charts discussion 'Brat and it's completely different...' debuts with 24,6M streams

[Hair]

Amazing numbers tbh 

[Contessa]

Charting SexCEx-Flop 

[LVP]

The best handled era this year

[vuelve88]

Impressive for a side project 

 

[dussel_06]

She's the ultimate gay icon of our generation I guess. 

[commander]

She's truly the cultural icon of 2024 

[Hurem]

If Billie doesn't win AOTY, Charli needs to get it  

[Bartender]

She deserves this and more

[ericcartman]

Now that's a side project 

 

Who had the biggest debut for a remix album previously?

Edited October 12 by ericcartman

[Gelato]

but a certain fanbase told me only people in an online bubble listened to her?

[professor2000]

[Europe]

16 minutes ago, Gelato said:

but a certain fanbase told me only people in an online bubble listened to her?

Are we going to pretend that her involving two big A listers didn't have a lot to do with this? Only the Billie and Ariana remix made it to the top 20 as well.

 

Says it all.

[State of Grace.]

Just now, Europe said:

Are we going to pretend that her involving two big A listers didn't have a lot to do with this? Only the Billie and Ariana remix made it to the top 20 as well.

 

Says it all.

The point is that CLEARLY a lot of people outside of stan twitter have heard the album. Anybody still denying this fact is a blind hater.

[Sazare]

#127: I might say something stupid Remix — 1.532M
 

Not this turd being the fourth-highest  I assume it's because it's immediately preceded by the Ariana remix but still

[Cain]

2 minutes ago, Europe said:

Are we going to pretend that her involving two big A listers didn't have a lot to do with this? Only the Billie and Ariana remix made it to the top 20 as well.

 

Says it all.

If those songs did the same amount of streams as the other ones the remix album would still open with 19M streams?? Says it all

[State of Grace.]

22 minutes ago, ericcartman said:

Now that's a side project 

 

Who had the biggest debut for a remix album previously?

According to chart accounts on twitter, Dawn of Chromatica (8.3M) and Club Future Nostalgia (2.3M) were the two highest debuts.

[Arrows]

18 minutes ago, Gelato said:

but a certain fanbase told me only people in an online bubble listened to her?

The fanbase of the artist whose album received 12 times as many streams as this? Compared to that, pretty much anything is a online bubble

 

Ot: Super deserved

[Sazare]

10 minutes ago, Cain said:

If those songs did the same amount of streams as the other ones the remix album would still open with 19M streams?? Says it all

I mean not entirely. Do we really think, for example, that any of Gracie Abrams' songs that don't feature taylor would be have anywhere near the same number of plays without the taylor song on her album? There's a reason artists feature bigger names on their albums — it draws in broader listenership in general.

Edited October 12 by Sazare

[Cain]

1 minute ago, Sazare said:

I mean not entirely. Do we really think, for example, that any of Maggie Abrams' songs that don't feature taylor would be have anywhere near the same number of plays without the taylor song on her album? There's a reason artists feature bigger names on their albums — it draws in broader listenership in general.

This is true, but to say the Brat era has been carried by these features is laughable. The album and term were already mega viral before Billie hopped on (in fact it's the only reason she hopped on it in the first place) and 360 and Apple were viral hits

[Doctor Dick]

56 minutes ago, vuelve88 said:

Impressive for a side project 

 

It's funny how Charli can't score a single solo Top 10 without Billie or Ariana and this whole album is not even solo at all yet she's getting a pass when she's basically reliant on a collab to get a huge debut. 

[Hitchhiker]

[truthteller]

LOVE LIVE BRAT ERA

[unclefloprry]

29 minutes ago, Cain said:

This is true, but to say the Brat era has been carried by these features is laughable. The album and term were already mega viral before Billie hopped on (in fact it's the only reason she hopped on it in the first place) and 360 and Apple were viral hits

Viral but nobody is streaming the music. 

Apple with +2M of videos on tiktok and doing Illusion numbers 

[vuelve88]

23 minutes ago, Doctor Dick said:

It's funny how Charli can't score a single solo Top 10 without Billie or Ariana and this whole album is not even solo at all yet she's getting a pass when she's basically reliant on a collab to get a huge debut. 

That's really funny  I love your sense of humor 

 

[Doctor Dick]

9 minutes ago, vuelve88 said:

That's really funny  I love your sense of humor 

 

Gaga had a huge string of solo smashes from 2009-13 and again hit the top 10 solo in 2016 before "relying" on collabs. Gaga also had a Top 5 debut with a solo song in 2020. 

 

The only solo Top 10 Charli has is from 10 years ago and it's attached to a movie (which is funny considering the excuses some people have for Gaga's hit soundtracks).