rate Pre-2000s Divas Rate Series - Sophomore Album | And the WINNER is...

[naval23]

@Saddy is always amazing with these rates - I love spectating them - what a finale! Thank you <3

[Ewan Chaos]

A few questionable outcomes in the rate (I'm still baffled at Angel's placement and people seemingly not liking it as much... or at least the raves & then people disliking it, did it have the most 11s????)... HOWEVER, the top 5 was kinda perfection.

 

I would have preferred IWDWS as the higher one, but I ranked So Emotional above it and never heard it before this rate so I'll take it. And the top 2 were perfection, even if I'd have sliiiiightly preferred a Material Girl win, Emotions is an undeniable classic and incredible song. Thanks for doing a great job hosting, as always!

 

 

[Soda Pop Queen]

Material Girl is a bit too high for my tastes (I prefer Dress You Up) but at least LAV isn't M's highest ranked song. 

 

A solid, albeit predictable, #1. It was either gonna be Emotions or IWDWS.

[GraceRandolph]

Thank you @Saddy

 

Are we going to be able to do the third album rate please @Ace Reject

[sparrowblue]

another great rate being a big mc fan, emotions is overplayed and overdone but it's still a moment.

Edited November 26, 2024 by sparrowblue

[allforyou]

The way none of my 11s made it to the top 15  I flopped in this rate

 

I'm very surprised that Dress You Up made it to the top 10 since it's usually regarded as one of Madonna's most forgotten singles

 

Emotions is a good pick for #1 since it's such a classic

[Truth Teller]

Angel not being top 10 is a travesty, y'all ain't ****

 

[Saddy]

34 minutes ago, Truth Teller said:

Angel not being top 10 is a travesty, y'all ain't ****

 

Well, next time join so u can save your fav songs

[Truth Teller]

2 minutes ago, Saddy said:

Well, next time join so u can save your fav songs

That would require listening to a pre-Control Janet album, a full-length Celine album and at least 6 Whitney filler ballads

 

It's a no

 

[jacklovesyou1]

On 11/24/2024 at 10:10 PM, SoldierofLove said:

 

@jacklovesyou1 you will start coughing in three days.

Catching up and nnn not me having covid around the time you sent this ... soldieroflove voodoo is real??

[SoldierofLove]

3 hours ago, jacklovesyou1 said:

Catching up and nnn not me having covid around the time you sent this ... soldieroflove voodoo is real??

You survived. 
 

[jacklovesyou1]

20 minutes ago, SoldierofLove said:

You survived. 
 

Just in time for pt 3 of the rate 

tell me your fave so i can sabotage 

 

[SoldierofLove]

12 hours ago, jacklovesyou1 said:

Just in time for pt 3 of the rate 

tell me your fave so i can sabotage 

 

My faves are:

 

You Can Be Mine
When I Think of You
He Doesn't Know I'm Alive

White Heat

Where's The Party

 

What are your faves?