charts discussion Lady Gaga - Disease | Day 16: #111 Global (-29), 1.5M (-240K)

[BrokenMachine]

Not a f*ing Xmas freeze in OCTOBER 

[Mrnoniee]

2 minutes ago, BrokenMachine said:

Not a f*ing Xmas freeze in OCTOBER 

Halloween Freeze?

[Burn]

2 minutes ago, Mrnoniee said:

Halloween Freeze?

When the album drops in February I'm sure they'll be telling us there's a Valentines Freeze.

[Assassin]

12 minutes ago, BrokenMachine said:

So 'she's not OUT yet' is the only thing you can cling to ?

Girl weren't you defending the Spotify numbers yesterday?  I thought you were a Liddo.

 

[OrgVisual]

1 minute ago, Burn said:

When the album drops in February I'm sure they'll be telling us there's a Valentines Freeze.

I mean this is the same fanbase who said Chromatica flopped because of BLM, what do u expect?

[Burn]

Just now, OrgVisual said:

I mean this is the same fanbase who said Chromatica flopped because of BLM, what do u expect?

They did what?!

 

 

Oh that's low. I shouldn't be surprised though.

[WildHeart]

Going from comparing your fave to Taylor to Charli XCX in a matter of days... last 3 weeks were really humbling to liddos

Edited October 27 by WildHeart

[Weld_E]

1 hour ago, wastedpotential said:

I- 

 

Is Charli XCX the horse you really want to attach your wagon to? 

 

We had that whole discussion yesterday about Taylor and GaGa not being peers, are you willing to stake the claim that GaGa's peer isn't Katy Perry, but rather a girl who's never managed to collect a Platinum album? Is that where we are? 

"At least she did better than Gracie Abrams!!!11!"

Oh wait…

[L.B GAGA]

Terrible dated messy song, deserved drop. She has better vocals, 911 the song,DWAS,Shallow,Alice on  chromatica proved it but i guess she opts for the worst to debut😢. Then she will give a tragic music video, then release the best one for the 3rd single when the hype is murdered from the first solo.Then  Second single will be a collab with  charli xcx or troye sivan and will smash due to a better producer, modern well sounding instrumentals and harmony in vocals. 

 

Its simple, good music from Gaga when new, it will smash. Her solo debut new efforts are flopping because of releasing an unproduced demo with noise and screams, then releasing a good solo from an album when its too late and the GP is irritated from the first solo.  

Edited October 27 by L.B GAGA

[Pepo]

Liddos claimed their fave was bigger than Beyoncé and on par with Taylor, now they're comparing her to the likes of Charli XCX 

 

How the mighty have fallen 

 

Edited October 27 by Pepo

[Jon Snow]

25 minutes ago, Doctor Dick said:

This song performed on par with Beyoncé yesterday and is performing similar to Charli now.

and tomorrow it will perform similar to Katy Perry 

 

[The Music Industry]

1 minute ago, Pepo said:

Liddos claimed their fave was bigger than Beyoncé and on par with Taylor, now they're comparing her to the likes of Charli XCX 

 

How the mighty has fallen 

 

It's genuinely funny, their complete lack of self-awareness

 

And then they wonder why they constantly get lashed too

 

[Doctor Dick]

The circlejerking in here because y'all were WRONG that she wouldn't chart and WRONG again that she would serve OUT. Continue jerking each other off while we continue on being happy our fave gave us something we love and made us hyped for the album. At least all we said turned out to be right: Gaga debuting way better than Katy, doing way better than Katy, Harlequin being no indication of how we can do first day, she'd do between 4M-5M. Literally everything turned out to be right.

 

Meanwhile, here we have you guys saying she won't chart on Spotify at all, do less than 2M, being OUT on day one because of Harlequin and OUT on day two and all of that was WRONG WRONG WRONG WRONG WRONG.

Edited October 27 by Doctor Dick

[L.B GAGA]

7 hours ago, Binxstan said:

As soon as I saw all of the yt twinks on this site saying this was the song of the century I knew it was going to flop into oblivion. 

Same thing ive seen on social media wiith the yt twinks, all slayed,with overhyping reaction videos to a terrible song. I was like

[WildHeart]

Who did claim that it would be out in its second day? Not liddos making things up to make it seem like its chart run is somewhat impressive... 

 

Edited October 27 by WildHeart

[katara]

25 minutes ago, Pepo said:

Liddos claimed their fave was bigger than Beyoncé and on par with Taylor, now they're comparing her to the likes of Charli XCX 

 

How the mighty have fallen 

 

It's so insulting tbh since Charli hasn't even achieved half of what Bebe Rexha has achieved for example 

 

[Jon Snow]

4 minutes ago, Doctor Dick said:

y'all were WRONG that she wouldn't chart and WRONG again that she would serve OUT

4 minutes ago, Doctor Dick said:

At least all we said turned out to be right: Gaga debuting way better than Katy, doing way better than Katy

the bar was that low? 

 

[Burn]

The way these threads always end up with @Doctor Dick being the last monster standing. Sis, most of your fellow LMs at least have the good sense to keep their heads down and retreat back to their base. 

[spree]

If this does the same streams as WW for Week 1 (or worse) it will be the greatest kii of the decade.

[Triton]

bUt beTTeR tHAn kATy! 
 

 

[Capris Groove]

She is now "old" and so is her fanbase. She spent her 'vital decade' singing showtunes and chasing success by sticking to a formula... She never evolved as herself in her own music... she did all that in the last 15 years and she has nothing to show for it. 5 years in she was already coughing up a rehashed version of herself or someone else. Now compare that to Janet going from Control to Rhythm Nation to janet. to The Velvet Rope, or M from self-titled to True Blue to Like a Prayer through Erotica to Ray of Light.

[wastedpotential]

32 minutes ago, Doctor Dick said:

The circlejerking in here because y'all were WRONG that she wouldn't chart and WRONG again that she would serve OUT. Continue jerking each other off while we continue on being happy our fave gave us something we love and made us hyped for the album. At least all we said turned out to be right: Gaga debuting way better than Katy, doing way better than Katy, Harlequin being no indication of how we can do first day, she'd do between 4M-5M. Literally everything turned out to be right.

 

Meanwhile, here we have you guys saying she won't chart on Spotify at all, do less than 2M, being OUT on day one because of Harlequin and OUT on day two and all of that was WRONG WRONG WRONG WRONG WRONG.

Please give it up deelishis. For everyone's sake, but especially for yours. 

 

Everyone fully expected GaGa to chart (I mean... we were all expecting like a million or two more than this ended up debuting with), and everyone fully expected this to hold better than Stupid Love. No one was expecting this to serve OUT on day 1 or day 2. However, now that we've seen the struggling debut and the gargantuan collapse, we are expecting this to serve OUT sooner than initially expected. 

 

It doesn't seem as if you're particularly happy that your fave gave you something you love and makes you hype for the album (I mean... we can all read Liddo base), but I say that because you're camped in here, screaming nonsensical things at us ("GaGa and Charli are peers" reads like a cry for help, tbh) like this:

 

 

We can agree that Harlequin had zero impact on Disease's performance, because otherwise it would've not made the chart in the first place. As everyone has reaffirmed to you (despite your continued hesitance on the topic), GaGa HAS outdebuted Katy and Woman's World, and that's worth celebrating if that's your definition of success (though... really? All you want is for GaGa's lead single with all of the flop movie/flop jazz album pressure riding on it is to outdebut the flop of the year?), congratulations to you, Doctor Dick, congratulations to Liddo base, and congratulations to GaGa! 

 

I'm glad you think that "literally everything turned out to be right", as I've been very concerned about the wellbeing of the Liddos this week, but that's such a positive sign! I hope you enjoy this song and LG7 when it comes in February! 

 

 

Spoiler

 

Edited October 27 by wastedpotential

[ImpressMeMuch]

11 hours ago, Beamon said:

 oh Godga her solo power

her what now?!

 

 

[BrokenMachine]

1 hour ago, Assassin said:

Girl weren't you defending the Spotify numbers yesterday?  I thought you were a Liddo.

 

I like the song and I have some hope for it to outchart Stupid Flop in the long run, but I'm not a liddo and I won't feed into their delusions 

 

I've been criticizing OGHs and liddos for equal this whole thread 

[Capris Groove]

Sorry but really, Artpop isn't the problem of her career. It's that, at her zenith, she decided to focus on jazz showtunes with Tony Bennett... she should've been acting like an imperial popstar.