Jump to content

Chappell Roan - "The Giver"


Recommended Posts

Posted

Well deserved for being lowkey shady towards Bey in her interviews :-*

 

  • Confused 1
  • Thumbs Down 6

  • Replies 1.1k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • KatyPrismSpirit

    39

  • stjosephprey4us

    29

  • CottageHore

    28

  • shark_heather

    26

Posted

 

I didn't expect drop so big in the US, it's almost bizarre

 

 

1 minute ago, Kristie Kuwa said:

Well deserved for being lowkey shady towards Bey in her interviews :-*

 

This is some next level of media illiteracy, please get real :rip:

Posted

we lost  :sad:

 

UK #1 cancelled. That Alex Warren guy is back to #1 and The Giver fell to #8 :noparty:

Posted

Good now let's all go back streaming the actual classic Pink Pony Club :wave2:

  • Like 1
Posted (edited)
15 minutes ago, BlackoutZone said:

 

I didn't expect drop so big in the US, it's almost bizarre

 

 

 

This is some next level of media illiteracy, please get real :rip:

 

Oh are you sure? Cause I can guarantee Ms Thing was being shady towards Bey her. "Its not me trying to cross genres and be like "look at me" and try to convince a country crowd that they should listen to my music by baiting them with a Country music."

 

That is pretty much in direct response to Beyonce doing Cowboy Carter and what she said her intention was 

Edited by Kristie Kuwa
  • Confused 3
  • Thumbs Down 4
Posted

I think this Dua analogy is spot on: This is her We're Good: a tired awful song with a tired awful sound no one asked her to do.

 

Dua had Levitating going on at the same time which masked the bombing of We're Good and similarly Chappel has Pink Pony Club going which will mask Giver's bombing.

 

She needs to move on FAST though. I hope she doesn't have more songs coming with this sound. The people who like her will not care about country and the country sphere will not accept her. It's a lose lose situation. 

Posted
14 minutes ago, Kristie Kuwa said:

 

Oh are you sure? Cause I can guarantee Ms Thing was being shady towards Bey her. "Its not me trying to cross genres and be like "look at me" and try to convince a country crowd that they should listen to my music by baiting them with a Country music."

 

That is pretty much in direct response to Beyonce doing Cowboy Carter and what she said her intention was 

was Bey even trying to convince the country crowd to listen to her music? i don't think she made CC trying to win the average country fan over but more of an artistic statement and honoring Black country music

 

if this is even shade it's more directed to artists like Post Malone whose last album was a very calculated effort to bait modern country fans (i don't think it's shade in the first place)

 

i'm sorry but you're reaching 

  • Like 3
Posted

The song is cute, but it is no GLB :cm: 

Posted (edited)
27 minutes ago, Kristie Kuwa said:

 

Oh are you sure? Cause I can guarantee Ms Thing was being shady towards Bey her. "Its not me trying to cross genres and be like "look at me" and try to convince a country crowd that they should listen to my music by baiting them with a Country music."

 

That is pretty much in direct response to Beyonce doing Cowboy Carter and what she said her intention was 

No, this is you trying to fit her words into your narrative and especially as a Bey fan, you should know better. Not only does she have genuine appreciation for country music that she has explored before, but also she's done it with great care honoring real country roots that she has been growing up with as well. Her doing a country record is a not a shocker, more of an expected natural progression. If you looked at the actual scope of the current music industry, not just through the lenses of being a Bey fan, you'd see that what Chappell said is way more fitting for other popular artists, most notably, Post Malone who had the 4th biggest song of last year with a Morgan Wallen collab and that was just one of many collabs with the current "IT" country musicians on his recent disposable project. EDM producers (Marshmello, Diplo) or even rappers all would tackle random country crossovers purely on hopes of getting new appeal and a hit. Heck, even Sabrina and her pop country moment with Please Please Please (which immediately smashed) is more fitting for Chappell's narrative than Cowboy Carter. You are shading Bey more yourself if you consider Chappell's words a shade towards Beyonce.

Edited by BlackoutZone
  • Like 6
  • Thanks 1
Posted (edited)
28 minutes ago, Kristie Kuwa said:

 

Oh are you sure? Cause I can guarantee Ms Thing was being shady towards Bey her. "Its not me trying to cross genres and be like "look at me" and try to convince a country crowd that they should listen to my music by baiting them with a Country music."

 

That is pretty much in direct response to Beyonce doing Cowboy Carter and what she said her intention was 

The paranoid complex of the hive omg. Yes, everybody all the time is talking about Beyonce.

Edited by UnRayuki
  • Like 3
  • Haha 3
  • Thumbs Down 1
Posted

Song is not good :chick1:

Posted
1 minute ago, UnRayuki said:

The paranoid complex of the hive omg

I swear not the whole hive is media illiterate. If you see that video and take it as Bey shade, you're kinda just d*mb sorry.

  • Like 2
Posted
1 hour ago, whatyouwant_ said:

Spotify Global

#28 (-19) The Giver - 3.2M (-3M)

 

Oh wow, basically 50% loss on Spotify :deadbanana2:

What went wrong @Post Malone

 

billie-eilish-is-fucking-OVER.thumb.gif.

  • Haha 2
Posted

Why is she giving an interview at apple music for a single? A flop single at that. My god, this lazy b isn't planning on releasing an album anytime soon, is she? She really wants to repeat Midwest Princess "rollout" all over again, except without music videos this time :rip:

Posted

i like the song, i think it's a bop. but for some reason it's not clicking with me all of her other songs did. i think i need a music video or a new performance of the song. but i also really want the subway so maybe that's my problem. 

Posted
6 minutes ago, Slate said:

What went wrong @Post Malone

 

billie-eilish-is-fucking-OVER.thumb.gif.

STOP THE COUNT

 

spacer.png

  • Haha 6
  • ATRL Moderator
Posted

She better upload the SNL version to Spotify asap 

Posted
4 minutes ago, Post Malone said:

STOP THE COUNT

 

spacer.png

Real numbers coming on Monday

 

billie-eilish-is-fucking-OVER.thumb.gif.

  • Haha 1
Posted
12 minutes ago, beyonceparkwood said:

I swear not the whole hive is media illiterate. If you see that video and take it as Bey shade, you're kinda just d*mb sorry.

You are right, let me correct myself "the paranoid complex of some people in the Hive..."

 

But really, what happened to those people, who hurted them so bad. I mean if Beyoncé would have had a Britney 2007 or Gaga 2013 I would understand the trauma and thinking everybody is shading/against their fave, but Beyonce is pretty well considered like everywhere...

Posted

Well the song is not good so :coffee:.

Just drop the subway now c'mon.

Posted

I'm really shocked at that drop. :biblio: That's insane. It's also a great song, so really doesn't deserve it.

Posted

She shipped it but it got shipped back :toofunny3:

Posted
35 minutes ago, beyonceparkwood said:

I swear not the whole hive is media illiterate. If you see that video and take it as Bey shade, you're kinda just d*mb sorry.

Ok drag me I guess lol I perceive Chappel as quite shady, so I may have read into it. I just found her choice of words interesting and akin to Beys statement within CC. Not more, not less. 

Yall can stop fuming at a lil interpretation like that lol

Posted

I personally knew that @Post Malone calling this the best song of all-time would be the kiss of death

 

billie-eilish-is-fucking-OVER.thumb.gif.

  • Haha 4
Posted
3 minutes ago, Riverbank said:

I personally knew that @Post Malone calling this the best song of all-time would be the kiss of death

 

billie-eilish-is-fucking-OVER.thumb.gif.

I should really start stanning for a certain someone at this point @Kyoto @bad guy

 

spacer.png

  • Haha 6
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.