Spotify 

[KatyPrismSpirit]

Joker FAD: biggest box-office bomb and panned movie of the year

Harlequin: debuting #20 and leaving the chart after one week

LG7 lead single: likely missing top 30 at this point, freefalling

 

Is this only the beginning of Kukai's shaky start prophecy?

[Underdogs]

Is she expected to have 2 simultaneous hits? That's very rare. Her Bruno collab is still in heavy rotation everywhere 

[Paddy]

The song has no replay value. I'm sorry but it's not as catchy as her other hits. Shame she didn't have some tv booked to perform and promote.

[Bloodflowers.]

4 minutes ago, Richie.Valdez said:

Her gays lost… there is no way on earth that she will release more gay pop music because y'all let it flop.  
 

 

I said that during Chromatica era but Bloody Mary going viral on Tiktok made gays lucky Gaga tried to make a pop album one more time. After this, it's back to Joanne, A Star is Born and Die With a Smile. Older tasteful straight people 2:0 over gays, I fear

 

 

[KatyPrismSpirit]

Just now, Underdogs said:

Is she expected to have 2 simultaneous hits

the thread title literally says DISEASE is missing the top 15 

[Cheers]

Can we aim for top 35 instead? Lets go, guys

[aesthetic bih]

See that, Gaga? Are you still going to pretend Disease doesn't exist? 

[DougAF]

The way I got mass downvoted for saying it weeks ago, but I'll say it again: 

 

THANK YOU, BRUNO 

[Mocha]

her Never Really Over 

 

[Truth Teller]

31 minutes ago, Doogle said:

Having your lead single fail to hit the top 15 while another song you're on is heading to the top 2 is kinda hilarious 

 

No wonder she never bothers making pop music and ignores her fans, the public don't want this music anymore  

They don't want the clunky, non-catchy iteration of it that she's been serving since 2013. I'm pretty sure if she took 12 TF/TFM rejects from the RedOne / Garibay / Fusari sessions, she would be successful. That "Nothing On But The Radio" demo that Addison Rae picked up from her 2010 vault sounds more like a hit than any Gaga single since BTW. But she's an artiste so she'll keep releasing unpleasant pop music and underperforming

[Starshine]

Well

 

[Underdogs]

Just now, KatyPrismSpirit said:

the thread title literally says DISEASE is missing the top 15 

Yeah, because she already has a hit with the other song. How can this be reasonably expected to smash when another Gaga song is so big?

 

 

[unino]

3 minutes ago, shimind said:

Yeah I'm sure Rose will soon have 100m+ listeners on Spotify 

comparing an artist who has 3-4 songs on their spotify page to another one with 11 albums whew!

[Brikenbur]

Didn't "BREAK MY SOUL" debut at #15 with only three days tracking? 

[KatyPrismSpirit]

Just now, Underdogs said:

Yeah, because she already has a hit with the other song. How can this be reasonably expected to smash when another Gaga song is so big?

 

 

Sabrina literally debuted at #1 with another song in the top 3. 

 

And that Bruno song has nothing to do with the LG7 era

[truthteller]

Perfect Illusion WON

[Raphy23]

A stable start. 

[KatyPrismSpirit]

3 minutes ago, Mocha said:

her Never Really Over 

 

[Uncatena]

I don't think she cares considering she is literally radio silent lmao. it remains a bop and she will probably sell out another stadium tour; the world will keep spinning. 

[unino]

4 minutes ago, Underdogs said:

Yeah, because she already has a hit with the other song. How can this be reasonably expected to smash when another Gaga song is so big?

 

 

i see what you are doing

[unino]

Just now, BorderBoy said:

How do you know that for sure when the song's only been out for like two days?

 

so you are saying it's going to debut in top 10?

[Sawk]

Art not charts era, the album is coming for huge critical acclaim, she's giving risqué artisté not McDonald's of music 

[BorderBoy]

How do you know that for sure when the song's only been out for like two days?