base talk More RAW Talent: Beyoncé or Lady Gaga?

[Big Bad Wolf]

6 minutes ago, ICLDXU4HS said:

@Big Bad Wolf What do you think about Kamala Harris?

She's about to end Donald Trump that's all I know mama 

[Freaky Prince]

Beyonce is a better singer (technically, I guess) and dancer, but Gaga can do both of those, plus write, play the piano and act, so I guess Gaga.

But, they are both the best live entertainers among mainstream female pop stars.

[QueenB]

1 hour ago, Infatuation_Junkie said:

If all the power went out in the arena, gaga could still wow with just a piano and vocals. Beyonce, not so much. No shade, love them both, but let's be real. 

 

 

Not to mention she opened her latest tour with a ballad section.

[ICLDXU4HS]

2 minutes ago, Big Bad Wolf said:

She's about to end Donald Trump that's all I know mama 

TF, you were supposed to drag her for me before you're gone.

 

[JonginBey]

We are SO back.

 

[MidnightsAtPeace]

Gaga: Singer (Vocalist), Songwriter, Composer, Producer, Dancer, Performer, Actress, Multi instrumentalist (professional pianist)

 

Beyoncé: Singer (Vocalist), Composer, Producer, Dancer, Performer 

[Big Bad Wolf]

4 minutes ago, ICLDXU4HS said:

TF, you were supposed to drag her for me before you're gone.

 

Absolutely not.

 

VOTE KAMALA HARRIS 2024!

[swissman]

1 hour ago, Big Bad Wolf said:

But why can't Beyonce write a song without a minimum of 12 people present in the room with her? Based on credentials that is

She can and has.

 

Jumpin' Jumpin' was written by her alone, with writing credits added to the two people who made the beat of the song. Indepedent Women was written by herself with writing credits going to the producers as well.

 

Choosing to write more with larger groups doesn't mean she cannot, and factually, doesn't prove so either.

[Big Bad Wolf]

Just now, swissman said:

She can and has.

 

Jumpin' Jumpin' was written by her alone, with writing credits added to the two people who made the beat of the song. Indepedent Women was written by herself with writing credits going to the producers as well.

 

Choosing to write more with larger groups doesn't mean she cannot, and factually, doesn't prove so either.

Shut up. Nobody was talking to you. Beyonce is a fraud. And you're an embarrassing joke defending her lack of talent. You should be ashamed of stanning someone who was present while Diddy drugged and raped men and women. Seek help. 

[CherryBay]

RAW Talent:

- Can sing - Bey

- Can dance - Bey

- Can write music (solo or with 1 other collaborator) - Gaga I guess

- Can create exciting visuals - Bey

- Can assemble exciting looks and costumes - Bey

[RihannaLoverrr]

Beyoncé 

[LittleStarmen]

Gaga has written songs that dont require 18 writers

Edited September 30 by LittleStarmen

[Shimenawa]

Both talented

 

Beyoncé is better dancer and vocalist and GaGa better musician/songwriter/actress

 

Beyoncé is more technically perfect and GaGa more messy & raw

 

I'd say GaGa has more diverse talents while Beyoncé is better at certain things

 

Edited September 30 by Shimenawa

[Big Bad Wolf]

How am I still not banned ddddd

[noodlelymph]

This is SUCH a dumb thread/comparison (but I do this all the time for MJ vs Prince lmao).
 

Beyonce is objectively a better vocalist, dancer, and overall entertainer and Gaga is objectively a better overall musician, actor, songwriter, and she plays the piano well.

 

hmmm put Gaga alone in a room with instruments and production software and she'll come up with something wayyyy better than Beyonce so I'm going with her. 

[Pinkbutterflies]

6 minutes ago, Big Bad Wolf said:

How am I still not banned ddddd

Pls don't go. You're the only truth speaker on here 

[toast]

The one I like more

[Anvarie]

People saying Gaga is a better musician/artist but look at her musical output for the last 10 years and compare it to Beyoncé. They have access to the same resources, clearly Beyoncé is producing much more vocally dynamic, visually creative, and engaging albums 

[Big Bad Wolf]

9 minutes ago, Pinkbutterflies said:

Pls don't go. You're the only truth speaker on here 

Girl, it's set in stone 

[ScorpiosGroove]

op randomly going on a nicki type coke rant 

[JoeAg]

so they're both divinely talented, I'll start there

 

as someone who was classically trained (double bass, orchestra nerd throughout grade school) I find I am more consistently impressed by Gaga's piano playing than any other talent here. but that's just what I'm IMPRESSED most by. I voted Gaga but now that I think deeper about it I'd genuinely say that they're equally talented. my upbringing with listening to music, writing music, playing music, and learning all about music was founded on principles of open-mindedness and progressiveness. both of these women encapsulate that ethos in ways that make them stand far above many of the rest 

[fememeist]

59 minutes ago, Pinkbutterflies said:

Pls don't go. You're the only truth speaker on here 

You can speak your truth too, no one's stopping you! As a matter of fact please do…  this forum will be a much better place without you if you do.

[Pheromosa]

2 hours ago, Big Bad Wolf said:

How am I still not banned ddddd

 

 

[Weld_E]

If dancing is one of Gaga's talents, then acting is one of Beys.

 

And these arbitrary claims like of 'Put them in a room  with a mic, but give Gaga instruments and she will prevail!!!' Like?? Give them both a mic and put them on stage—we all know who will prevail.

 

As for Gaga's songwriting, what good is it if her output consistently falls short? If we're talking about critical success, Beyoncé's albums have demolished Gaga's since Self-Titled."

 

[Kristie Kuwa]

Gaga is better at theatre, I leave it at that