JoJo Posted October 19 Posted October 19 ATRL really needs a rule against thread derailment. This post is supposed to be about APT's Spotify performance. No one wants to go through 5 pages of two unrelated fandoms arguing wtf 13 1
lgaga1fan Posted October 19 Posted October 19 (edited) 2 hours ago, Harrier said: I don't want to bash Rose but it probably isn't fair to compare the numbers on this Bruno collab to Jennie/Lisa's solo music or the Rosalia collab. Not only is Bruno a big name he's also coming straight off a different big collaboration hit. The song is great and Rose is my favorite BP member but yeah let's avoid this comparison I mean even in Korea this shot to No 1 which no other Blackpink solo track has done since Solo I believe. DWAS wasn't charting high on Melon either which is a Bruno track so the automatic popularity in Korea is clearly excitement for Rose. I think I forgot to say that specifically and should have bc this is a Spotify thread not Melon. Edited October 19 by lgaga1fan 1
Zaram Posted October 19 Posted October 19 (edited) 57 minutes ago, A Million Lights said: Why some people downvoted this post? Because he is a known ogh and reddit mod Edited October 19 by Zaram
rhaenyra Posted October 19 Posted October 19 Roseanné the woman that you are She is her and her is she
lgaga1fan Posted October 19 Posted October 19 Also yeah even tho the DWAS comps are inevitable why are yall using this thread to bash Gaga and try and bash Rose? We should be happy that a female korean artist has a shot to chart high on the hot 100, that's genuinely historical. Celebrating success of these women that are growing this year like Charli and Rose should be focused on. I don't even like APT but am happy to see Rose succeed because she's my favorite BP member. 3
Mariano Posted October 19 Posted October 19 14 minutes ago, JoJo said: ATRL really needs a rule against thread derailment. This post is supposed to be about APT's Spotify performance. No one wants to go through 5 pages of two unrelated fandoms arguing wtf I mean you're dealing with OGH and their obsession with Gaga OT: The song is a bop
Assassin Posted October 19 Posted October 19 7 minutes ago, Zaram said: Because he is a known ogh and reddit mod what does me being a reddit mod have to do with anything.
Sannie Posted October 19 Posted October 19 1 hour ago, Sonny said: Why is a thread about Rose's impressive stats all about Godga? OT: CONGRATS ROSIE. Like... what is the discourse? Gaga and Rose sitting pretty in the top with a good song with an amazing male artist. Neither side has any reason to be mad. 1 2
Calvin Posted October 19 Posted October 19 3 minutes ago, Assassin said: what does me being a reddit mod have to do with anything. 3
slw84 Posted October 19 Posted October 19 Bruno proving himself again...I just don't understand the October release as this song fits a spring/summer vibe but if it's a hit then good for them.
Acuminatus Posted October 19 Posted October 19 (edited) Rosie is probably my bias in BP, I am so happy she got a HIT! Edited October 19 by Acuminatus
Mariah4life Posted October 20 Posted October 20 Some of y'all are weird. Let both girls succeed. Is it that hard?
Beamon Posted October 20 Posted October 20 oh Collabruno he's so smart to cling to two talented female artists for hits 1
Witnessed ET Posted October 20 Posted October 20 We knew Rosé's power with BP but we never knew her solo power
Witnessed ET Posted October 20 Posted October 20 14 hours ago, Harrier said: I don't want to bash Rose but it probably isn't fair to compare the numbers on this Bruno collab to Jennie/Lisa's solo music or the Rosalia collab. Not only is Bruno a big name he's also coming straight off a different big collaboration hit. The song is great and Rose is my favorite BP member but yeah let's avoid this comparison While Bruno's name definitely helped the song globally, it's important to note that no other BP member has had an instant skyrocketing to the top of Korean charts with their solos like Rose did with this one, except for Jennie in 2018. Plus she's never had a hit as big as Jennie with SOLO or Jisoo with Flower in Korea, so this is really big for her. Lisa was always a non-factor individually in Korea so there's that.
Nefertiti0 Posted October 20 Posted October 20 (edited) Day 2 #2(+1) Global — 10,187,478 #5(+6) US — 1,471,877 #1(+3) Canada — 309,048 #2(+16) Australia — 279,407 Edited October 20 by Nefertiti0 2 1
State of Grace. Posted October 20 Posted October 20 Oh Smashé the global star that you are. I didn't expect this level of smashery. Rosie better serve a Sour / Short n' Sweet 1
Prismee Posted October 20 Posted October 20 I've always wished for a K-pop star to become a new MPG and I feel like the moment is here
kellebrity98 Posted October 20 Author Posted October 20 Spotify: #1 Hong Kong #1 Singapore #1 Taiwan #1 (+1) Malaysia #1 (+3) Canada #2 South Korea #2 (+16) Australia #2 (+1) Worldwide #2 (+2) Vietnam #2 (+3) Philippines #2 (+18) New Zealand #5 (+1) Thailand #5 (+6) United States #7 (+36) Indonesia #11 (+31) Austria #12 (+16) United Kingdom #14 (+22) Switzerland #15 (+26) Germany #16 (=) Brazil #12 (+14) Peru #21 (+18) Portugal #33 (+23) Japan #48 (+10) Netherlands #37 (+21) Norway #33 (+27) Chile #24 (+36) Turkey #41 (+21) Belgium #44 (+21) France #36 (+29) Poland #45 (+28) Ireland #45 (+28) Sweden #49 (+127) India #54 (+33) Mexico #50 (+39) Colombia #79 (+43) Spain #146 (NE) Italy #193 (NE) Argentina
KOMH Posted October 20 Posted October 20 Just as I thought, Apt is now cannibalising "Die with a Smile" in its main markets. Oh Godsé
BIAATCH Posted October 20 Posted October 20 I cant imagine the update when this get the TTH cover and #1 placement
Recommended Posts