Pikachoo Posted October 17, 2024 Posted October 17, 2024 you know what ill be honest now that he's passed away, every celebrity is coming out of the woodwork saying "im speechless my heart is broken you were so kind liam rip" even his former bandmates. well im sorry but where were all these people when Liam needed them the most? when he was at his lowest? where were they reaching out to him? now its all sharing pictures and Rita Ora not being able to finish singing her and Liam's song because she's in tears. well where were you Rita? how come I never read in the tabloids "Rita Ora is urging Liam to go to rehab". wel your tears are too late. so damn phony. he needed you when he was ALIVE 1 2 13
Bubble Tea Posted October 17, 2024 Posted October 17, 2024 3 minutes ago, Pikachoo said: how come I never read in the tabloids "Rita Ora is urging Liam to go to rehab" Because friendships and relationships aren't conducted via tabloid? You have no idea what was going on behind the scenes. Spoiler NO IDEA! 13
itsmee Posted October 17, 2024 Posted October 17, 2024 8 minutes ago, Pikachoo said: wtf? if she's talking about abuse that's one thing. why was she discussing what Liam thought of his bandmates? Exactly and she did that under a comment it was totally uncessary land her tone was very "girl I have so much messy tea jusst wait" no disrespect to victims of abuse but that's not the way to go about stuff even the whole writting the book was shady af My older brother had maniac depressive behaviours and was very mentally abusive towardss me not even in a million years I would write a book or post a tiktok exposing him I hate the stuff he did to me and he deserves to be held accountable but not in the world stage in front of millions of people as a humiliation ritual that type of stuff should only be reserved to proper vile human beings like extremely violent ones or child abusers/grapists
Pikachoo Posted October 17, 2024 Posted October 17, 2024 2 minutes ago, Tropical said: Because friendships and relationships aren't conducted via tabloid? You have no idea what was going on behind the scenes. Hide contents NO IDEA! I'm not targeting Rita in particular. but even someone like Zayn, who hasn't spoken to Liam in years. now he's saying "i love you my brother i wish i can hug you". well guess what, you had years to call him up and give him a hug. it shouldn't take death to finally show compassion to someone. 2 3
Abracadabra Posted October 17, 2024 Posted October 17, 2024 7 minutes ago, Pikachoo said: you know what ill be honest now that he's passed away, every celebrity is coming out of the woodwork saying "im speechless my heart is broken you were so kind liam rip" even his former bandmates. well im sorry but where were all these people when Liam needed them the most? when he was at his lowest? where were they reaching out to him? now its all sharing pictures and Rita Ora not being able to finish singing her and Liam's song because she's in tears. well where were you Rita? how come I never read in the tabloids "Rita Ora is urging Liam to go to rehab". wel your tears are too late. so damn phony. he needed you when he was ALIVE well to be fair... how would we know if anybody has reached out to him? I'm more than sure than certain other artists and 1D members reached out to him at some point. why would it even be reported in the tabloids that rita ora called up liam payne unless somebody told them? 1
ChrisTheLoner Posted October 17, 2024 Posted October 17, 2024 2 hours ago, Almodusa said: 1 hour ago, Almodusa said: Tearing up after reading both of these heartfelt tributes
KatyPrismSpirit Posted October 17, 2024 Posted October 17, 2024 9 minutes ago, Pikachoo said: you know what ill be honest now that he's passed away, every celebrity is coming out of the woodwork saying "im speechless my heart is broken you were so kind liam rip" even his former bandmates. well im sorry but where were all these people when Liam needed them the most? when he was at his lowest? where were they reaching out to him? now its all sharing pictures and Rita Ora not being able to finish singing her and Liam's song because she's in tears. well where were you Rita? how come I never read in the tabloids "Rita Ora is urging Liam to go to rehab". wel your tears are too late. so damn phony. he needed you when he was ALIVE This way of thought is so screwed. Every person on the face of this Earth lives their own life? And has their own struggles. To assume they didn't do enough to prevent his death is extremely unfair. Especially since they might have not known how urgent his situation was. Be a little bit more empathetic perhaps 2
ATRL Moderator MissedTheTrain Posted October 17, 2024 ATRL Moderator Posted October 17, 2024 Seeing the others boys' statements has made this hit even harder Like it's such a gut punch to my younger self who loved them 2
Exzime. Posted October 17, 2024 Posted October 17, 2024 6 minutes ago, Pikachoo said: you know what ill be honest now that he's passed away, every celebrity is coming out of the woodwork saying "im speechless my heart is broken you were so kind liam rip" even his former bandmates. well im sorry but where were all these people when Liam needed them the most? when he was at his lowest? where were they reaching out to him? now its all sharing pictures and Rita Ora not being able to finish singing her and Liam's song because she's in tears. well where were you Rita? how come I never read in the tabloids "Rita Ora is urging Liam to go to rehab". wel your tears are too late. so damn phony. he needed you when he was ALIVE Lets not do this. There are complexities in relationships, some people want to be left alone. Some people do not want to interject someone's life. Especially as grown adults. It's unrealistic. 4
Abracadabra Posted October 17, 2024 Posted October 17, 2024 8 minutes ago, Pikachoo said: even someone like Zayn, who hasn't spoken to Liam in years. now he's saying "i love you my brother i wish i can hug you". well guess what, you had years to call him up and give him a hug. it shouldn't take death to finally show compassion to someone. Liam said that Zayn had reached out to him during his hardest times so they obviously have been in touch 5
KingWitch Posted October 17, 2024 Posted October 17, 2024 Yeah Harry's statement is just very impersonal, i have a feeling all the hate Liam got is about to shift towards him because the internet never learns 3 1
imabadkid Posted October 17, 2024 Posted October 17, 2024 11 minutes ago, Pikachoo said: I'm not targeting Rita in particular. but even someone like Zayn, who hasn't spoken to Liam in years. now he's saying "i love you my brother i wish i can hug you". well guess what, you had years to call him up and give him a hug. it shouldn't take death to finally show compassion to someone. Tbh no one knows their relationships... obviously their lives went in different directions post 1D but let's not pretend to know the true nature of their relationships. They experienced something truly special together, that doesn't go away... not saying they were all best friends but they all had unique relationships with each other.
gatito Posted October 17, 2024 Posted October 17, 2024 1 minute ago, KingWitch said: Yeah Harry's statement is just very impersonal, i have a feeling all the hate Liam got is about to shift towards him because the internet never learns i believe their relationship was complicated or at least not as tight 2
Peak Now Posted October 17, 2024 Posted October 17, 2024 5 minutes ago, KingWitch said: Yeah Harry's statement is just very impersonal, i have a feeling all the hate Liam got is about to shift towards him because the internet never learns This was my first thought too...
babycomeround Posted October 17, 2024 Posted October 17, 2024 I actually can't believe this is real, it's sinking in after reading the other members tributes. 1D were such a part of pop culture. Truly devastating. 1
Puttanesca Posted October 17, 2024 Posted October 17, 2024 Okay reading the guys' statements broke me. I was never a big fan but they were a huge part of my generation's high school experience so this is just surreal. I couldn't imagine losing a friend or even someone I knew in high school at this age. What a tragedy 1
Ian B Posted October 17, 2024 Posted October 17, 2024 5 minutes ago, KingWitch said: Yeah Harry's statement is just very impersonal, i have a feeling all the hate Liam got is about to shift towards him because the internet never learns Harry and Liam's relationship was not as close as Louis/Niall's, his statement is correct and respectful. There is no reason to judge or compare ways of grieving 4 4
Talentonly Posted October 17, 2024 Posted October 17, 2024 10 minutes ago, KingWitch said: Yeah Harry's statement is just very impersonal, i have a feeling all the hate Liam got is about to shift towards him because the internet never learns This is ridiculous. Nobody needs to shift "hate" towards someone who's friend (no matter how close) has just died. Y'all need to really wake up to reality
ONOPKA Posted October 17, 2024 Posted October 17, 2024 Louis's statement is very touching especially the part about Bear 3
Taste of Honey Posted October 17, 2024 Posted October 17, 2024 13 minutes ago, KingWitch said: Yeah Harry's statement is just very impersonal, i have a feeling all the hate Liam got is about to shift towards him because the internet never learns I hope not. It wasn't necessarily the warmest, most glowing statement ever but nothing malicious in it.
Popular Post PoisonPill Posted October 17, 2024 Popular Post Posted October 17, 2024 35 minutes ago, Pikachoo said: you know what ill be honest now that he's passed away, every celebrity is coming out of the woodwork saying "im speechless my heart is broken you were so kind liam rip" even his former bandmates. well im sorry but where were all these people when Liam needed them the most? when he was at his lowest? where were they reaching out to him? now its all sharing pictures and Rita Ora not being able to finish singing her and Liam's song because she's in tears. well where were you Rita? how come I never read in the tabloids "Rita Ora is urging Liam to go to rehab". wel your tears are too late. so damn phony. he needed you when he was ALIVE Lord the parasociality When will ya'll grasp that a private relationship between two people who don't know you isn't performed publicly at all times for your approval? 17 1
Born to Run Posted October 17, 2024 Posted October 17, 2024 53 minutes ago, itsmee said: I don't like that Maya girl and before you jump on my throat she wasnt just telling her story as a victim of abuse she was commenting on insta sharing "tea" with fans like saying Liam talked crap about all the one direction members while attending their tours she already knew the amount of hate he was getting with these type of comments she put more fuel in the fire and this small action shows me how she didnt have good intentions and wanted to see Liam suffering and just expose him to humiliate him and have some clout for herself i know at this day or age we LOVE the expose culture but its toxic af everyone wants to throe everyone under the bus for some attention and clickd and its disgusting MAYA HENRY LIED If you think abortion/axe thing actually happened, taken from a fan fiction book where she did NOT claim abuse while she happens to be the daughter of a big lawyer and Liam walked away with it, idk what to say! Mods, start banning these losers screaming abuser!! in this thread, thanks. 8 1 11
brraap Posted October 17, 2024 Posted October 17, 2024 He seemed very self aware and was on the road to recovery. It's a shame there was a second witch hunt starting against him that he didn't think he could handle. 3
Recommended Posts