poll Biggest MPG bomb of the year: JLo vs. Katy vs. Gaga

[Cry]

11 minutes ago, halcyonday said:

Gaga by far.

 

Single = FLOPPED

Album = TANKED

Movie = PANNED

Now how is "single = FLOPPED" when DWAS is bigger than the whole 666 album?

[halcyonday]

4 minutes ago, Cry said:

Now how is "single = FLOPPED" when DWAS is bigger than the whole 666 album?

Happy Mistake, a heavily promoted single with Spotify playlisting, payola on TTH AND a TV live performance, BOMBED

[ZacXCX]

This thread really made me chuckle. The incoherence of some posts, the jumping through hoops to try to make a point, the morale police fights starting right away on page one, Jennifer Lopez. Never change, ATRL.

 

 

While regular people don't give a sh*t about 90% of the things mentioned here, Ga is still more recognized for her vocal talent/versatility and is met with more respect overall, which gives her the best platform of the 3. And her name is on DWAS even if the solo hit people don't want it to be. Maybe JLo should've collabed with Bruno Mars, since it's all it takes.

Edited October 5 by ZacXCX

[Erreur2 La Nature]

Objectively JLO bombed much harder than them. Though Katy's the one whose image is truly suffering right now.

[Gelato]

katy obviously. she hasn't had a song as big as DWAS in over a decade so the mental gymnastics that need to be performed to claim it's gaga are insane

[Yudelkis]

 

J.Legend

>>>>>

Lady Perry

 

 

 

[Mandalay]

Voted for J.Lo because she was really hated by the GP earlier this year.

 

Katy still has a tour doing well, right?

 

Gaga is doing a lot better than both. 

[PMM]

when it comes to fans: J.lo - at least GP were talking about her
when it comes to ATRL: Gaga
when it comes to GP: Katy - GP don't know she released another album after Witness

[Stunnah]

57 minutes ago, Gelato said:

katy obviously. she hasn't had a song as big as DWAS in over a decade so the mental gymnastics that need to be performed to claim it's gaga are insane

[DiabeticGrandpa]

Gaga bombed with her acting and music career back to back. 
 

 

[Ivan_brit]

Jlo year was a complete disaster 

[Cry]

2 hours ago, halcyonday said:

Happy Mistake, a heavily promoted single with Spotify playlisting, payola on TTH AND a TV live performance, BOMBED

Album bomb + single bomb + smash single > album bomb + singleS bomb

 

OT : I fear that the correct answer is Katy Perry.

[spree]

how can a 200M investment be less of a bomb than a 1-2M album rollout?

[dumbsparce]

Gaga's was the most unexcpected but she also has the biggest chance at a rebound.mp3 One second she's a flop, suddenly the hit will be her 

[Daglazzo]

How stupid you should be to compare studio albums to the cover side project album and Todd's movie?  

[Chris]

No offense to JLO, but who really asked for that musical?

[Sannie]

Katy has spent millions and is traveling around the world to beg people to listen to and buy her album and nobody is listening. The entire reason Katy Kats have to desperately cling onto others is to try and shield themselves from the colossal bombing that Katy was and is still going through. And the fact that Katy submitted her music to the Grammys shows just how out of touch and delusional she is. She redefined what it means to flop and ruined her entire career.  

[Janet]

7 hours ago, Digitalism said:

Clearly Gaga

Because Katy was only a stan thing. The GP didin't even care she released 

 

This level of delusion is crazy 

[Sannie]

2 hours ago, spree said:

how can a 200M investment be less of a bomb than a 1-2M album rollout?

Quick, do you think Gaga paid for Joker?

 

Gaga was paid more for Joker than Katy will make from 143. In fact, it's become obvious with all the promo Katy will lose more money than Gaga made with Joker.  

Edited October 5 by Sannie

[halcyonday]

2 minutes ago, Sannie said:

Quick, do you think Gaga paid for Joker?

 

Gaga was paid more for Joker than Katy will make from 143. In fact, it's become obvious with all the promo Katy will lose more money than Gaga made with Joker.  

 

[Sannie]

6 hours ago, halcyonday said:

Happy Mistake, a heavily promoted single with Spotify playlisting, payola on TTH AND a TV live performance, BOMBED

Your avatar is  of one of Several of Katy's massive promo slots Katy paid for in order to try and get people to pay attention to her new album… and it didn't work even in the country the performance happened in.  The Happy Mistakes performance received more attention than anything Katy did this era  and went viral for Gaga sounding so good. 
 

And it's not Gaga's fault Spotify won't promote Katy dddd. Not even Katy's label wants to invest in her. 
 

no amount of smiling and kii'ing through the pain is going to change that after years of y'all claiming Katy dying her hair and showing her boobs would propel her to the top, she bombed by doing both.  And bombed in such a way that she changed the musical landscape for every other girl who never has to worry about bombing again because it won't come close to what Katy did.

Edited October 5 by Sannie

[Xtina23]

Gaga's movie and album is setting studio back MILLIONS of dollars!!!

 

She wins the BIGGEST ATOMIC BOMB OF 2024!!!

 

7 hours ago, Rama said:

The one that will forever be attached to a sexual abuser

 

7 hours ago, Stunnah said:

Sorry. You will have to be more specific. 

 

 

Maybe these images courtesy of the public search engine, Google, can help refresh @Rama's memory.

 

 

 

You're welcome.

xoxox

[halcyonday]

1 minute ago, Sannie said:

YThe Happy Mistakes performance received more attention than anything Katy did this era  and went viral for Gaga sounding so good. 

Happy Mistake

604 832

-144 477

 

VIRAL SMASHA WITH HUGE ATTENTION

 

[Escape]

Since when is JLO a MPG?

[prézli]

50 minutes ago, Sannie said:

Katy has spent millions and is traveling around the world to beg people to listen to and buy her album and nobody is listening.

Same with JLo? She shot 2 movies both paid by herself and her album flopped.